ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Serious Question - Should any BE team make the Tourney?

Indiana has beaten Michigan State 2 , louisville and Marquette. Palm is a joke.
 
Shu fans making quips on Rutgers...thats not the topic of thread

The big east is garbage this year
You’ve said this about 5-10 times now. Every team is above .500 overall, there’s no bad team in the entire conference.

It’s not even close to as bad as the Pac 12 and almost every team graduates nobody of significance. Also, out of conference games exist and make up about 40% of your entire schedule. It’s not like the big east got demolished in that respect and had some terrific wins against elite teams. Just because the conference is eating itself alive doesn’t mean it’s a bad conference
 
I will be the first to admit that, after producing 2 #1 seeds last year, and the National Champions, the Big East is lacking in elite teams--very true. But to claim that RU would be the 4th-best team in the BE is crazy and to dismiss the conference as "garbage" (and to resort to name-calling) betrays a kind of weird malice towards the conference. Conference in 5th in RPI and 5th in NET. Probably going to send 4 teams, 40% of Conference to dance. No teams with a losing record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUMAN
And calling Indiana average and they beat Marquette by 23 points.
 
NET rankings are updated:
26 - Villanova
29 - Marquette
54 - Creighton
61 - SHU
62 - Butler
66 - SJU
71 - Xavier
74 - Providence
76 - G'town
101 - DePaul

So just two Big East programs count as Q1 games at home or on a neutral court.

# of Programs in the Top 50 by conference:
9 - ACC
8 - Big 12
7 - Big Ten, SEC
4 - AAC
2 - Big East, MWC, WCC, Southern, Ohio Valley
1 - Pac 12, MAC, A10, Atlantic Sun

Would be a little crazy if the Big East programs that left the conference to focus on basketball ended up behind the AAC going forward.

Goes in spurts Big East was due for a down year has had a bunch of good ones in a row. Big was horrible last year very good this year The people thinking the Big East is going away are clueless. Georgetown and Providence both start Freshman backcourt is their really anyone who does not think they will be good down the line. Btw I know someone will come back saying Rutgers is young too. I agree should be good down the line
 
Big East is going nowhere, but conference was down. Hoping Belmont gets in and steals bid.
 
This thread is hilarious. The Big East is a good conference. That’s neither a compliment nor an insult. No great teams on top, and no garbage teams at the bottom. Frankly, Villanova somehow winning the regular season championship speaks volume about the inability of schools like Seton Hall and Marquette to flex their muscle and take advantage of a golden opportunity. The conference is nothing special, but it’s not a one bid mid major conference. As for talking about RU in the Big East, that’s just stupid to talk about how we’d finish in fourth. We had some nice moments in conference this year, but please we’re not consistent enough to talking hypotheticals like that
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vegas pj and batts
This thread is hilarious. The Big East is a good conference. That’s neither a compliment nor an insult. No great teams on top, and no garbage teams at the bottom. Frankly, Villanova somehow winning the regular season championship speaks volume about the inability of schools like Seton Hall and Marquette to flex their muscle and take advantage of a golden opportunity. The conference is nothing special, but it’s not a one bid mid major conference. As for talking about RU in the Big East, that’s just stupid to talk about how we’d finish in fourth. We had some nice moments in conference this year, but please we’re not consistent enough to talking hypotheticals like that

I agree with your statement regarding Marquette but SH lost 4 starters and 3 were 1000 point scorers.

There is no way they were going to contend for a title and were picked 8th in most preseason polls.

Willard should be the COY in the conference for the job he did this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: batts and biazza38
I agree with your statement regarding Marquette but SH lost 4 starters and 3 were 1000 point scorers.

There is no way they were going to contend for a title and were picked 8th in most preseason polls.

Willard should be the COY in the conference for the job he did this season.
Yeah, bit of a reach by mentioning SHU. Frankly, I completely forgot about the roster turnover when I said that. My bad
 
Judging by the ratings the Big East probably only deserves 2 into the tourney being Marquette and Villanova. SHU has been up and down all year. If the BE ever got 4 or 5 into the NCAA the BIG 10 should get 8 or 9. The BIG 10 is way better than the Big East this year. There are only 10 teams in the BE so if they get 4 or 5 in they will get 40 % or 50 % of their teams in. The BIG 10 being so much better should get over 50 % in which would be at least 8 in as we have 14 teams and all 14 are rated really well.

