dislocate kneecap per Andy Katz on BTN
Heard on BTN that dislocated knee cap (patella) again. This is rough. It happened to him last year and I think he avoided the surgery. For this to happen the ligament has to be torn and the surgery repairs the tear. However its a pretty long recovery. If he opts for the surgery he'll be out for the rest of the year. It's a really tough decision. Last year I think he was only out 2 weeks. Of course he risks recurrent dislocations without the surgery.I spoke to one of the coaches after the game who said he's going for an MRI and it's his knee. They won't know severity of it until MRI results but initial thought was he ll be out for a bit. Hopefully MRI is as best as can be and he won't be out too long and we get great news like last year. I may be wrong but I thought he dislocated his knee again and the Ohio state trainer saw it and ran right to Eugene and put it back in place. Felt so bad for Eugene as he was in agony
I fear you're right. Hope you're wrong. I feel awful for EugeneHeard on BTN that dislocated knee cap (patella) again. This is rough. It happened to him last year and I think he avoided the surgery. For this to happen the ligament has to be torn and the surgery repairs the tear. However its a pretty long recovery. If he opts for the surgery he'll be out for the rest of the year. It's a really tough decision. Last year I think he was only out 2 weeks. Of course he risks recurrent dislocations without the surgery.
Heard on BTN that dislocated knee cap (patella) again. This is rough. It happened to him last year and I think he avoided the surgery. For this to happen the ligament has to be torn and the surgery repairs the tear. However its a pretty long recovery. If he opts for the surgery he'll be out for the rest of the year. It's a really tough decision. Last year I think he was only out 2 weeks. Of course he risks recurrent dislocations without the surgery.
For sure he definitely has to have instability after his first dislocation.Depends on the extent of the damage to the ligaments, if any. It's super painful and uncomfortable when it happens, I've done it 2-3 times, but may not be as bad as he was reacting. Will have to wait for MRI results to see if there is ligament damage.
Could be 2 weeks if no damage and just a lot of swelling, or 6-8 weeks+ with ligament damage.
I speculate that his knee was still compromised from his injury last year if it's the same leg.
It's a tough call. He's always going to be more likely to have another dislocation even with the surgery, of course that risk will be reduced.How can he play if every play could be his last?
He's got to have surgery...rehab and hope to come back stronger for his senior year (don't think he'd qualify for a medical RS).
MO
Any orthopedists on the board who can speculate about the potential outcomes for this kid of injury?
Depends how bad the dislocation/subluxation (partial dislocation) is.
I first subluxated my right knee as a HS sophomore, and it took a few weeks to heal up. The next time I did it, I healed a bit faster. Over the next 2.5 years of HS, I managed to have my patella slip out of place probably 50-60 or so times, and never needed surgery. By the end of my senior year, it didn't even stop me playing pickup bball/football for the day - just took a little rest, tightened up my knee brace, and played again after 10-20 min.
Now, that's all *terrible*, mind you, because every time the kneecap went out of place, I got small tears on my ligaments. And each small tear healed with a bit of scar tissue, which was less flexible than the healthy tissue. So over dozens of injuries, and countless small tears/scars, I lost a ton of elasticity in my ligaments - which meant my patella was far more likely to slip out of place.
At some point, EO is going to need to address it, even if he's able to get back on the floor this year with rest and PT.
Thanks for the tag. In this case, unfortunately a pediatrician. I wish I could add some insight here, but I don't have it.I think I recall @Loyal_2RU mentioning once on the boards that he is an orthopedic (or was it a pediatrician?) but I could be misremembering.
Chop, hopefully your game activity is confined to standing at the RAC and the only muscles that get excessively taxed are your lungs.
TL
EO will be wearing a brace on his knee for the rest of his basketball career
Initial thoughts after the game were that it may not have been as severe as last time...
Gotta figure he’s out for the road trip...but hoping to see him against NW
EO will be wearing a brace on his knee for the rest of his basketball career
Initial thoughts after the game were that it may not have been as severe as last time...
Gotta figure he’s out for the road trip...but hoping to see him against NW
EO will be wearing a brace on his knee for the rest of his basketball career
Initial thoughts after the game were that it may not have been as severe as last time...
Gotta figure he’s out for the road trip...but hoping to see him against NW
Is it possible to like a post twice? Great news, thanks...EO will be wearing a brace on his knee for the rest of his basketball career
Initial thoughts after the game were that it may not have been as severe as last time...
Gotta figure he’s out for the road trip...but hoping to see him against NW