We all agree that our basketball transfers stink. The disconnect is how good are our football transfers? We can cherry-pick players here and there, but it doesn’t really mean anything. I could easily post that I have faith in Pikiell because he recruited Cam Spencer, who is better than any transfer Schiano brought in, because Spencer is actually playing in the show.
How can tape of lower conference transfers going up against other lower conference players, prove effectiveness in the Big Ten? Come on! To exaggerate the point, Savon Huggins looked all world in high school, but wasn’t that good at Rutgers.
You can say you have faith in Schiano’s ability to identify talent, and that would be acceptable.
But At least some of the Big Ten players they will be going up against will be playing in the NFL. So for me the jury is out on how effective these players will be, though I appreciate that you think these players will be good.