Most improved is shown on the field not on paper so we'll have to wait and see but it's always fun to make guesses.
From The Athletic mailbag today:
Your critique of Colorado’s recruiting is obviously not entirely negated by the late commitments we’ve seen (even with perhaps more to come), but isn’t Deion Sanders taking your “stars matter” doctrine as far as it can go for a non-top five program? The average rating of their commits is on a Penn State, LSU level. The quantity is just low. For a program like CU, isn’t it in line with “stars matter” to take fewer higher-impact recruits then build through the portal elsewhere? — Cole H.
There’s a lot to unpack here with your question, so let’s start with complimenting Sanders.
Colorado’s 2024 recruiting class includes 10 verbal commitments, and three are ranked in the top 100 nationally in the 247Sports Composite. One, of course, is five-star offensive tackle Jordan Seaton of Bradenton (Fla.) IMG Academy,
who committed to the Buffaloes last week after tricking the public by leaving Colorado off his final list.
That’s a really solid ratio of top-tier prospects — the caliber of players Colorado wouldn’t have landed in the past. That’s all Deion, and it’s why Colorado’s average player rating is 91.09, which, as you said, is on par with
Florida State (91.94),
Texas (91.99),
Miami (90.02),
Oregon (91.60),
Oklahoma (90.73) and many more.
But these numbers, though often insightful, can also be misleading and don’t tell the whole story. Yes, Colorado’s average player rating is high, but that’s because the class is small and the top-tier prospects carry more weight in that average than in other classes that include 20 or more commitments. It’s easier to have a higher average with fewer commitments, so though it looks like Colorado is doing the same thing as its peers, it isn’t.
That’s the main takeaway I have. Sanders has done an incredible job with the top half of his class, but it makes me wonder how good this group could have been if he lost himself completely in high school recruiting. Yes, he has a portal-heavy plan, and I understand that’s the goal, but does anyone think Sanders has taken a maniacal approach to recruiting like the coaches who win titles in this sport?