better'd be absolute amazing if its selling for $200+ lolYes the Signet is fantastic. Im actually having a dram of it right now. It is in one of my favorites. It has a taste to it that I dont find in any other scotch. Some kind of cocoa malt. I never had the Macallen 18 Triple Cask so I cant speak on that. I have had other Macallens and they tast kinda similar to me, mostly sherry bombs, but IMO nothing else I tasted is similar to the Signet. Let us know how you like if you try it.