1) Wilmer may be shining by Mets standards, but not by NL standards, and that's what matters. His .773 OPS would place him 10th among NL first basemen.
2) So if all goes well MAYBE McNeil will be as good offensively as Cabrera was. Since the Mets sucked with Cabrera, that hardly gives me the warm and fuzzies.
3) If you're not going to blow it up, you MUST get SIGNIFICANT improvement from Rosario. Do you realize that his OWAR and DWAR are both negative? That means (if you put any stock in WAR) that we'd be better off with some random AAA shortshop. Incremental improvement will not be enough. Rosario must make a quantum leap in 2019, and I for one am not sure he's got it in him.
3) Frazier at third is what he is at this point of his career - an OK complementary player, but not the leading man the Mets need him to be.
4) The catching situation is OK if you are strong everywhere else. We ain't, therefore, it ain't. If the Mets are going to spend FA money on a catcher, which I doubt, I would look beyond Mesoraco.
5) Which takes us to the outfield and the other guy who must make a quantum leap. That is Conforto. Nimmo's production is acceptable. They need to fill out the OF with a big time free agent. They won't. Too much dead money on the books. I get that.
SO... I am not optimistic.