Originally posted by megadrone:
To the OP:
Waters could not recruit. He could coach, and had a couple of key players that could (and did) take him far (Douby for the most part).
I'd upgrade him to better than average coach. He was definitely knowledgable down to even the small details of a proper box out.
Things that I think you left out in that one little sentence:
* Best dressed coach
* Made you wonder whether "Gaptards" on this board referred to the football stadium or his smile
* Was NOT personable at all
* Highly dependent on some great assistant coaches / great people (Coach D, Mance, Jimmy Carr, etc) to keep players cohesive/eligible/motivated/happy. Trust me, this was Jimmy Carr's program.
* A bit too loyal at times (Coach Heck was AWFUL)
* Waters could recruit some decent players, with Douby being the only real superstar he was able to bring in, but I'd GLADLY take Calvin Wooten or Adrian Hill on this team at any time, along with other good players along the way. We haven't had a 30-point-on-any-given-night scorer on this team in ages. Mack's carried this team, but since Eli left he's been doing it on his own.
* Forget the whole "Kent State Snowgate" incident. The guy had zero bad bones in his body, and we haven't sniffed at getting a guy with ZERO baggage like Coach Waters.
His problem was that we got spoiled with 18-13, 16-15 type seasons and needed something to get us over the top. We needed somebody to get us recruits like Corey Chandler (god, what a disaster with his career). So we went to Freddie after pretending we had a good reason to get rid of Waters for cheap.