Question about Korsak and NFL

[superfan01]

Obviously making an nfl team as a punter is brutally hard because there are no backups.

we know he is good.

but does his style translate to NFL where getting the kick off quick and hangtime seems to be the key?

does he have a shot at the NFL?

have we ever had a punter or kicker in the NFL?

 

[rutgerskevin]

Mike Barr definitely kicked in some preseason games--not sure if he ever played in a regular season game.

 

[RU76]

Similar question asked when soccer style place kickers arrived.

 

[bryanjints]

The way the Giants are going they are going to need a good punter for 10 years. Maybe he can make it there.

 

[198hamilton]

When Korsak takes those extra few steps before he kicks is the same thing as hang time. It's all about net punting.
One day there will be several rugby style punters in the NFL

 

[chickenpatty2]

I've been thinking about this, too. He has some skills, but isn't he always stepping out to the right in order to get those couple of steps in before he kicks it? A Pro team would figure out how to attack that at some point, no?

 

[superfan01]

When Korsak takes those extra few steps before he kicks is the same thing as hang time. It's all about net punting.
One day there will be several rugby style punters in the NFL

I understand that regarding hang time.
. But maybe the reason the nfl teams don't have rugby punters is because it doesn't work at that level.

 

[Source]

have we ever had a punter or kicker in the NFL?

Deron Cherry was a punter at Rutgers. But then he became an All Pro safety for the Kansas City Chiefs. Don't know if they ever called upon him to punt in an emergency.

Some of the early Rutgers backs and quarterbacks from the 1920s and 1930s were sometimes handed the dual jobs of running/throwing the ball and punting it away or drop-kicking it for a field goal.

 

[RUfromSoCal?]

heard on RURant today he may come back for 1 more year... which would be AMAZING! if it happens...

NFL doesn't like rugby punting or running kicks... they think they have way too much talent/speed at every position - and that style of punting is too risky... and I'd agree the margin for error in NFL punting is 1/100ths of a second and inches...

he WILL get a shot... not sure if he'll catch on.. I sure hope so!!

 

[RUfromSoCal?]

everything has changed........

 

[SouthJerseyRU]

When Korsak takes those extra few steps before he kicks is the same thing as hang time. It's all about net punting.
One day there will be several rugby style punters in the NFL

You can't do a rugby punt in the NFL. They have different rules for illegal man down field on punts than NCAA.

A few weeks ago, the Eagles punter Aaron Siposs ( an Aussie) caught the snap and there was a man in his face so he pulled the ball in and did a rugby punt, but they called a penalty.

Korsak can succeed in the NFL, but he'll have to do it via a standard NFL punt.

 

[RUforJERSEY]

When Korsak takes those extra few steps before he kicks is the same thing as hang time. It's all about net punting.
One day there will be several rugby style punters in the NFL

Well that day ain't today

 

[ashokan]

Maybe he doesn't have to rugby punt.
I imagine he's not awful at the standard and usual

 

[runner3283]

I understand that regarding hang time.
. But maybe the reason the nfl teams don't have rugby punters is because it doesn't work at that level.

I’ve heard same but. I don’t understand why it doesn’t work

 

[zappaa]

He doesn’t turn the ball over or have enough air time kicking from his own territory…imo

 

[krup]

I’ve heard same but. I don’t understand why it doesn’t work

As mentioned above, only the outside gunners can leave before the ball is kicked, so the style doesn’t translate. With the short hang time of the rugby punt, returns would be easier against it.

 

[robjknight]

Adam will play in NFL!

 

[RUScrew85]

As mentioned above, only the outside gunners can leave before the ball is kicked, so the style doesn’t translate. With the short hang time of the rugby punt, returns would be easier against it.

I was wondering why he was able to hold it so long - another difference between CFB and the nfl.

 

[zappaa]

Adam will play in NFL!

Doing what?
He can’t kick from his own end zone up to NFL standards and metrics

 

[jsol_05]

I've been thinking about this, too. He has some skills, but isn't he always stepping out to the right in order to get those couple of steps in before he kicks it? A Pro team would figure out how to attack that at some point, no?

Yep

 

[Jimpeg]

take if for what its worth...Mel Kiper has him as the 3rd rated punter in the class.