Anderson got fired for one reason: 2-7-2 in Year 6.
His teams did very well in the first half of the season. Those .500 years you see matched up with my years there. He would start 4-2, 5-2-1 and wind up 5-6, 6-5, 5-5-1. Depth, obviously. But he did have WTF games early, too. Beating Michigan State (without Tony Mandarich, but still ...) and Penn State (their worst team in forever, but still ...) was sandwiched around losing to Vandy at Giants Stadium.
Anderson was a pretty solid guy, but two things about him pissed me off. First, trailing Army 24-0, first play of the second half is a run up the middle. You could hear Giants Stadium sigh. I could hear Anderson saying, "We like to have a good mix."
Second thing was bigger -- after that drunk-driving crash that killed Bob Lowther and injured Bob Speidel and Paul Garea (sp?), he was asked about Speidel's status on NJN. He could have given coach-speak. He could have lied. He could have told the truth, that it was a university matter. But no, he just walked off the camera. At a university that had a fraternity pledge die in February, you won't answer a question about a player who was driving drunk and killed a teammate? As if there wouldn't be some kind of punishment after more than a dozen frat brothers got hit hard?
His "he's a solid guy" image disappeared to me that day. The 2-7-2 made it easy. But he was competent, which we don't have now.