ADVERTISEMENT

Coaching Carousel 2025

this is a really good hire for them if true

and another coach coming in with more success and better track record than pike
yes Im shocked he wasnt hired before somewhere...honestly i wonder if Iowa is going after him because its a better job than Minnesota but they likely DeVries and MacCollum higher on their list

I think the schools is in the Northeast suffer a bit because there really are not a big wealth of hot coaches to tap into as most of the schools are very low level in the maac, northeast, patriot, ivy, america east
 
yes Im shocked he wasnt hired before somewhere...honestly i wonder if Iowa is going after him because its a better job than Minnesota but they likely DeVries and MacCollum higher on their list

I think the schools is in the Northeast suffer a bit because there really are not a big wealth of hot coaches to tap into as most of the schools are very low level in the maac, northeast, patriot, ivy, america east
i would be surprised if DeVries left West Virginia

MacCollum makes more sense for Iowa

I think if we were in this coaching cycle we would have a really good chance at Richard Pitino JR but I imagine he lands at Villanova if they are mutually interested or perhaps Providence if they move on from Kim English
 
DeVries to Indiana!
when i made the list of coaches i would take Pike over they included Ben Johnson at Minnesota and Mike Woodson at Indiana and I had Pike around 14-15 best case scenario

they have since been replaced by two coaches who are DEFINITIVELY superior to him from a prior track record standpoint

guess hes more like 16-18 territory right now...
 
interesting..wonder what Iowa does now
if they bring in maccollum which seems like the natural fit i would feel pretty comfortable pegging rutgers in at 18 in next years preseason poll without needing to see the portal transfers
 
if they bring in maccollum which seems like the natural fit i would feel pretty comfortable pegging rutgers in at 18 in next years preseason poll without needing to see the portal transfers
well there is always the mess that is Penn State and if Collins bolts to Nova but yeah its going to be very very ugly around here next year
 
if they bring in maccollum which seems like the natural fit i would feel pretty comfortable pegging rutgers in at 18 in next years preseason poll without needing to see the portal transfers
You do realize that irregardless of your hypothetical coaching rankings, Iowa, Minnesota, Northwestern, Nebraska and Penn State all rank behind RU in terms of ability to recruit talent from a pool of players??

We have more access to talent in our region AND, the ability to offer an opportunity in a unique marketplace (Close to NYC etc)

Recruiting to Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska Northwestern and Penn State etc have extreme or unique limitations. This group of schools is more likely to remain in the 11 to 18 range, more than RU does. All RU needs to do is get away from the sham of Adidas contract that we got pulled into and stay aligned to Nike.

The next group above these 5 is a little gray, but it really depends on how Maryland sustains itself (Under Armour is on the verge of bankruptcy) and RU and USC have to decide how much they want to win. USC has more resources, but may choose to stay focused on football.
 
when i made the list of coaches i would take Pike over they included Ben Johnson at Minnesota and Mike Woodson at Indiana and I had Pike around 14-15 best case scenario

they have since been replaced by two coaches who are DEFINITIVELY superior to him from a prior track record standpoint

guess hes more like 16-18 territory right now...
Let’s not downplay how awesome Pike was at Stony Brook. He was once this type of guy too. Devries is awesome though. Better suited for todays environment
 
well there is always the mess that is Penn State and if Collins bolts to Nova but yeah its going to be very very ugly around here next year
Penn State gives 0% you know whats about basketball which is a shame because they are in the Ohio State Michigan territory from an NIL perspective and could easily have a competitive basketball team by accident if they wanted to but they probably put money into wrestling and other things instead

Northwestern yes that is a job that will also go down the tubes if Collins leaves but the fact were even having a conversation about being in that territory going into year TEN of Pike is ALARMING
 
Let’s not downplay how awesome Pike was at Stony Brook. He was once this type of guy too. Devries is awesome though. Better suited for todays environment
Pikiell made ONE NCAA tournament at Stony Brook

If anything the fact he could not close the deal in a tournament format any of the other 5 years he finished 1st or 2nd in the regular season is a further indictment on him
 
You do realize that irregardless of your hypothetical coaching rankings, Iowa, Minnesota, Northwestern, Nebraska and Penn State all rank behind RU in terms of ability to recruit talent from a pool of players??

We have more access to talent in our region AND, the ability to offer an opportunity in a unique marketplace (Close to NYC etc)

Recruiting to Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska Northwestern and Penn State etc have extreme or unique limitations. This group of schools is more likely to remain in the 11 to 18 range, more than RU does. All RU needs to do is get away from the sham of Adidas contract that we got pulled into and stay aligned to Nike.

