Ok , this is my home school and I've seen every game for several years. Micah is in my son's grade and I have been able to see him play football and basketball many, many times.
First of all, this TRN team is ridiculously big and talented. They may be the best Shore area team in history. Every opponent, outside of the first game, was clearly and totally overmatched on a physical basis. So, statistics are completely irrelevant.
Many of the top players on TRN are D1 players (maybe 10 total) but lower level D1/Ivy. Schools like Temple, UConn, Monmouth, UPenn, Cornell etc are around the building.
Micah is a D1 player. He will have multiple P5 offers. For a very long time, he was thought to be a lock for WVU. Recently, Rutgers has been involved. He is likely to be a running back but his throwing is improving. It is conceivable that he would be a QB in college, but he needs further development. Tough, physical, talented - but not a blazer. Strong safety might be the spot.
The OT mentioned above (Jalen Mathews) is a legit top tier lineman. Rutgers was on him first , when he was a freshman. Now, literally everyone wants this kid. He loves RU, but it will be tough to keep him over the high level competition.
Intriguing is the monstrous junior tackle Justin Kaye. Needs work across the board, but he is an absolute giant. Family loves Rutgers and kid would commit on the spot.
Interestingly, TRN plays in the finals at RU next Sunday. Josh Kaye (the older, much smaller) brother of Justin is thought to be a PWO candidate. If he's offered, he will accept and RU could wrap up both with a dual offer following the game.
The WR Tareeq Council is thought to be a Temple silent commit, but could play his way into a better spot. Tough to say how good he is, again, since the team is so dominant, especially running the ball.
There are other very good players who may ultimately be worthy of a high D1 spot, but those mentioned above are the players that are getting the most attention.
While the TRN line is already dominant x 100, it should also be noted that Jake Guarnera also lived in TRN and played on the Pop Warner teams growing up. His dad is RU football alum James Guarnera who had a taste of NFL time following his time on the banks as a DL. The family moved to Florida. While Jake still loves Rutgers, he is an absolute top shelf recruit who recently was hosted by Tennessee and posted pictures of him with Peyton Manning in the locker room. Before that Michigan with pictures of him and Juwan Howard. Thats tough to beat... He will literally be able to pick his team. If he was still at TRN, it would be completely unfair to the opposition (even worse than it is now).
Shore players dont generally have a lot of success at the high D1 level, but I am hoping that this group reverses the trend. Hopefully at Rutgers.