ADVERTISEMENT

I dont buy the narrative that schools better than RU want Pike and that’s why Hobbs keeps extending him

If you think it’s all about the money with Pikes, then you don’t know him. Which of course, you don’t.
Pike might not move solely over money, but you can repel a lot if offers with a very good pay
Better to get ahead of it
 
You just can't control yourself, can you? There's a time and a place. Last night was not the time or the place. It's a life skill that you may require. Work on it.
What better time than losing at home to Hofstra?
 
Here is why I’m not buying what Hobbs tried to sell on the knight report podcast that he extends guys preemptively when he thinks other schools will start calling.

1) There’s only about 10 schools that can pay the “make me move” price which I believe is roughly $1,000,000 more per year than his current salary. Those schools are Arizona, Oregon, Texas A&M, Arkansas, UCLA, WVU, Illinois, Virginia, Auburn, Tennessee, Michigan State, Kansas, Kentucky.

Those schools arent looking for coaches and if those jobs opened up pike wouldnt be on shortlists

2) AD’s are focusing on offense with their hires these days. The best hire over the past number of years was nate oates. Offense, offense, offense. AD’s recognize that offense is what gets fans most excited and sells tix + it ultimately is what raises your ceiling.

Imagine being an AD for a school with a top 10 salary pool and hiring pike and saying, “guys we got this great coach, past 7 years in the b1g and won 1 total tourney game”. Theyd bring out the pitchforks. Can he take a shit program to average by virtue of simply out toughing teams? Hell yeah. Thing is those top 10 salary schools arent looking to go from historically bad to average, theyre looking to go from good to great.

3) $15,000,000 buy out. A school isnt paying that unless its a sure fire slam dunk proven coach. Pike is not that.

4) Pike is a northeast guy. Where the hell is he going

Ultimately, Hobbs needs to chill out with these annual extensions any time he has a couple good weeks. He already is signed super long term, with a ton of guaranteed money and a huge buyout. You don't need to extend him every year. You don’t extend guys and pay them more money when they do not have a single alternative that can offer them more than we can.
Do you want Eddie Jordan back!
 
An average good coach can’t just bring a program up from where we were. And that is what pike has done. You can have a better x/o guy and a better recruiter but unless you have someone like him that cares about the school/kids/program you can’t build from underground with a solid foundation.

You you could have had a flashier type come in here and win with hired gun mentality, but no one would have left us on surer ground that pike
At what time will it be ok to raise expectations and want a 2nd weekend visit in the tourney? Time wise im talking how many years would pike have to be coach here. Cc: @ScarletDave
 
Do you want Eddie Jordan back!
I am not saying fire Pike at all but everyone throws out Eddie Jordan or another bad hire by our AD’s and are board unwillingness to pay to get a top talent coach. If the board is now paying at the level Pike is receiving then your next hire could have been Shaka before he took the Marquette job. Collins because he wants to come back east. The list goes on

Once again NOT saying to fire the coach but throwing out the numerous second rate low budget coaches we have had is not fair.

If we are going to pay top 25 coach money you will get winning in return. Look at the other top paid coaches and where they are playing this week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutgersNo1
Here is why I’m not buying what Hobbs tried to sell on the knight report podcast that he extends guys preemptively when he thinks other schools will start calling.

1) There’s only about 10 schools that can pay the “make me move” price which I believe is roughly $1,000,000 more per year than his current salary. Those schools are Arizona, Oregon, Texas A&M, Arkansas, UCLA, WVU, Illinois, Virginia, Auburn, Tennessee, Michigan State, Kansas, Kentucky.

Those schools arent looking for coaches and if those jobs opened up pike wouldnt be on shortlists

2) AD’s are focusing on offense with their hires these days. The best hire over the past number of years was nate oates. Offense, offense, offense. AD’s recognize that offense is what gets fans most excited and sells tix + it ultimately is what raises your ceiling.

Imagine being an AD for a school with a top 10 salary pool and hiring pike and saying, “guys we got this great coach, past 7 years in the b1g and won 1 total tourney game”. Theyd bring out the pitchforks. Can he take a shit program to average by virtue of simply out toughing teams? Hell yeah. Thing is those top 10 salary schools arent looking to go from historically bad to average, theyre looking to go from good to great.

3) $15,000,000 buy out. A school isnt paying that unless its a sure fire slam dunk proven coach. Pike is not that.

4) Pike is a northeast guy. Where the hell is he going

Ultimately, Hobbs needs to chill out with these annual extensions any time he has a couple good weeks. He already is signed super long term, with a ton of guaranteed money and a huge buyout. You don't need to extend him every year. You don’t extend guys and pay them more money when they do not have a single alternative that can offer them more than we can.
Why do you care? You are a SHU fan that craps on R Hoops every chance you get. POS.
 
Or maybe he’s also a good coach with a ton of talent?
Good coaches recruit develop and acquire through the portal a ton of talent. We keep saying talent is coming. It’s time to stop making excuses for a complete letdown of a season. I agree on paper what is supposed to be coming is extremely exciting but no more free passes.
 
