When I was a student (2005-08) football seasons, the simplicity was what worked. We leaned into gameday elements that were unique to Rutgers:
- "First down, touchdown, GO RU!" on EVERY 1st down
- For Whom the Bell Tolls" on EVERY 3rd down
- "It is 3rd down....and 7" from Joe Nolan, no screaming
- One standard version of "The Bells Must Ring" played after every score each year
- The cannon
- Chilling R...U... chants, even with 30K in the building
Sure, there was piped in music and when done right, made for some of the most memorable moments at that place. 44,114 singing "We Will Rock You" in unison on 11/9/06 gave me goosebumps.
But i don't know what's going on now. I live in FL now, so I only attend 1-2 games/year, but it comes through just as obnoxious on tv. I watch a good amount of football on Saturdays and nobody else's noise (not crowd noise, just noise) stands out as much as RU's. Maybe I'm hypersensitive to it, but I don't think so.
I will say that I did attend the Washington game this year and thought everything about that experience was big time. But more often than not, give the crowd a chance to think.