"Do recruits really want this or do they want a classy, tradition based uniform? If not, how do the SEC and Big Ten teams recruit? I don't believe it helps recruiting."
It ABSOLUTELY helps with recruiting. As much as many here despise Penn State, thousands of kids grow up wanting to wear those uniforms -- the same ones used for decades. Same with Michigan and Alabama and many, many other programs.
Why is it that the traditionally strong programs are able to keep the same uniforms for decades while other programs have to switch weekly in order to catch the attention of high school students? I think it's the same reason people here wouldn't want the NY Yankees to change their uniform. The same reason I HATED when the NY Rangers brought on a 3rd Jersey. Tradition means something to die-hard fans.
I'm not saying you're not a die-hard fan if you go for the gimmick uniforms or love the way Oregon puts on a new uniform each week, but the die-hard fans who dream of one day playing for their team have a certain uniform image in their mind. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think that's why most of the biggest schools in college football and why most of the biggest pro sports teams DO NOT change their uniforms. It doesn't make them old fashioned... it means they have pride in their history.
I'm in my forties... I know many people in their forties who like the flavor of the week uniforms and many more who don't. It may strictly be an age thing, but I think it's more of a generation thing. When I was 8 years old I loved the same uniforms I love now. Tradition meant something to me as a kid and still does. I'm sure it means something to most of the kids who grow up wanting to play for the Penn States, the Alabamas, the Michigans of the world as well.
Maybe RU just hasn't won enough for people to care about the jersey...