I don't think the sky is falling but fans forget how things were before Pritzlaff. Rutgers had good attendance, good recruiting classes, a great area for wrestling, lots of national qualifiers, and couldn't develop an AA. I'm not saying he is solely responsible for later development but great classes, big crowds and lots of qualifiers aren't convincing.
Rutgers did well last season correcting course and securing some post season individual honors. Hopefully that can continue! If it does, credit will be given for navigating this hurdle and keeping program on course. If not, criticism will be warranted.