The next group above these 5 is a little gray, but it really depends on how Maryland sustains itself (Under Armour is on the verge of bankruptcy) and RU and USC have to decide how much they want to win. USC has more resources, but may choose to stay focused on football.
Iowa is a class above us just from a tradition standpoint

I will play along that we are in the Minnesota, Northwestern, Nebraska, Penn State and I would replace Iowa with Washington group

being in the bottom 5 of any list is not good though
 
Pikiell made ONE NCAA tournament at Stony Brook

If anything the fact he could not close the deal in a tournament format any of the other 5 years he finished 1st or 2nd in the regular season is a further indictment on him
this...those years concern me when you put together his futility in the Big 10 tournament
 
  • Like
Reactions: scottsdaleal
You do realize that irregardless of your hypothetical coaching rankings, Iowa, Minnesota, Northwestern, Nebraska and Penn State all rank behind RU in terms of ability to recruit talent from a pool of players??

We have more access to talent in our region AND, the ability to offer an opportunity in a unique marketplace (Close to NYC etc)

Recruiting to Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska Northwestern and Penn State etc have extreme or unique limitations. This group of schools is more likely to remain in the 11 to 18 range, more than RU does. All RU needs to do is get away from the sham of Adidas contract that we got pulled into and stay aligned to Nike.

The next group above these 5 is a little gray, but it really depends on how Maryland sustains itself (Under Armour is on the verge of bankruptcy) and RU and USC have to decide how much they want to win. USC has more resources, but may choose to stay focused on football.
this isnt true....rutgers has never been a more attractive job than Iowa. We are basically in the same boat with the bottom 5

please do not even bring Maryland into this conversation
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUbbFannn
interesting..wonder what Iowa does now
Ben McCollum is a logical target with his ties to the state of Iowa
He was born in Iowa City and played North Iowa Area Community College..

But because his one year at Drake which also was his first year at the Division I level might
keep him from being a top candidate despite his great year at Drake and his 394–91 Division II
coaching record
 
Pikiell made ONE NCAA tournament at Stony Brook

If anything the fact he could not close the deal in a tournament format any of the other 5 years he finished 1st or 2nd in the regular season is a further indictment on him
He had incredibly good seasons at Stony Brook of all places. Unprecedented success there, both from before they had him til today. If you’re gonna say that then what’s so good about 0 tournament wins Devries? Such a poor way to evaluate. Multiple top 100 finishes in KenPom at Stony Brook, including a top 60 finish. The best they’ve done since is 168. We can criticize his current shortcomings, performance but putting weight on conference tournament wins is a dishonest, unfair reevaluation. He was a great coach who is behind the times in the NIL era.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shields
He had incredibly good seasons at Stony Brook of all places. Unprecedented success there, both from before they had him til today. If you’re gonna say that then what’s so good about 0 tournament wins Devries? Such a poor way to evaluate. Multiple top 100 finishes in KenPom at Stony Brook, including a top 60 finish. The best they’ve done since is 168. We can criticize his current shortcomings, performance but putting weight on conference tournament wins is a dishonest, unfair reevaluation. He was a great coach who is behind the times in the NIL era.
10 years but only 1 ncaa appearance and massive failure in those conference tourneys when it mattered
 
I am seeing Indiana promised $7 million in NIL for DeVries where Iowa was offering half if that

Iowa fans sound bummed as they were positive they were getting him. Now onto MacCollum
 
Question: When people say we need a "name head coach" or a coach "with a track record of winning at the P4 level" - that doesn't mean someone like Will Wade, right? Since he's currently at McNeese State?
Or the Drake coach Ben McCollum?
Darian DeVries only spent 1 season at P4 West Virginia (and didn't make the tournament - if Pike doesn't get credit then neither should he?) after only coaching at Drake.

I don't follow other HCs much so just trying to make sure I'm following on who "should" be coaching Rutgers.
 
Question: When people say we need a "name head coach" or a coach "with a track record of winning at the P4 level" - that doesn't mean someone like Will Wade, right? Since he's currently at McNeese State?
Or the Drake coach Ben McCollum?
Darian DeVries only spent 1 season at P4 West Virginia (and didn't make the tournament - if Pike doesn't get credit then neither should he?) after only coaching at Drake.

