ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Fair Haven, NJ

Better off going into Red Bank for eateries with a bar. Too many to list.
Burger night at Nauvoo Grill Club is OK. Not a lively bar scene.
Raven and the Peach is supposed to be nice, never been there.
The main drag is River Road which takes you through Red Bank, Fair Haven, and Rumson.
The hot place in the area now is Tommy's in Sea Bright. Hard to get a table for dinner on any night.

Good List.

This is probably debatable, but the OP needs to hit Barnacle Bills if he wants the best burger in that area.

OP - go to Barnacles and order a bacon, cheddar burger with steak fries - Thank me later
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutgersJoe
If you have not hit it up recently, definitely go next year. Great food, great fun. Best Fireman's fair in the County, if not the whole State. From what I hear, they do really well on it too.

The Fair does very well, but the department members put a lot of time and effort into getting that fair up an running. You don't see many fairs anymore than run for 8 nights.

I haven't been in a few years, but I should go this year for Fireman's Night - ALWAYS a good time. I grew up about 5 blocks away from the FH Firehouse and you could hear the revelers from a mile away….not to mention the horns and sirens blaring from the fire trucks from all the different fire departments that would show up on Fireman's Night. Don't know if they do it anymore, but it was a great way to cap off every summer.
 
Pretty sure I read recently that Fromagerie has decided to close.
Fromagerie is diagonally across the street from me. Went once with the wife, and I thought it was just OK for the price. I heard it was starting to slide in the last year or two. They look like they are getting ready to open real soon. New paint, stonework on front, signage.

And to rutgersdave, most people in these parts love living in New Jersey. Monmouth County is awesome. Farms to the west, ocean and beaches on the east, awesome State and County parks, and generally friendly people. I tell my kids frequently that they live in such a wonderful place.
 
Fromagerie has closed. Very suddenly a short time ago. Overnight they locked the doors and left.

I worked there when the Peter's owned it. Good food fun working there. The Peter's kids place for MHS yeh?
 
And to rutgersdave, most people in these parts love living in New Jersey. Monmouth County is awesome. Farms to the west, ocean and beaches on the east, awesome State and County parks, and generally friendly people. I tell my kids frequently that they live in such a wonderful place.
From the boardwalk in Spring Lake while watching my sons (and the rest of the class - boys and girls) go thru their junior lifeguard training a little old lady to nobody in particular, "Do you think they realize how lucky they are?"
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUinPinehurst
I worked there when the Peter's owned it. Good food fun working there. The Peter's kids place for MHS yeh?
When Red Bank Green ran the story that it was closing , there were several comments to the story that said how it was much better when it was owned by the Peters:
http://www.redbankgreen.com/2015/10/rumson-fromagerie-says-adieu/#respond

The counterpart to the Fromagerie in Sea Bright, Harry's Lobster House, which was long past its prime also recently closed.

Definitely hit Woody's in Sea Bright.
 
Zoe's Bistro in Little Silver is very good too. Did any of you RFH guys play football? They are trying to put together an Alumni football game, full pads, Shore Regional vs. RFH.
 
I moved to Fair Haven about a year ago also from Hoboken. We have been very happy here so far. The area has a lot to offer as many people have mentioned. I also do the commute to downtown Manhattan which is a manageable commute but very expensive. If you have any questions feel free to email me at rutgers33@yahoo.com. Good luck with everything.
 
molly maguires to reopen as shore bbq - under vic rallo ownership. fromagerie is closed - not sure if it will be the same style.

good place for news and info in area is word on the shore.
 
We mentioned Brennan's Deli before, and it is excellent, but the OP will find the Fair Haven has an excellent deli of it's own in the Fairwinds Deli right on river road. Warren Abrahamson who owns and runs it is a former student of mine in Holmdel HS. I can walk down the street to Brennan's but I go to Fairwinds just as often. The peninsula has good eateries.
 
molly maguires to reopen as shore bbq - under vic rallo ownership. fromagerie is closed - not sure if it will be the same style.

good place for news and info in area is word on the shore.

The place will be Surf BBQ (not shore bbq). Rallo is not the sole owner. The Diaco family is going in with him, same as with Unidici (the old Hook Line and Sinker) on River Road. Vic Rallo graduated Seton Hall Law School. Back when FM 106.3 was still on the air, I used to hear his commercials for Basil T's (now Birravino) several times a day. He has a very deep and distinctive voice. We had a fire call at Unidici when it first opened, and I remember running into Vic. I was expecting someone much taller to go with the voice. Here's a story on the new venture (it looks like it is close to opening--pass it every day on the way to work):
http://www.redbankgreen.com/2015/10/rumson-rallo-to-open-surf-bbq-here/#more-100406
 
The place will be Surf BBQ (not shore bbq). Rallo is not the sole owner. The Diaco family is going in with him, same as with *Unidici (the old Hook Line and Sinker) on River Road. Vic Rallo graduated Seton Hall Law School. Back when FM 106.3 was still on the air, I used to hear his commercials for Basil T's (now Birravino) several times a day. He has a very deep and distinctive voice. We had a fire call at Unidici when it first opened, and I remember running into Vic. I was expecting someone much taller to go with the voice. Here's a story on the new venture (it looks like it is close to opening--pass it every day on the way to work):
http://www.redbankgreen.com/2015/10/rumson-rallo-to-open-surf-bbq-here/#more-100406
Was that where the Varsity used to be?
 
