Aaron Rodgers

[KnightsofChrome]

Graham and Unitas both won NFL titles before the Super bowl era. So merely semantics in saying they never won the "super bowl". (although Unitas did also win a superbowl in split duty as an old man).

Thanks for clearing that up...:rolleyes:

 

[ngrant]

Back to football..CalKnight reps WestCoast QB's which is the fountainhead of more of the Best than anywhere else. Question: Bartkowski was one. Who was theCal Berzerekely product who died of ...Roth? Japan connection?

 

[brianoc]

You can not compare Ryan to either Seaver or Carlton. Before them Koufax and Gibson. He was not as good as Clemens, Pedro or Randy Johnson.

Ryan had great stuff and was capable to throw a magical game but he was basically a 500 pitcher with control problems.

Aaron Rodgers is a great quarterback and I also vote Munn over Gisele

 

[brianoc]

You can not compare Ryan to either Seaver or Carlton. Before them Koufax and Gibson. He was not as good as Clemens, Pedro or Randy Johnson.

Ryan had great stuff and was capable to throw a magical game but he was basically a 500 pitcher with control problems.

Aaron Rodgers is a great quarterback and I also vote Munn over Gisele

You also need to include Elway in the conversation of greatest QB's. He had all the tools.