Again. You are years removed from this process. Things are different now post covid and kids are choosing “lesser” schools left and right for a myriad of reasons. Plus schools that in the past you have talked crap about are harder to get into than schools you perceive to be better. My daughter has five friends alone that applied to Clemson and Rutgers. All 5 got it to Rutgers. 2 got into Clemson.
Yeah...what I'm not removed from is hiring people and no one is impressed by the schools these kids (or more likely their parents) are impressed by. Other than a scholarship or a very specific program, COVID or "experiencing" the south or midwest is pretty hilarious as a rationale.
No doubt it's harder to get into an OOS school...however it's not my perception, pretty much anyone who didn't go to Clemson or Moravian or whatnot is going to "perceive" Rutgers to be better.