Man, Reppin- I already know you are a troll but man, you really take over a thread when you want too.
Neither Martin or Hicks are going to redshirt, unless there is an injury of some sort. Let's not be totally FB ignorant. And when it comes to RB- you never worry about a redshirt...if he is ready to play, you play him somewhere. Even if he only gets 10 carries during the year. And because of what you stated about the NFL and the use of RB's, it is even more reason to come out early. You know longer have an Emmitt Smith or these RB's that are going to go for 10+ years. Once a guy hits his mid 20's he is on the very far backend of his career. They also are not going to sign long term 4-5 mil per contracts so they best get started on their career as early as possible.
As for the knighted debate- it can only be a good thing. The way I see it...A player wants to be the first in his position group to get this honor. Then that players wants his position group to be the first to get the honor as a whole. That means the top players start assisting the lessor and younger guys all that much more.
Walk ons- yes, most know from day one that they may never see the field. But this gives them something tangible to work toward, even if it takes them 3-4 years to earn it.