Hasn't being a Rutgers fan taught you anything? After every set of big wins comes an even bigger WTF loss!
2002 Basketball - After winning three straight against top 25 opponents late in the season and taking care of business against Seton Hall, Rutgers lost to VaTech to close out the regular season and BC in the first round of the BE Tourney to miss out on what should have been a shoe-in berth to the NCAA Tournament.
2004 Football - Beat Michigan State on opening day, lose to 1AA New Hampshire the following week.
2006 Football - Beat #3 Louisville to get to 9-0 and a top 10 ranking, lose to Cincinnati the following week.
These are just the first few examples that come to mind. I can keep going but I'll save myself and you the pain of reliving these awful memories... OK, I'll do one more.. after re-reading your post, you're going to need more convincing to pump the brakes.
2012 Football - Start the season 7-0, lose to Kent State at home.
That being said, I hope you're right! :)