Hit the nail on the head. These Ivy pseudo-intellectuals like the author and Dowling have no grasp of public universities in 2015. They just long for their days on campus and think every school should be modeled after a small New England private college.
This has nothing to do with Dowling-esque criticisms and everything to do with reality in 2015.
The American is half-decent for basketball, but not in the way of games that would interest UConn fans. But in football? It's a disaster. Far-flung, full of teams that aren't the most popular in their markets, it's just not good.
I have argued on here for a while that UConn and UMass should return to the Colonial (stop saying Yankee Conference, people; that was at least TWO incarnations ago) and battle UMaine and UNH in football, and seek admission to the Big East for all of their other sports. That gives you Providence, St. John's, Seton Hall as local rivals and brings back Villanova and Georgetown as traditional ones. I hardly think that qualifies as Dowling-esque.
In football, sure, you would be downgrading, but if you were competitive the crowds, while not as big as a successful FBS program, would be better than they will get if they continue on this course. Not to mention at that level, their facilities would be considered very good (apart from the actual stadium, which wouldn't seem as bad there either) and they should be able to out-recruit their New England rivals and contend for a playoff spot. I doubt the American's TV money is so awesome that they will screw themselves by leaving, and the Big East's basketball deal is not bad at all and would get better with UConn in it.
Branding people who are looking at ECONOMICS as "Ivy pseudo-intellectuals" who don't "grasp" public universities ignores so many things, but mainly one: Universities are NOT sports franchises, and not all of them are destined to be big-time players in athletics. We have been saying all along UConn is screwed by realignment, so you can't go and say that someone looking at the situation and realizing that and sensing they need to shift their vision is somehow tied to their desire for every school to be a "small New England private college." It's called reality, and what this board has been saying since the Big East broke up: UConn is in trouble. Staying the course is not viable.
Downgrading football while upgrading basketball is exactly what a school in UConn's position should do. Accepting that the investment is gone is far wiser than throwing good money after bad.