It was Briody's when we moved here in 2005, and it had been Briody's for a long time before that. On the corner of Blackpoint and East River Road, across from station 42-2.
I am thinking of somewhere else then...in Fair Haven off the main road and not Rumson.

I know Briody's very well. Was my Dad's older brother hang out when it was in Jersey City and our stop off on the way home to Middletown from the Peninsula House as a kid...bar pie and a coke. LOL
 
I am thinking of somewhere else then...in Fair Haven off the main road and not Rumson.

I know Briody's very well. Was my Dad's older brother hang out when it was in Jersey City and our stop off on the way home to Middletown from the Peninsula House as a kid...bar pie and a coke. LOL

I think you are referring to The Varsity Club, which used to be on Fair Haven Rd. in Fair Haven - near the intersection of FH Road and River Road (next to Sickles Elementary School). Prior to becoming the Varsity Club it was called the Lock Stock and Barrell, which Springsteen and members of the E Street Band would hit for dinner in the early 1970s.

After a very extensive remodeling effort, the forming building was transformed into the Nauvoo restaurant.

I worked at the Varsity Club as a bus boy and waiter when I was in high school.
 
I think you are referring to The Varsity Club, which used to be on Fair Haven Rd. in Fair Haven - near the intersection of FH Road and River Road (next to Sickles Elementary School). Prior to becoming the Varsity Club it was called the Lock Stock and Barrel, which Springsteen and members of the E Street Band would hit for dinner in the early 1970s.

After a very extensive remodeling effort, the forming building was transformed into the Nauvoo restaurant.

I worked at the Varsity Club as a bus boy and waiter when I was in high school.
Yes. Because of the long three part name I got it confused with Hook, Line and Sinker.

My brother and I along with our friends used to go there way back when around the time ESPN started the Sunday night NFL games.
 
To the OP- make the move.

I'm in red bank. Almost every new resident I encounter is from either hoboken or JC. It's a great area.
Restaurant wise here's my favorites right now
B2 Bistro in Red Bank- one of the best burgers you will ever eat anywhere. Amazing cocktails & beer list as well. No millercoorsbud crap on tap, only microbrews, crafts & good imports
Zoe Bistro in Little Silver- new chef owner who is making it rain over there. I usually order off of whatever is on special.
Barnacle bills. Always a good burger. Their dogs are under appreciated.
Tommys Tavern in Sea Bright is crap. 2 hour waits for poor service and mediocre product... If you even get your food
Tramas Trattoria in Long Branch is heaven. Best mussels around!
Little Szechuan has killer takeout Chinese.
Temple has the best filet mignon around
Copper Canyon has the best steak at the shore

I could go on with more, nut I'm getting hugry and it's 730
 
To the OP- make the move.

Tommys Tavern in Sea Bright is crap. 2 hour waits for poor service and mediocre product... If you even get your food
Tramas Trattoria in Long Branch is heaven. Best mussels around!
Went to Tommy's in the early fall for lunch. My crabcake sucked, and my son's burger was not great. I was told by several it is much better now. Problem is, every time we have tried to go, there is a long wait. It's noisy in there. Not my kind of place.

Trama's -pretty sure this is the original chef from Ama, which was in Altantic Highlands, now in Sea Bright--have heard great things.

Speaking of Atlantic Highlands, the space previously occupied by Ama is Cristines--fabulous. Atlantic Highlands is a great little town. The Lamp Light is good for bar food and craft beers.
 
I just wanted to thank everyone again for the input. This thread was incredibly helpful and increased my overall comfort level and added to my excitement. This board is the best for stuff like this. Thanks again, and hope to catch an RU road game with some of you guys soon at a local bar.
 
About 25 yrs ago my brother and I along with our friends used to do that for Giant games at the Globe.

Still around, the Globe?
http://www.thegloberedbank.com/

2de7fd_89400e020962f36964d7c9b4dbc9fe4a.jpg
 
agree on Tommys in the Galleria - good food - usually hard to get space at the bar.

MJ's in Tinton Falls is a good place for football watching - nice large screen - lot of good viewing space.
 
I live in Red Bank. I grew up in Middletown, so have been in the area most of my life. As most of the other posters on this thread have said, you are hitting a home run in coming to this area. I do not know all the ins and outs regarding Fair Haven, but it is a lovely town and the schools have a great reputation. The Eastern Monmouth County area is a great place to live. There is so much here, with the proximity to the beaches, NYC, even Philly. We have theater and arts, every type of food and retail establishment you could think of (both the big chains for convenience as well as a host of cool and excellent local places). This part of NJ is beautiful as well and is right in my wheelhouse as far as being not too crowded and not too sleepy. The commute on the ferry to 111 Wall Street is the fastest, and prettiest way to do it, although it is costly. But if the finances work it beats the train hands down. I have done both. I have since escaped the city for work, but as long as you are doing it, the ferry works well. I think you will love it here. All the best!
 
first found the event distasteful and really out of character with the area. thought the event was a one off- really do not believe it to be material and find it as shock value on this string.
 
Good List.

This is probably debatable, but the OP needs to hit Barnacle Bills if he wants the best burger in that area.

OP - go to Barnacles and order a bacon, cheddar burger with steak fries - Thank me later
I always order the cheddar on the side and use it for the fries and burger without the burger swimming in it.
 
The original poster is a great guy that I've helped in the past.....he has found a great house as well. I have a streak of some sorts where I've done a mortgage for someone in Fair Haven for 3 straight years, this one would extend that streak to 4 years in a row if everything works out!!!

Rates have been falling all week with the stock market/oil markets in flux. It's also great time to refinance an existing mortgage if you have rates over 4.5% in most cases. Rates are pushing down to under 3.5%, if you have a "Jumbo" mortgage that exceeds 625K in most of the tri-state area.

KingHigh and I are finalizing a closing for another board member here today as well. Always good to hear from RU fans over the years with real estate or mortgage referrals or recommendations for friends etc, even if they have their mortgage situation covered....send anyone else that is in the market over to me, they'll be in great hands!!......email is gginn@myinvestorsbank.com.....or call my cell that has been on this board now for a few years....(732) 742-4367.

Go RU.....!!
 
I live in Rumson. Fair Haven and Rumson share the same high school. I coach baseball and soccer, and I envy the programs they have in Fair Haven. I also like their downtown (Rumson does not really have one). Closer proximity to Red Bank is a plus too. Don't really see any negatives or downsides. Given the choice to do it again, we would have picked Fair Haven over Rumson. You will love the annual Fair Haven Fireman's fair which is the last week before Labor Day every summer.
Are you going to take the Ferry from Highlands or Atlantic Highlands?
A couple of local parks/sites that are worth checking out are:
1. Hartshorne Woods--go to the entrance at the top of Portland Road-- great views, and an old military battery on the top of the hill; Outstanding hiking and mountain biking trails.
2. Twin Lights in Highlands- you can go to the top of the lighthouse.
3. Mt Mitchill park in Atlantic Highlands/Highlands--spectacular views of Sandy Hook and NYC
4. Sandy Hook. Great paved trail for running, biking etc, and lots of interesting military buildings and artifacts.
5. Huber Woods in Middletown- nice wooded trails and a learning center and a cool reptile house.

Good luck with the move. If you need a local attorney, Brooks von Arx is a good real estate attorney.
this IS THE TYPE OF STUFF i love TO SEE POSTED HERE!!!

In searching for a fall area to stay for our NE yearly trips from Fla>>>>we could have stayed anywhere>>>this area is where we have chosen !!

Has EVERYTHINg we need.....hike n bike trails and the FERRY to NY loomed large !
 
To the OP- make the move.

I'm in red bank. Almost every new resident I encounter is from either hoboken or JC. It's a great area.
Restaurant wise here's my favorites right now
B2 Bistro in Red Bank- one of the best burgers you will ever eat anywhere. Amazing cocktails & beer list as well. No millercoorsbud crap on tap, only microbrews, crafts & good imports
Zoe Bistro in Little Silver- new chef owner who is making it rain over there. I usually order off of whatever is on special.
Barnacle bills. Always a good burger. Their dogs are under appreciated.
Tommys Tavern in Sea Bright is crap. 2 hour waits for poor service and mediocre product... If you even get your food
Tramas Trattoria in Long Branch is heaven. Best mussels around!
Little Szechuan has killer takeout Chinese.
Temple has the best filet mignon around
Copper Canyon has the best steak at the shore

I could go on with more, nut I'm getting hugry and it's 730


How are we not best friends in real life? Arrested Development fan living in Red Bank who loves Rutgers football?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bob-loblaw
From the boardwalk in Spring Lake while watching my sons (and the rest of the class - boys and girls) go thru their junior lifeguard training a little old lady to nobody in particular, "Do you think they realize how lucky they are?"
They don't know it now, but they will. I grew up next door, in Sea Girt, and I had zero idea how lucky I was. Nor did any of my friends. But we all look back now, many years later, and just shake our heads at how fortunate we were. It was an idyllic existence.
 
They don't know it now, but they will. I grew up next door, in Sea Girt, and I had zero idea how lucky I was. Nor did any of my friends. But we all look back now, many years later, and just shake our heads at how fortunate we were. It was an idyllic existence.
Parents still there half the year and sister with her family lives there now. As did I for a bit.

I'm lucky in the fact I think my guys (15 and 12) get it.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT