Perennial powerhouse at St. Benedict's with experience recruiting and coaching college stars and future pros. Developed relationships with important people in the area.
25 wins at Wagner
23 wins with an NIT appearance in Year 3 at Rhode Island.
Recruiting top 100 players and beating out Power 5 schools for recruits (like us). Four McGlynn chose Rhode Island over Rutgers and others, as well as 2016 shooting guard Jeff Dowtin and 2015 decommit Leroy Butts.
They have 14 wins this season but they did lose one of their best players. Unlike Jordan, I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt based on how they've played without Matthews and during 2014-15 season (which included a sweep of GW). They play hard and they play defense. Recruiting remains on the upswing.
Junior EC Matthews was a 4-star, Jarred Terrell was a 4-star and inside the top 70 (at Rhode Island!).
He signed one of the most under the radar players in NJ in 2016, someone Rutgers never watched and never offered. In fact, The Patrick School HC/AD openly mocked the Rutgers staff on social media.
Obviously I would take some other guys before him, but at some point he becomes one of the best candidates.
Amaker, Lonergan, Sendek, Greenberg.
Then Hurley.
Who's better a mix of recruiter/defensive-minded coach who's young (early 40s) and competitive and rom NJ after the first four names I cited above?
Engles, Boyle and Dooley? Maybe, if we miss on Hurley, but not BEFORE Hurley.
So while he hasn't made the tournament, he's made the NIT at Rhode Island and has them in position to make the dance as long as he's there, with a 14-win team that's competitive without its best player.
He recruits four-star players to Rhode Island. He has good assistants (Jim Carr, for example) and grassroots and high school coaches trust him with their players.
New Jersey would rally around Hurley moreso than even a Sendek, and we all agree that knowing how to recruit NJ - not just the desire - is very important to hit our potential. We don't need the best, but we need to rebuild relationships with local coaches much like Coach Ash has done since arriving at Rutgers.
You don't wave the white flag.