ADVERTISEMENT

Is Leonte Caroo the best player in rutgers modern history?

Ray Rice #1 for now; I'll see how season unfolds before designating Caroo the best
 
its Rice and Sanu for me at this point. Lets see what Caroo can do in the final 7 games against tough competition before declaring him the best but he is closing the gap
 
Anyone who says any player but Rice doesn't understand how good he really was.

Herschel Walker is sometimes called the greatest college football player ever. He's also considered by any as the best RB ever in college.

Here's Rays stats compared to Herschels.

Att. Yard ypc td
910 4926 5.4 49

994 5259 5.3 49
 
Here is a highlight reel of Sanu - low quality (if it works, which the other one did not):

 
Here is a highlight reel of Sanu - low quality (if it works, which the other one did not):


And a different one ... This one shows very good patterns and catches, and runs after catches ... then some bone-crushing blocks ... then some of his great Wildcat runs (including a weird view of his 90-yard run) ... and finally his acrobat, gravity defying catches, including his 3rd or 4th down catch while on his back reaching back on a very badly thrown Dodd ball, his one handed leaping TD catch, and several other tremendously acrobat catches:




People remember that Sanu was a GREAT WR for RU ... not good, but great. BUT they forget that he was also RU's best runner while he played for RU (unfortunate, but true, exacerbated by just awful OL's) ... Also, his best position would probably have been Safety, and had he been able to actually play Safety for RU (RU was so short offensive play makers, Sanu had to play WR as a Frosh), he might have been an All American at Safety, and maybe an All Pro in the NFL ... Oh yeah, he could throw the ball a little also ... and he might have been RU's best punter had he only focused on punting.
 
Anyone who says any player but Rice doesn't understand how good he really was.

Herschel Walker is sometimes called the greatest college football player ever. He's also considered by any as the best RB ever in college.

Here's Rays stats compared to Herschels.

people forget - if he had come back for his senior year - he probably would have become NCAA all time leader in rushing yards....


but, Sanu was a beast


Carroo is amazing pure WR
 
I still haven't seen anyone at RU who is able to do this:

LeonardLeapAgainstLouisville1.jpg


People remember that Sanu was a GREAT WR for RU ... not good, but great. BUT they forget that he was also RU's best runner while he played for RU (unfortunate, but true, exacerbated by just awful OL's) ... Also, his best position would probably have been Safety, and had he been able to actually play Safety for RU (RU was so short offensive play makers, Sanu had to play WR as a Frosh), he might have been an All American at Safety, and maybe an All Pro in the NFL ... Oh yeah, he could throw the ball a little also ... and he might have been RU's best punter had he only focused on punting.
And let's not forget his operatic singing voice and his chain saw juggling ability!
 
Geeze people.. it is obviously Ray Rice. How many times did we see Rice face 8 or more in the box and win that battle?

Brian Leonard might have been the most important.. as he set the stage for everyone to BELIEVE Rutgers could succeed. Carroo is probably the best receiver.

Maybe we should make a list by position.
 
Flip the coin to the future. Who is gonna be our star WR next year. Some on the roster are good but we need a standout.
 
Great thread!

Leonte will be in the top 5 conversation but no one -ever- impacted RU like Ray.

I agree about Leonard, and Davis, and Britt but Ray put us on the map.

I will say, though, that Britt has one of the best crack back blocks I've ever seen. Sanu was also good at blowing people up....
 
He is pretty darn good, but he's still no Sanu...

Is Leonte Caroo the best player in rutgers modern history (modern = beginning with Schiano)?

I can't remember a player being so undefendable (if that is a word). Everyone knows he's getting the ball - since the Nova days to the now Laviano days. It is unbelievable how he continues to dominate and get results.
 
In terms of skill players, there's Ray Rice, big gap, then Carroo, Britt and Sanu all bunched up. Carroo may be #2 by the end of the season. If he leads us to a couple of nationally significant upsets, then maybe....
 
Since the topic was "Best Player" and not "Best Offensive Player" I find it hard to believe no one has mentioned Devon McCourty. His senior year was as good a year as a player had ever had here. Besides stellar play in the secondary, he was a special teams animal. That year, if I remember correctly, he blocked a punt, forced a fumble on punt coverage and ran a kick off back for a TD.

I regarding Caroo, I would put him near but not at the top of the list.
 
Since the topic was "Best Player" and not "Best Offensive Player" I find it hard to believe no one has mentioned Devon McCourty. His senior year was as good a year as a player had ever had here. Besides stellar play in the secondary, he was a special teams animal. That year, if I remember correctly, he blocked a punt, forced a fumble on punt coverage and ran a kick off back for a TD.
Didn't he play an ungodly number of snaps vs. Yukon one year?
 
Listen Carroo is awesome but he doesn't touch Ray Ray. Davis was also a BREAST on the line also. McCourty and Sanu as make the list. Brian Leonard will always be on my list for what he did here.
 
Top 10 since Schaino. All time probably just outside the top 25 but certainly top 50
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT