That's what, I'm saying. All the information about Hurley either came from Hurley's camp, or were people making guesses.
But Hobbs wouldn't have told Hurley who the other candidates were. And he certainly wouldn't have told Hurley that someone else was the number 1 candidate and Hurley was the number 2 candidate. So there is no way for Hurley to reliably know if he was the top candidate or not.
At best, Hurley's and Lonergan's shared agent would have known they were both candidates and may have known where they ranked in comparison to each other. But if the agent knew that Hurley was the top candidate and would be offered the job, then Lonergan would have never interviewed for the job on Monday.