It's all speculation but you can do a little deductive reasoning to get an answer. MSU is tough to recruit too, yet Mullen has done a decent job. It's tough to win in the SEC, yet Mullen has won.
Give Mullen the team Fludd inherited and 4 years to recruit, where do you think we would be right now.
Give Fludd the MSU program Mullen inherited and 4 years, does anyone think Fludd would have had the success Mullen had?
Fludd isn't a good coach, he had everything in place to atleast field a competitive team, in his 4th year he can't even do that.