FTR, If Sutton can play at a Big 10 level, then he should play and compete…
If his health is going to be an ongoing issue that the coaches MUST find a position for him to play in that wouldn’t expose him as a turnstile at Right Tackle like in the Penn State game or a speed bump at Right Guard, then it’s time to move on.
Yes he has done all he’s can for this program and should be appreciated for it. But if there’s no one “better” than him to take over the starting job, I’d go with a younger player than an injured player who can’t move against All American DEs and DTs.