This is an interesting dilemma. Just looking at former NJ state champs we have had about 24 NJ state champs under Coach Goodale, 18 that didn't All American and 6 that were AAs. This excludes existing roster kids that were state champs and yet to AA.
Of the All Americans, 3 of these kids initially committed to Rutgers (Ashnault, Perrotti, and Poz) and 3 initially committed elsewhere and then came to Rutgers (Suriano, Rivera, and DelVecchio).
On the current roster Janzer, Soldano, Casale, White, Clark, Kinniard, Raimo, Fongaro and O'Neil were NJ state champs and initially committed to Rutgers. Plus Peterson committed to Princeton and Alvarez chose NC State before switching to RU. We don't know if they will AA. Soldano, Peterson, and Alvarez definitely have the ability to AA.
Past NJ champs who didn't AA include:Dellefave, Visciaro, Campolotanno, Gentile, Giraldo,, Angelo, Grello, Mulligan, Correnti, Aragona, Smith, Melde, Winston, Benner, Langel, Firestone, Caruso, and Glasgow. So 25 % of NJ champs who have competed at RU became AA. Is this good or bad? I don't know. What should we expect?
There is a lot of top NJ talent that goes and stays out of state. Need to understand why and what we can do about it. Seems as if we have a good pre-existing relationship with an out of state stud we should go after him. Other wise go after and get the really best NJ kids.