A little dated, but this article sums it up pretty well and offers some reasonable alternatives. I'm not embarrassed by anything I wrote. If anything , soccer should be embarrassed. Yet, today the world's soccer fans are gloating and gushing over the dramatic conclusion. But . c'mon. 9 out of 10 shooters scored on their PK. Imagine deciding the NBA championship on a free throw contest amongst 5 shooters on each team ( statistically harder than PKs) or the World Series on a home run hitting contest amongst 5 batters).
“The penalty shootout is an abomination. It reduces a team sport to a contrived tiebreaker that obliges physically tired and emotionally drained players to step up one by one, trudge half the length of the field and try to shoot down the opponent’s goalkeeper from 12 yards … Ludicrous. Grotesquely, compellingly ludicrous.
Adding to that frustration, it’s been proven that if a shooter kicks a ball to a far corner, it’s physically impossible for a goalie standing at the center of the goal to have enough time to react and reach the shot.Thus,
goalies must guess, leaving the fate of many games in the world’s biggest sporting event down to sheer luck."
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jimpage...atrocious-penalty-kick-shootout/#4862ab257336