For me I go back and forth.
Athan: Top 10 single season TD, game day manager, protected the ball, ran the ball when he needed to, led the team to 7 wins( including 4 B1G). Had a great season without most of his TEs and a banged up OL
Kyle. Put the team on his back, many YAC yards, found the end zone, was a very good pass protector,
I think I narrowly give it to Kyle for this reason. Athan had phenomenal help from his WRs, Kyle had numerous yards based solely on his talent
No right or wrong answers. That said who ya got?
Athan: Top 10 single season TD, game day manager, protected the ball, ran the ball when he needed to, led the team to 7 wins( including 4 B1G). Had a great season without most of his TEs and a banged up OL
Kyle. Put the team on his back, many YAC yards, found the end zone, was a very good pass protector,
I think I narrowly give it to Kyle for this reason. Athan had phenomenal help from his WRs, Kyle had numerous yards based solely on his talent
No right or wrong answers. That said who ya got?