Totally absurd post saying Hall does not belong at this point . Someone who is usually a good poster can't put his hate for Seton Hall asides. BTW the Big is probably going to get 8 or 9. What you have to remember is the A10 may get only one team in at most two. Pac 12 probably only two that leaves bids for other conferences.
 
  • Like
Reactions: biazza38
Totally absurd post saying Hall does not belong at this point . Someone who is usually a good poster can't put his hate for Seton Hall asides. BTW the Big is probably going to get 8 or 9. What you have to remember is the A10 may get only one team in at most two. Pac 12 probably only two that leaves bids for other conferences.

He is a very good poster. Likely having a bad day.
 
Proff & Friar, I don't hate SHU. I just never liked Hazell with his constant throwing out his leg into a defender and getting rewarded with three 3's. I attended the Prep and I use to be a big SHU fan. My opinion is based on SHU only being rated as # 59 in Kenpom and # 52 in Segarin. When RU had Billet & Hodgson they finished at # 42 in the RPI and didn't get selected for the NCAA. There are quite a few mid majors that will make the NCAA taking many of the 68 spots. Quite a few teams are ahead of SHU in those rankings and won't make it. I think they will probably make it but losing twice to Depaul is not good.
 
DePaul isn’t awful anymore. Not unlike us they have been improving. Recently beat St. John’s and Georgetown.
 
This is getting close to the college football playoff argument:

Forget the NCAA 68 team tournament. What(How many) teams DESERVE the opportunity to play for a national championship?
 
Reiterating again that I don't agree with the idea of the BE not getting any teams (or even be limited to one), it has still been a historically bad year for the conference and they need to spring back hard next season.

The Big Ten had a bad year last year, too... but still had a few Top 15 programs in Michigan/MSU/Purdue to carry the banner while the other teams retooled for a much stronger showing this season.

The BE is good/decent up and down the conference roster, but has no programs that are standouts - which could lead to the earliest exit from the tournament in conference history without some upsets.

In the five seasons since the Big East restructured, only Nova and Xavier have made it out of the Round of 32 (with Xavier losing twice in the Sweet 16, and Nova winning two championships). They'll need to pull off some upsets to get anyone to the second weekend this year, too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHajekRC84
Reiterating again that I don't agree with the idea of the BE not getting any teams (or even be limited to one), it has still been a historically bad year for the conference and they need to spring back hard next season.

The Big Ten had a bad year last year, too... but still had a few Top 15 programs in Michigan/MSU/Purdue to carry the banner while the other teams retooled for a much stronger showing this season.

The BE is good/decent up and down the conference roster, but has no programs that are standouts - which could lead to the earliest exit from the tournament in conference history without some upsets.

In the five seasons since the Big East restructured, only Nova and Xavier have made it out of the Round of 32 (with Xavier losing twice in the Sweet 16, and Nova winning two championships). They'll need to pull off some upsets to get anyone to the second weekend this year, too.


And the Big 10
Hasn’t won the Natty since 2000. And they certainly are a great conference in basketball.
 
And the Big 10
Hasn’t won the Natty since 2000. And they certainly are a great conference in basketball.

The AAC won a NC in 2014, too... is that an argument that they're a great conference? Or just an argument that UConn had a great season?

The BE can't just be Nova and the Novettes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shields
my 2 cents.. BE is nothing special this year but certainly a deserving conf. given the overall play of teams across the country. Hall belongs with the season end results and I KNOW THAT IS NOT SUPPOSED TO MATTER anymore.

I player like Powell can carry them, although like (my new best friend) Mr. Choppin said I don't see any deep runs.
 
The AAC won a NC in 2014, too... is that an argument that they're a great conference? Or just an argument that UConn had a great season?

The BE can't just be Nova and the Novettes.

The BE argument could be the Big Ten is the Nonettes
 
Reiterating again that I don't agree with the idea of the BE not getting any teams (or even be limited to one), it has still been a historically bad year for the conference and they need to spring back hard next season.