I don't follow other HCs much so just trying to make sure I'm following on who "should" be coaching Rutgers.
Will Wade has success at the P4 level, the others wouldn't come anyway, unless RU suddenly makes a big jump in NIL promises.
 
Will Wade has success at the P4 level, the others wouldn't come anyway, unless RU suddenly makes a big jump in NIL promises.

Oh I see.

I wasn't really thinking about "would they come here".
More so that if someone says "we need a name coach. someone with a P4 track record" they wouldn't want those other guys.
 
Oh I see.

I wasn't really thinking about "would they come here".
More so that if someone says "we need a name coach. someone with a P4 track record" they wouldn't want those other guys.
I might be looking from a different angle than what the conversation was you were part of. Without a strong NIL commitment a name may be the only way RU can bring in the talent needed. However, the names are only going to want the NIL commitment.
 
Question: When people say we need a "name head coach" or a coach "with a track record of winning at the P4 level" - that doesn't mean someone like Will Wade, right? Since he's currently at McNeese State?
Or the Drake coach Ben McCollum?
Darian DeVries only spent 1 season at P4 West Virginia (and didn't make the tournament - if Pike doesn't get credit then neither should he?) after only coaching at Drake.

I don't follow other HCs much so just trying to make sure I'm following on who "should" be coaching Rutgers.
Bac and the others picking coaches and the rest are just full of shyt. How do we know that ? Their shyt smell blows with the wind like their opinions. Imagine depending on these guys for anything. No consistency, little real loyalty, they will fire coaches yearly and they fawn over the flavor of the day.
 
Fordham fired men’s basketball coach Keith Urgo today
When Kyle Neptune went to Villanova Ugo moved up from his assistant to be the Ram's HC
>some possible names for the job include Van Macon (St. John’s), Rob Jones (Norfolk State), James Jones (Yale), Mike Hopkins (former Washington coach), Kimani Young (UConn), Brandin Knight (Rutgers) and Bruiser Flint (Arkansas)<
note: When Neptune left Fordham 3 years ago Brandin's name was mentioned as a possible replacement.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamzagoria/2025/03/20/ncaa-coaching-carousel-fordham-fires-keith-urgo/
 
Question: When people say we need a "name head coach" or a coach "with a track record of winning at the P4 level" - that doesn't mean someone like Will Wade, right? Since he's currently at McNeese State?
Or the Drake coach Ben McCollum?
Darian DeVries only spent 1 season at P4 West Virginia (and didn't make the tournament - if Pike doesn't get credit then neither should he?) after only coaching at Drake.

I don't follow other HCs much so just trying to make sure I'm following on who "should" be coaching Rutgers.

I can't speak for everyone, but when I say this I am saying that's what I would need in order to support firing Pikiell right now. It's basically something that isn't going to happen, but if we were actually willing and able to poach a high level coach then it would be a different situation.

Now, if Pikiell has another disappointing year or two and I really feel that his time here is ended, my standards for potential replacements would not be as high as that.

Also, Will Wade would absolutely count. It's "track record of winning at the P4 level". That doesn't imply he needs to be at the P4 level RIGHT NOW. He wasn't fired by LSU for lack of winning.
 
I can't speak for everyone, but when I say this I am saying that's what I would need in order to support firing Pikiell right now. It's basically something that isn't going to happen, but if we were actually willing and able to poach a high level coach then it would be a different situation.

Now, if Pikiell has another disappointing year or two and I really feel that his time here is ended, my standards for potential replacements would not be as high as that.

Also, Will Wade would absolutely count. It's "track record of winning at the P4 level". That doesn't imply he needs to be at the P4 level RIGHT NOW. He wasn't fired by LSU for lack of winning.
Will Wade would never consider coming here...but that point is moot now
 
Will Wade would never consider coming here...but that point is moot now

It is likely that no one who fits the criteria I would want in order to fire Pikiell now would come here. That’s why I would not want to fire Pikiell now even if the buyout were less onerous.
 
It is likely that no one who fits the criteria I would want in order to fire Pikiell now would come here. That’s why I would not want to fire Pikiell now even if the buyout were less onerous.
To be honest no one has ever been able to fit the criteria here. Pike was a total shot in the dark really but anyone would be better than Eddie..we aren't in that situation now
 
  • Like
Reactions: scottsdaleal
To be honest no one has ever been able to fit the criteria here. Pike was a total shot in the dark really but anyone would be better than Eddie..we aren't in that situation now
I think littlestpage was actually a hire of choice IIRC
 
  • Wow
Reactions: bac2therac
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT