ADVERTISEMENT

OT: 2024 NY Giants Season Thread

Jones looked like Brady compared to how DeVito is playing. What a ugly game by the Giants. If they play this ugly on Thanksgiving I really think Schoen and Daboll may be gone
 
Postman_1 said:
Jones looked like Brady compared to how DeVito is playing. What a ugly game by the Giants. If they play this ugly on Thanksgiving I really think Schoen and Daboll may be gone
Click to expand...

They may not make TO Thanksgiving.
 
Cutlets is 15 of 19 with no INTs and 3 sacks
8 straight completions
 
Last edited:
This team is worse than the 70s Giants
Can't believe how bad NY/NJ football is - now even Army is a con
 
Saquon runs for 255 yards and 2 TDs the week Jones is booted.
He added 47 yds receiving for 302 combined yards.
 
willisneverrana43 said:
I'm pretty sure that all Schoen needed to do was tag him for $12.5 or $13.5 for one year. And he didn't. Numbnuts.
Click to expand...
His base is 13.5 this year
For combined yards at this point in a season only Eric Dickerson had more.
He might end-up MVP and headed for Super Bowl

I watched the highlights and the OL is terrific.
Saquon gets a gap and he bursts through like a smaller Rice but he has long speed to leave defenders in the dust.
He hits full speed really quick.
He broke LeSean McCoy's record of 217 yards in a game
What an additional statement about how bad NYG's OLs have been.
 
How are Giant fans feeling today?

Management didn’t want to hand the ball off to a $14M RB. So that gave the money to the QB. A QB they flat out cut 9months later (paid to leave)

We are grateful E-A-G-L-E-S
 
ashokan said:
His base is 13.5 this year
For combined yards at this point in a season only Eric Dickerson had more.
He might end-up MVP and headed for Super Bowl

I watched the highlights and the OL is terrific.
Saquon gets a gap and he bursts through like a smaller Rice but he has long speed to leave defenders in the dust.
He hits full speed really quick.
He broke LeSean McCoy's record of 217 yards in a game
What an additional statement about how bad NYG's OLs have been.
Click to expand...
Definitely a combo of Saquan and the guys around him. It has been a perfect fit. Everyone just needs to stay healthy which is always the challenge in a long NFL season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 29PAS, mdk01 and ashokan
Hardslider21 said:
How are Giant fans feeling today?

Management didn’t want to hand the ball off to a $14M RB. So that gave the money to the QB. A QB they flat out cut 9months later (paid to leave)

We are grateful E-A-G-L-E-S
Click to expand...
They tried to sign him he turned it down. Then ended up playing on the tag. He wouldn’t have had this success in NY.
 
RUPete said:
Definitely a combo of Saquan and the guys around him. It has been a perfect fit. Everyone just needs to stay healthy which is always the challenge in a long NFL season.
Click to expand...
There's no comparing the Eagles offensive line to the woeful Giants O-line.
What a break for Barkley.
 
ashokan said:
The OL didn't help
A RB stuck still behind OL who cant move takes excessive body blows while stationary (no give).
The faster over the LOS the better.

For me (and people like Carl Banks) the pre-draft worry was being too heavily muscled from lifting.
The closer the muscles are to their max limits the more power is combined with proximity to weakness.
Benching 425 and squatting 600 means strong muscles that are also close to their point of failure.
That's even worse if players juiced and their overstrong muscles rip away from lagging tendons

Take a consumer car and drive it to its max speed all the time and you'll need a bunch of mechanics pretty soon.
Stanford reduced injuries over 70% when they went away from heavy max weights
Click to expand...
Umm Barkley is gonna be the mvp and probably an all time Philly great now
What the heck are you talking about ??
 
Plum Street said:
Umm Barkley is gonna be the mvp and probably an all time Philly great now
What the heck are you talking about ??
Click to expand...

I've not put SB down for his ability so I'm not sure what you are contesting.
Like NYG GM who drafted him, I considered SB a generational talent - I liked the pick.
However I was concerned about likely injures and that came true.
Barkley is on fire now but he's always one play away from another year of rehab.
He's a bit overpowered for his "envelope" and could always throw a rod.
A 230lb RB squatting 450lbs is fine for me - 600lbs and I'm "concerned."
 
Reportedly Dan Campbell is in year 3 or 4 of a 6 year deal paying $4 mill per year. I'm not sure how poaching is handled in the NFL but I'd look into it.
 
I heard stat during the game that NFL leader for INTs is ex-Giant Xavier McKinney.
He never missed a snap for NYGs in 2023.
Xavier McKinney and Saquon lost in same year while staring for others.
Can't say I wouldn't be happy to see the coaches and management head out.
Yesterday I saw the clip where Joe Schoen is trying to convince Mara of the "shrewd" move of getting rid of Saquon.

Mara looked unsold but I guess he dweebed-out

https://nypost.com/2024/11/26/sport...mock-john-mara-for-viral-saquon-barkley-clip/

bleacherreport.com

Xavier McKinney Makes Cryptic Posts amid Giants Drama: 'Get the F--k out My Faccceee'

Green Bay Packers safety Xavier McKinney is certainly feeling good after intercepting his seventh pass and tying for the league lead in his team's 38-10 win…
bleacherreport.com bleacherreport.com

​

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers NJ
The more games they play shows that Daniel Jones was not the problem. The team has so many weaknesses every player is dragged into a lower level of play.
 
tom1944 said:
The more games they play shows that Daniel Jones was not the problem. The team has so many weaknesses every player is dragged into a lower level of play.
Click to expand...
It's hard to figure how the offensive line could be THAT bad. Five positions and they have just gotten worse and worse at just about all of them.
 
Kbee3 said:
It's hard to figure how the offensive line could be THAT bad. Five positions and they have just gotten worse and worse at just about all of them.
Click to expand...

Losing Andrew Thomas was devastating. And it affected all of them.
 
These words coming from a rookie are brutal. His drop in the first Redskins game probably cost the Giants the game. How bout saying if the ball hits your hands you gotta catch it. Not a good look at all. Guy has more controversial comments lately then he does big plays.

 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rutgers NJ
Postman_1 said:
These words coming from a rookie are brutal. His drop in the first Redskins game probably cost the Giants the game. How bout saying if the ball hits your hands you gotta catch it. Not a good look at all. Guy has more controversial comments lately then he does big plays.

View embedded media
Click to expand...
He's turning into our very own d-bag. Somebody should have seen this kid's mouth and the NY media wouldn't be a good mix.
 
Pretty sure the giants won’t be on hard knocks again anytime soon . I don’t think there has been an organization that looked worse on that show .
 
Rutgers NJ said:
He's turning into our very own d-bag. Somebody should have seen this kid's mouth and the NY media wouldn't be a good mix.
Click to expand...
In the Giants sub on Reddit they are actually defending it lol. They are also defending Shedeur pushing the ref at the end of last weeks game because the ref missed calls. GTFO, both these instances are bad.


Plum Street said:
Pretty sure the giants won’t be on hard knocks again anytime soon . I don’t think there has been an organization that looked worse on that show .
Click to expand...
I heard no teams are gonna wanna do the "Off Season" version the Giants did. Say one thing wrong and you look like a fool tbh
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers NJ
Postman_1 said:
In the Giants sub on Reddit they are actually defending it lol. They are also defending Shedeur pushing the ref at the end of last weeks game because the ref missed calls. GTFO, both these instances are bad.



I heard no teams are gonna wanna do the "Off Season" version the Giants did. Say one thing wrong and you look like a fool tbh
Click to expand...
It’s gonna definitely get the GM and coach fired
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers NJ
rubaseball78 said:
It would be nice if Thomas played more than 5 games each year.
Click to expand...
Thomas is there most important offensive player. I believe on Talkin Giants they said they average 7.1 more points per game when he plays. Now on defense Dexter Lawrence may be out with a dislocated elbow. He is there most important defensive player. Just get this season over please
 
Postman_1 said:
These words coming from a rookie are brutal. His drop in the first Redskins game probably cost the Giants the game. How bout saying if the ball hits your hands you gotta catch it. Not a good look at all. Guy has more controversial comments lately then he does big plays.

View embedded media
Click to expand...
Well. I would advise them to keep throwing him the ball.
 
Plum Street said:
It’s gonna definitely get the GM and coach fired
Click to expand...
Overdue. Having to play Dallas in Dallas on Thanksgiving is just what the worst team in the NFL deserves.
And a new GM and a new coach is what the embarrassed Giants fans deserve.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
  • Poll

OT Poll: Which organization would you rather be: NY Giants or NY Jets

Replies
18
Views
695
Rutgers Football
NickRU714
N
Tango Two

Rutgers’ bowl destination, opponent seems clear after dominant finish to 2024 season

Replies
1
Views
800
Rutgers Football
RU at the shore
R
Richie O

Football Tracking Rutgers Football's TV ratings for the 2024 season

Replies
1
Views
333
Rutgers Football
Knight Shift
Knight Shift
Richie O

Football Rutgers Football Freshman Attendance Report - 2024 Regular Season

Replies
0
Views
365
Rutgers Football
Richie O
Richie O
Tango Two

Q&A with Rutgers QB Athan Kaliakmanis, who looks to close out an impactful 1st season

Replies
0
Views
159
Rutgers Football
Tango Two
Tango Two
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT
Top Bottom
Back