Yes - and no (re Mag). I understand your point, but the Mag situation really only demonstrates that the new narrative becomes a problem when a kid underperforms, or fears they will underperform.
Lost in all the “he quit on the team to preserve his body” discussions, is the reality that he quit following two terrible performances (Maryland and Minny). Don’t get me wrong - he wasn’t “hurting” the team in those games. He was still better than our other options, but in terms of displaying his skill level, more games like those last 2 to wind down the season would have hurt his marketability. That was likely the real issue and probably the reason he didn’t come back sooner this season. He didn’t want to produce sub optimal stats because again - that would reduce his marketability.
All of this still stinks - but the point I’m trying to make is that doesn’t necessarily parallel a suggestion that kids like Ace and Dylan can’t buy into a D first philosophyif the team has success with it early on. If Dylan’s season gets off to a start like JY’s final season at Rutgers prioritizing D, we’d be just fine. This is not out of the realm of possibility.