OT: 2025 NY Giants Off Season Thread
- Thread starter Tango Two
- Start date
Aaron Rodgers to the Giants? NY host think its ‘best choice’ for Big Blue
Would the Jets even try to trade Aaron Rodgers to the Giants?
Schoen playing the big, ugly boss over a 1 year, 3 mill player.
I don't care but did he do that with Golladay?
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
nypost.com
I don't care but did he do that with Golladay?
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
Giants GM Joe Schoen told members of the media he didn’t think his maneuvering was alienating players.
nypost.com
Is this true or is it from his agent? I remember when they traded Leonard Williams. Williams was praising Schoen and how he handled it. He asked him if the trade would be ok with him instead of just trading him.Schoen playing the big, ugly boss over a 1 year, 3 mill player.
I don't care but did he do that with Golladay?
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
Giants GM Joe Schoen told members of the media he didn’t think his maneuvering was alienating players.
Schoen playing the big, ugly boss over a 1 year, 3 mill player.
I don't care but did he do that with Golladay?
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
The ugly details behind Giants’ surprising Nick McCloud cut: ‘I am not f—king around’
Giants GM Joe Schoen told members of the media he didn’t think his maneuvering was alienating players.
Golladay was Gettleman's signing. I think Schoen ended up cutting him loose during or after 2022. When teams continue to lose the way the Giants have - everyone piles on. When teams win - none of this stuff matters.
SI piece says NYG players confirming Schoen told player not to pay his rent.
ITs been my impression Schoen got rid of Saquon because he was peeved about the negative media he was getting, The trade had a "taking things personal" vibe to it .
Giants GM Threatened to Release Player Who Wouldn't Take Pay Cut Before a Game
https://www.si.com/nfl/giants-gm-threatened-release-player-pay-cut-before-game
Last edited:
Golladay was released March 2023 and was considered one of worst pick-ups in NFL (21.1 mil cap hit in 2022). I think he had the yips because he would drop easy balls hitting him in the hands
Kenny Golladay proving to be a $72 million bust for New York Giants
When Dave Gettleman was still running the New York Giants’ front office, the team had a strong need to add
sportsnaut.com
Last edited:
As of now this is who I want at 3 if available. He is better then both QB's IMO. Teams that draft for need are in the position that we are in right now. Remember the great Giants D lines of years past. You could never have to many pass rushers.
Sign Justin Fields as a bridge.
Don't know enough about JJ McCarthy's knee.
Fields as a bridge QB maybe. I’d rather have a more seasoned vet if they are gonna be working with a young QB if we draft one. As for McCarthy it depends on his knee health and what the Vikes want. I definitely wouldn’t give up a first for him
We don't even know if McCarthy is a good NFL QB yet so I'm not trading significant assets for him.
The problem with JJ is he already has 1 year burned.
Next year he is likely still recovering.
So you realistically have one season (Year 3) before you need to make a decision on his 5th year option.
Sounds like JJM is not the hit trade that some made out to be because of the injury. Fair enough.
NY Giants won't be raising season ticket prices for 2025 after brutal 3-win campaign
NY Giants' John Mara expressed frustration with how this past year played out. There won't be price increases for 2025 season tickets, the team says.
www.mycentraljersey.com
NY Giants won't be raising season ticket prices for 2025 after brutal 3-win campaign
NY Giants' John Mara expressed frustration with how this past year played out. There won't be price increases for 2025 season tickets, the team says.www.mycentraljersey.com
How about a 10% rebate to the 2024 season ticket holders?
I get a kick out of the rumors I see in my feeds about the Giants needing to trade their #3 overall plus other assets to trade for McCarthy. I think it all started from Mel Kiper. Had to laugh since the Giants already passed on him last season at #6 (if they loved him they would have drafted him). If they do give up that much for him, fire them on the spot.
Beyond Fields, there may be some other bridge type options:
Vets - Andy Dalton or Mariota might be able to hold down the fort for a year or 2
Other younger Guys with potential upside - Hooker, Willis, Ratler, Milton might come much cheaper and be low risk options with potential upsides or to fill a backup role - all these guys are better than anyone currently in the Giants QB Room.
Coming off an ACL year? Yeah, if the give up that much fire them on the spot.
It’s now obvious Mara doesn’t watch games that don’t involve the Giants .
Every damn minute there is a graphic about what a GIANT mistake it was to not bring back Barkley.
if he did there’s no way anyone with a clue would keep this group of morons together.
