Today could be the nadir of the Schiano era

[mdk01]

That is complete BS. In today’s Transfer Portal makes building talent takes a matter of months vs. years.
And if you look at Greg’s Year 4 recruiting class next season it’s a joke right now, ranking near the bottom of P5 Teams.

You conveniently omit the NIL advantage most P5 teams have over Rutgers

 

[Purple-Ed]

Can we schedule Wagner 12 times next year?

 

[NickRU714]

Ash hasn’t been here in years, does
Kansas and Illinois say the same about their previous coach. If we had won 9 games this year who would get the credit. If we don’t win 6 who will get the blame. It’s the same person win or lose, no excuses

Isn’t the common refrain:
“Flood only won because of the prior coaches recruits.”

Does that still apply?
Doubtful HC Ash is given credit for HC Schiano going 5-7 and making a bowl in Year 2.

 

[NickRU714]

You conveniently omit the NIL advantage most P5 teams have over Rutgers

I was lead to believe the number 1 selling point for HC Schiano was that only he understood NJ recruiting and could instantly turn around recruiting.

Now that isn’t the case? Perhaps for reasons outside his control - but regardless still the situation.

So does that mean he’s no longer what Rutgers needs?
We need to win through superior coaching and not recruiting - since “most” P5 teams have recruiting advantages even HC Schiano can’t overcome?

 

[shields]

Auburn is 5-6. What a team and they won by 24.

 

[mdk01]

I was lead to believe the number 1 selling point for HC Schiano was that only he understood NJ recruiting and could instantly turn around recruiting.

Now that isn’t the case? Perhaps for reasons outside his control - but regardless still the situation.

So does that mean he’s no longer what Rutgers needs?
We need to win through superior coaching and not recruiting - since “most” P5 teams have recruiting advantages even HC Schiano can’t overcome?

Schiano was hired before NIL, a fact you conveniently ignore. I'm not sure any coach can successfully play in the B1G East with the dollars Rutgers can throw around. Got any names?

 

[Section124]

Schiano was hired before NIL, a fact you conveniently ignore. I'm not sure any coach can successfully play in the B1G East with the dollars Rutgers can throw around. Got any names?

The Navy coach seems to do fine without NIL and resources. Every week I watch games and underdog teams seem to compete and have an offense. I wasn’t a fan of bringing back Greg but was OK with giving him a shot. Most people thought he changed. He did not. He’s still the same conservative micro manager. The game has passed him by and he doesn’t know what to do. You can see that in his eyes.

 

[NickRU714]

Schiano was hired before NIL, a fact you conveniently ignore. I'm not sure any coach can successfully play in the B1G East with the dollars Rutgers can throw around. Got any names?

Who's ignoring?
"Perhaps for reasons outside his control - but regardless still the situation."

It's not his fault - but that doesn't really matter. What matters is adapting (if necessary) to the new environment.
New plan could be do focusing on a coaching staff with a coaching background as opposed to prioritizing "recruiting".

Names isn't my job. That's for AD Hobbs.

If no coach can successfully play in the Big Ten - then we shut down the program?
Leave the Big Ten?
Not sure what that's supposed to mean.

 

[brgRC90]

Isn’t the common refrain:
“Flood only won because of the prior coaches recruits.”

Does that still apply?
Doubtful HC Ash is given credit for HC Schiano going 5-7 and making a bowl in Year 2.

You don't understand how it works in the Schiano Safe Space: if the team wins a game it's because Schiano has gotten better players. If the team loses it's because he "inherited the worst team in the history of football" and has bad players, even 3 years later. Schiano is NEVER to blame.

 

[brgRC90]

If no coach can successfully play in the Big Ten - then we shut down the program?
Leave the Big Ten?
Not sure what that's supposed to mean.

No coach can win at Rutgers except Schiano.* When he dies, which is when he'll leave, the program must fold. (*Note: this does not mean Schiano is actually winning.)