There has to be video somewhere or else how could it be overturned by the ref?
Rutgers No. 4 Field Hockey Hosts Indiana Friday, No. 1 Northwestern Sunday
- Thread starter Tango Two
- Start date
Good point. Let's get a look at it & settle this. Meredith & Pat Hobbs should have access to it as well as the Big. Question--how does a video pick up the sound of a whistle?
I don't think it is from the whistle I believe it is when she first touches the ball; it is right at 8 seconds so I don't think they should have overturned it
The other stupid rule is the challenge rule in a shootout if you used your challeneges you can't challenge!! very stupid
So this is the fall sport I actually coach now (and have been lucky in the past few years to win state titles). The timing is very, very close on the 8 seconds. Its a tough rule that is has to cross the line before 8 seconds and not just be in the air (honestly a rule that puts officials in a really bad spot).
At the high school level it is 10 seconds and the horn sounds when time expires.
I would like to see their clock paired up with the actual start of the play.
I ran my clock a few times and each time it came out right around 7.8 seconds, but the video has us already in motion. It is super close.
At the high school level it is 10 seconds and the horn sounds when time expires.
I would like to see their clock paired up with the actual start of the play.
I ran my clock a few times and each time it came out right around 7.8 seconds, but the video has us already in motion. It is super close.
I will take NUTS at his word that the clock starts when the ref blows the whistle and not when the player first touches the ball.
I stopped the video that is linked in this thread at the 8 second mark, and the ball is in the air but NOT across the goal line. If anything, that video probably started a split second after the whistle blew, as the video starts when our player had just touched the ball.
From this, I conclude that the goal was properly disallowed.
I stopped the video that is linked in this thread at the 8 second mark, and the ball is in the air but NOT across the goal line. If anything, that video probably started a split second after the whistle blew, as the video starts when our player had just touched the ball.
From this, I conclude that the goal was properly disallowed.
Just read the rule and yes it is from the time that the whistle blows to start the play. There should be a clock on the goal like they have in BB. I imagine there is a split second that it take the official to stop the clock once the ball crossed the line.
So, did anyone time the video yet? Stuff I saw said it went over 8 seconds.. not sure how that could be unless they started counting before she began her shot... which could happen.. just don't have the video to time it myself
I shall assume that Rutgers people have internally confirmed this since I have not seen a formal complaint to the Big Ten. Guess it doesn't matter unless the women make a nice comeback here. But you have to know NW securing the championship.. perhaps wrongly.. has to have affected the team.
I shall assume that Rutgers people have internally confirmed this since I have not seen a formal complaint to the Big Ten. Guess it doesn't matter unless the women make a nice comeback here. But you have to know NW securing the championship.. perhaps wrongly.. has to have affected the team.
Similar threads