Oats is a tremendous coach. If he’s not Nate Oats, we should fire him?
 
Miss me with the “1 tourney win 7 years” deal. Sorry he didn’t take Eddie Jordan’s clown show and immediately recruit players good enough to go to the NCAAs by their senior year. Oh wait that’s exactly what he did. He’s a miracle worker after what went on here the last 30 years
bravo sir,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,this program was a laughing stock before pike......i can"t believe the anti pikers are still questioning his coaching chops.. the man is a miracle worker.....can't wait for the next few years. help is on the way.
 
Why do you care? You are a SHU fan that craps on R Hoops every chance you get. POS.
They deserve to be crapped on this year. This year was a massive failure. Didn't make the tournament, made zero adjustments to cope with mag loss, completely dropped what was an easy shot at the tournament (yes, beating minny and neb at home is easy for good teams).
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUDivision
From a Rutgers fan perspective? Sure. Because the bar was buried here due to decades of horrific hires and a cheap administration.

Again, I think hes your average “good” coach. Hes no where close to great though. And frankly, for a fan base with incredibly low expectations, “good” is just fine. Theres very few fans here that want more than simply an ncaa tourney bid.
How about we see what he does with the influx of talent coming before judging if he’s good vs great. He’s done quite a bit with average talent.
 
Rutgers is a REALLY hard job. It would be a huge career gamble for an established "very good" head coach to take this job at ANY price. Sure, you might get someone to humor the Rutgers administration in order to get a pay raise at their current school but that's about it. Pike is here and has competed with bluebloods like Indiana, Purdue, and Michigan State on even terms with inferior talent for several consecutive years now. To think that any other good coach could step in and not miss a beat is delusional. Just absurd that this comes up again and again from the same usual suspects. Just a complete lack of understanding of the college basketball landscape.
 
Good point. What he did at Buffalo is more impressive than Alabama.

With that said, considering what Pikiell inherited at Rutgers and where he’s gotten us, I feel good about calling him a very good coach.
Hurley had Buffalo in the tournament the season before Oats got there
Still impressive what Oats did there - just context
Oats didn't take over a bad program at Buffalo
 
  • Like
Reactions: S_Janowski
I am not saying fire Pike at all but everyone throws out Eddie Jordan or another bad hire by our AD’s and are board unwillingness to pay to get a top talent coach. If the board is now paying at the level Pike is receiving then your next hire could have been Shaka before he took the Marquette job. Collins because he wants to come back east. The list goes on

Once again NOT saying to fire the coach but throwing out the numerous second rate low budget coaches we have had is not fair.

If we are going to pay top 25 coach money you will get winning in return. Look at the other top paid coaches and where they are playing this week.
1. We probably aren't willing to pay Pike's contract to an unproven commodity. He's getting what he's getting because he has done a good job.

2. We are paying him an average Big Ten salary and getting average Big Ten results.

Sure we could fire him, then bet that the next guy is the next Shaka Smart and not the next (pick your choice of seemingly great mid-major coaches who were no better than average at a major school). But that's a big gamble and there is no particular reason to take it now. Pike might stay the same, but his recruiting seems to be picking up, so the team might get better.

As far as the original intent of the post - Maryland hired Kevin Willard away from SHU after he had a run (albeit longer with a much longer rebuild) similar to Pike's record (edging into the tournament and losing in round 1 or 2). They idea that teams wouldn't be interested in Pikiell is insane.
 
At what time will it be ok to raise expectations and want a 2nd weekend visit in the tourney? Time wise im talking how many years would pike have to be coach here. Cc: @ScarletDave

We all want Final 4s and national championships - we are just realistic on what it takes to get there. Until Pike arrived, this was considered a dead end job where careers go to die - and then it got worse after Rice (credit to Eddie for at least running into the dumpster fire to try to put it out).

Pike is one of the best coaches in the country and will continue to get better in all aspects. Recruiting, coaching, etc. The guys he recruited to the dumpster fire are just graduating now - you dont find guys like Geo, Ron, Caleb, Paul, Myles, Derek, Wolf unless you are outworking almost everyone.

Last night was a game for the die hards - and the team was met with applause after the game, as they should have been.

And FFS, there really has not been enough credit to Hofstra (one of only 3 teams to beat Charleston). We didnt lose - they won that game. Those guys just could not miss in the second half, banked 3's, tear drops that just always found their way in. They hit big time shots. 57% from the floor to our 51%, both teams at 40% from deep. Hell of a game.

For context... the last 10 games before Pike took over...

24 Point loss to Nebraska
10 point loss to Ohio State
16 Point loss to Illinois
12 Point loss to be a bad PSU
22 Point loss to Minny
39 Point loss to Northwestern
31 Point loss to MSU
23 Point win over Minny - 3 players suspended before the game, including their best player! And they were already the 2nd worst team in the Big.
17 point loss to 11 seed Nebraska in the Big Ten Tourney

And you were expected a tourney birth the next year? Getting there in year 4 (really year 3 since the 2016 class was mostly done and his first class was in 2017) was a miracle - and he sort of hit it out of the park with Geo and Myles in his first class. Harper, Tez and Caleb in his second class.
 
