Schiano has failed to win a conference championship or make an upper tier bowl in 14 seasons at Rutgers. Pikiell has made the NCAA tournament twice (would have been three times if not for COVID).
Pike was gifted Dylan Harper and Ace Bailey and has continued to flounder in the portal. While I’m not high on Pike, I don’t want him fired. That being said, it’s a fair question to start asking. Basketball recruiting is nasty and don’t think the inner circles aren’t talking about what’s going on here.
While yes, Pike has done more, this will be 3 three years of missing the tournament and recruiting is trending the wrong way.
Meanwhile, Schiano has adapted and is having success landing guys in the portal. You can bring up conference records or what we did 3-4 years ago, but find me another coached who missed the top tournament with top 5 picks and kept his job for much longer