FYI , just watching the giants the last 2 years should’ve been enough to burn this b-tch down
Every damn minute there is a graphic about what a GIANT mistake it was to not bring back Barkley.
if he did there’s no way anyone with a clue would keep this group of morons together.
FYI , just watching the giants the last 2 years should’ve been enough to burn this b-tch down
Media people cite the Giant's drafting success aside from the OL flops.
There are also the pick-ups like Okereke
They've got some good people in the draft but when you suck every year you will get better drafts as a matter of course I assume
NY Giants need a top cornerback: Here are 5 prospects they could target in 2025 NFL Draft
Tae Banks, the Giants' 2023 first round pick, struggled through his second NFL season. Other than quarterback, starting corner is a glaring need.
www.mycentraljersey.com
Giants turn to Jets as they replace fired defensive position coach
The Giants have a new defensive backs coach.
I think they are only complimenting last year's draft and not the previous ones. Anyway, something is not quite adding up because if they were drafting so great each year, you'd be improving not trending downward.
Should Giants have fired Brian Daboll? They’ll immediately get chance to see if they could’ve upgraded
Brian Daboll is back for Year 4 with the Giants.
Crippled OL and scrubby QBs
I'm seeing a lot more talk about Giants taking SU QB McCord.
I don't trust anything this time of year but McCord has been undervalued imo
Should Giants have fired Brian Daboll? They’ll immediately get chance to see if they could’ve upgraded
Brian Daboll is back for Year 4 with the Giants.www.nj.com
If NYGs take Shedeur, Dabol probably has Pops Prime stalking in the background
Mara needs to fire dumbbell and that complete moron
GM. If you dont watch this game and fire your GM you are a F-in joke , not of an owner , but a joke a of a human being with no clue
GM. If you dont watch this game and fire your GM you are a F-in joke , not of an owner , but a joke a of a human being with no clue
I don't know who that is but it makes no sense considering Shedeur is among top 4 passers and had highest completion rate (74%). He had no run game or OL - tons of pressure and sacks (and dirty hits). I think a lot of people in media just hate Sanders. I recall Jets had a scout knocking Sanders and Jets are hideous for QBs
Give this one a read. Out of most of the QB's in this years draft he had the most time to throw. He is not a good processor. A bunch of his sacks are his fault and not his O lines. He took one for -28 yards vs BYU. Jim Nagy who runs the Senior Bowl and is a highly respected talent evaluator in the NFL said these QB's would possibly be QB7 last year. Picking one at 3 is too high for me with one of Carter, Graham or Hunter being available.
This part here:
"I am warning teams not to dismiss Sanders sack totals by accepting the popular narrative that makes the offensive line the scapegoat and to ask themselves “What’s really taking so long for Sanders to get the ball out of his hand?”
Author never mentions that Colorado was 134th in nation for rushing - dead last.
The offensive line WAS bad and not bad because of Shedeur.
I also dont see mention of Shedeur being committed to being a pocket passer.
The NFL is full of shoot or scoot QBs (a trend made worse by declining OL skills and DLs off the hook).
Shedure will stay in place looking for a completion instead of running over the LOS.
Unfortunately that lack of a run game let pass defenders (LBs as well as DB) ignore the run.
DL could also focus on rush rush rush because there was no run run run
Football is a Rubic's cube - when the greens and blues move what happens to the reds and whites?
Looking at OL just via pass game and not run game is judging the pizza by the dough and not the cheese/sauce
I'm hungry now
NY Giants need a wide receiver: Here are 5 prospects they could target in 2025 NFL Draft
Malik Nabers has earned his place atop Giants' depth chart, but there is room for another wide receiver in this offense. Who could fit with Big Blue?
www.mycentraljersey.com
NY Giants need a wide receiver: Here are 5 prospects they could target in 2025 NFL Draft
Malik Nabers has earned his place atop Giants' depth chart, but there is room for another wide receiver in this offense. Who could fit with Big Blue?www.mycentraljersey.com
Nothing against those guys, but I think the Giants' have greater need elsewhere,
The news kept reporting that Mara did not want to continue the decade-long history of hiring and then quickly firing successive coaching/GM regimes. Here’s the big problem with that thinking: it’s the hirings, not the firings.
That’s what he needs to fix.
(P.s., and what’s his nephew still doing in the personnel department? Ten years in this personnel department is a horrible resume. It should be a jet pack to the unemployment line.)