So you’re saying there’s way more than 10 schools that would be able to pay Pikiell well more than what he makes here after the extension?

Got it.

Let’s keep in mind the cost of living less in a lot of these areas as well.
When you're banking $4mil a year, the price of eggs isn't a significant consideration. I've had this conversation with people over the years and I always tell them it sucks to be rich in Carson City, Walla Walla, Omaha (Buffet is an idiot), Abeline, Kansas City, Pittsburg, Boise and all those other little sh!t towns built to serve wage workers. You're rich (or gonna be rich) - you wanna be in New York or Los Angeles. No you don't want to live in Honolulu. There's sh!t to there after a month. Chicago? San Fran? Why would you do that to yourself? Settle for second rate?

As for Pike, I don't think he is smoking a cohiba in private room service in the back of Manhattan's finest restaurants accompanied by models, actresses, minor celebrities. He's the buy buying T-bill and AAA bond mutual funds and cutting his own grass on weekends. Doesn't cheat on his wife. Money is a motivator for him but not the be all end all. My only worry is the day UConn comes knocking.
 
Rutgers is a REALLY hard job. It would be a huge career gamble for an established "very good" head coach to take this job at ANY price. Sure, you might get someone to humor the Rutgers administration in order to get a pay raise at their current school but that's about it. Pike is here and has competed with bluebloods like Indiana, Purdue, and Michigan State on even terms with inferior talent for several consecutive years now. To think that any other good coach could step in and not miss a beat is delusional. Just absurd that this comes up again and again from the same usual suspects. Just a complete lack of understanding of the college basketball landscape.
Why is Rutgers a really hard job in 2023? How many schools can offer a coach a better opportunity than Rutgers?
 
When you're banking $4mil a year, the price of eggs isn't a significant consideration. I've had this conversation with people over the years and I always tell them it sucks to be rich in Carson City, Walla Walla, Omaha (Buffet is an idiot), Abeline, Kansas City, Pittsburg, Boise and all those other little sh!t towns built to serve wage workers. You're rich (or gonna be rich) - you wanna be in New York or Los Angeles. No you don't want to live in Honolulu. There's sh!t to there after a month. Chicago? San Fran? Why would you do that to yourself? Settle for second rate?

As for Pike, I don't think he is smoking a cohiba in private room service in the back of Manhattan's finest restaurants accompanied by models, actresses, minor celebrities. He's the buy buying T-bill and AAA bond mutual funds and cutting his own grass on weekends. Doesn't cheat on his wife. Money is a motivator for him but not the be all end all. My only worry is the day UConn comes knocking.
Uconn had to pay big bucks to Kevin Ollie after firing him and Hurley is under contract through 2027
I doubt they could afford that any time soon
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes
I don’t know why anyone cares as long as the school is happy pay it and it keeps Pike happy and focused. Stability is underrated and undervalued. Recruits who are evaluating us know Pike is going to be there for their college careers, which is a big positive. And if we go back to cycling through coaches, it tends to be at least as expensive and potentially more so in the long run, especially because you have to replace all the assistants.

I really don’t understand how anyone could expect more than what Pike has delivered since he got here. There are only a handful of coaches that could have done as well or better than Pike has, and they were all largely unavailable to us at the time Pike was hired. I certainly have some criticisms of some of the coaching, but let’s be honest, the basketball skills of the players were willing to come here before the program had any success were very limited, and the success we have had with the level of talent we have had is stunning. The last several years we have been in contention every year for the Tournament with a team where hardly anyone on the team can shoot or drive to the basket. And with that success we now have better players coming in, and it will be interesting and fun to watch how Pike and the team evolve. He was also the right coach for the league we have been in. His rugged defensive style of play works well in the slow physical Big 10, and would have been less successful in a run and gun league like the Big 12.
 
Kyk originally predicted like 3 or 5 wins this year in conference and says we have a severe lack of talent but Pike is only good coach to get this many wins and is mad we didn't make it to the second week of the tournament.

Severe disconnect there

Dumpsterfire to now having multiple 5 stars committed and a potential super class coming in. The trajectory of the rebuild is absolutely unbelievable

If Pike can't make a tournament run once the increase in talent comes in, then you can reopen this discussion. Until then, appreciate the miracle ride we have been on since he got here
 
Kyk originally predicted like 3 or 5 wins this year in conference and says we have a severe lack of talent but Pike is only good coach to get this many wins and is mad we didn't make it to the second week of the tournament.

Severe disconnect there

Dumpsterfire to now having multiple 5 stars committed and a potential super class coming in. The trajectory of the rebuild is absolutely unbelievable

If Pike can't make a tournament run once the increase in talent comes in, then you can reopen this discussion. Until then, appreciate the miracle ride we have been on since he got here
I predicted 16-15 and 8-12 once the roster was set. I was two games off. Youre trying too hard again. Didnt you predict 22-9?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT