But we fans all identify what we think are errors in hindsight. And in many cases, what we identify as the error by the coach isn’t what we think it is; we’re missing information the coaches have which is necessary to do a proper analysis.While this is mostly true, I don’t think it’s true in all cases.
For example NFL coaches used to make egregious 4th down strategy errors all the time.
It’s a lot less work to pick out an error than it is to not make any errors. Someone who would have no hope of holding a candle to Pike as a coach can still conceivably identify an error he is making.
Anyway, while it might be fun for fans to play at knowing better than pro coaches, it seems like a few people genuinely believe they know better than the coaches. They post as if the coaches are dumb. Which is silly.