I just don't get this. His average kenpom ranking (including the rebuild years) was #77. This is below average but not close to the bottom of the P5 (and again it counts the rebuild as well). It's not like he had some resource advantage or was even at the average level in resources, the state of the program he inherited, etc. None of this squares with him being an "awful coach", "worst coach in P5", etc. Average to below average? Sure. Terrible? Just no.
It is possible to argue for him being fired without making these completely hyperbolic statements.
This is just nuts dude. You think those teams were talented at the P5 level? And to the extent they were, Pike identified and recruited those players!
Literally everyone got the COVID years, there are still COVID year players around this year, that argument is ridiculous.
Agreed - overall his tenure history doesn’t grade out as “terrible”. That said - if you parce out the evaluation of defense and offense separately, there’s no question he grades out as “poor” for offense, and “excellent” for defense.
This is why I’m hoping he commits to recruiting specifically for implementation of a press system next season. My view is that his best chance to improve his overall success is to aim for a style where the offense is specifically intended to come from the defense.