The Big Ten had a bad year last year, too... but still had a few Top 15 programs in Michigan/MSU/Purdue to carry the banner while the other teams retooled for a much stronger showing this season.

The BE is good/decent up and down the conference roster, but has no programs that are standouts - which could lead to the earliest exit from the tournament in conference history without some upsets.

In the five seasons since the Big East restructured, only Nova and Xavier have made it out of the Round of 32 (with Xavier losing twice in the Sweet 16, and Nova winning two championships). They'll need to pull off some upsets to get anyone to the second weekend this year, too.
This is a pretty fair assessment. The league is down this year after losing a ton of talent to the draft last year and two of the top coaches. Lots of freshman talent and reloading recruiting classes. The New Big East is still a relatively young league and although Nova has two of the last three National Championships, the rest of the league needs to build on that. It's all about money (Fox) and getting/retaining the coaches. Jay Wright is the anchor, and there are a core group that see this as their destination job (Cooley at Providence and Ewing at Georgetown, etc.), IF you get coaches and you can pay them, you will get the players that want to play in a BB-only, urban focused league.

The question is who will emerge as the upper echelon and join Villanova to be that consistent 1-4 seed in the NCAA. IMO, Marquette (Wojo) and Georgetown (Ewing) are most likely, but time will tell. This year, SJU may have the most talented roster, but not sold as Mullin as a coach yet. I would not want to face them in the NCAA though if they make it in. Villanova and Marquette are likely 5/6 seeds, so they have a fighting chance to get through the first weekend.
 
This is a pretty fair assessment. The league is down this year after losing a ton of talent to the draft last year and two of the top coaches. Lots of freshman talent and reloading recruiting classes. The New Big East is still a relatively young league and although Nova has two of the last three National Championships, the rest of the league needs to build on that. It's all about money (Fox) and getting/retaining the coaches. Jay Wright is the anchor, and there are a core group that see this as their destination job (Cooley at Providence and Ewing at Georgetown, etc.), IF you get coaches and you can pay them, you will get the players that want to play in a BB-only, urban focused league.

The question is who will emerge as the upper echelon and join Villanova to be that consistent 1-4 seed in the NCAA. IMO, Marquette (Wojo) and Georgetown (Ewing) are most likely, but time will tell. This year, SJU may have the most talented roster, but not sold as Mullin as a coach yet. I would not want to face them in the NCAA though if they make it in. Villanova and Marquette are likely 5/6 seeds, so they have a fighting chance to get through the first weekend.

The Fox deal works out to $4M per team per year, right? If the conference can go into the negotiating cycle on an upswing, that would certainly help with the getting coaches and paying them part.

The BE definitely needs an upper echelon to emerge. With the new quadrant system, it's tough when there are few Q1 opportunities in conference.
 
The AAC won a NC in 2014, too... is that an argument that they're a great conference? Or just an argument that UConn had a great season?

The BE can't just be Nova and the Novettes.


Not sure how you drew that line. Not exactly a read across.
 
The Fox deal works out to $4M per team per year, right? If the conference can go into the negotiating cycle on an upswing, that would certainly help with the getting coaches and paying them part.

The BE definitely needs an upper echelon to emerge. With the new quadrant system, it's tough when there are few Q1 opportunities in conference.
That's roughly the money, yes. The BET has done extremely well at the box office and ratings wise. That was a concern with the NBE not having Syracuse and UConn which normally filled the seats in person and on TV. It would be helpful for SJU to emerge as an elite program, but I'm not sold on Mullin as an elite coach.

Villanova's two NC's gave the league instant credibility at it's formation, but like you said, others need to step up and go deep each year.
 
I believe that happens within 3-4 years.

UConn just has to get smart and drop D-1 football which is a ridiculous revenue drag on them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUChoppin
I'm as big of a hater on the BE and shoe, but they deserve 3, maybe 4 teams in given how poor the bubble is this year: THE NOVA, Marquette, shoe, and Johnnies. At least 1 should play in Dayton in an at-large play-in game, and all but Nova and Marquette should be lower seeded teams. Time will tell if this what I predicted will happen after the BE split, that the remaining teams will eventually become on the caliber or just slightly better of the A-10.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT