The amount of injuries around the country with other programs (not just RU), makes these situations more ridiculous than many realize. The teams like Baylor (down their starting 5 for a couple of games), and more importantly for RU, a organization like the NCAA is going to make a determination that the team has a complete resume, when it doesn't.
The reality is that every player and program should be evaluated based on where that team is at the end of the aeason and not based on a Q1 victory in the Battle of Atlantis or Maui, when teams before Thanksgiving are not the same as they are around President's Day or certainly in early March.
The fact that clearly more talented teams like Texas A&M a couple of years ago, got shut out of the NCAAs, because a phantom committee decided that almost winning 4 games in 4 days means nothing, but a November loss means more, is just dumb.
Put the most talented and skilled players into March Madness and evaluate the rosters based on when they are full strength. To compare Northwestern at full strength to Rutgers at full strength, is not the same thing.
This is not lobbying for RU to be given an exception for not winning enough games, but I also know RU would not have defeated Northwestern and Nebraska on the road or Illinois or UCLA at the RAC, if it was the same lineup or players healthy like it has been for parts of January and February......claiming late November vs Monmouth and Merrimack is important to blow teams out, defeats the purpose of player development.
I'd rather see a team or roster get rewarded for player development during November and December and building up towards a pinnacle competition in mid March, than proving something by how many points RU defeats Seton Hall or Columbia by in December.....Seton Hall is worse now than December and so is Columbia.....RU, despite the record saying 12-12, is better than that, if Dylan Harper is healthy and doesn't miss games with the flu and now Ace Bailey might as well.
This is not the same thing as Mawot Mag tearing his ACL and not coming back to play or in the situation of Iowa, missing Owen Freeman with a broken bone in his hand.....Common sense would indicate a season ending injury should be viewed differently than a rolled ankle or flu bug that takes away 25% of a conference schedule from a player.
Cannot wait to have these bigger conferences break away from the NCAA and have their own tournament, for NIL money, in Vegas every March and let the fans migrate there every spring. Spread the games out in the 3 Vegas venues and make it a real "bowl like" tournament. Enough of games in Spokane Washington or Albuquerque New Mexico, with 3 days notice to travel.