Sure there are - but even within NJ they are much rarer than the other case (since elite students are also statistically richer students) and outside of NJ even in neighboring states it would be unicorn territory. If you were right, then given our states extremely talented student population, RU would be a top 50 school with ease.
We are a Top 50 school!
CUWR ranked us 33rd in the world. (See the other thread for a discussion about this ranking system versus US New and World Report)
We have a Top 3 Philosophy program in the nation.
Our business school was ranked the 9th best value in the nation by Fortune (or Forbes I forget)
Our Supply Chain Management program is Top 10 in the nation.
Governor Christie designated Rutgers the Supercomputer hub for the state and we also have the 10th most powerful academic supercomputer IN THE WORLD!
And that is just off the top of my head from my own experiences.
I assume our sciences have to be top rated because I am always hearing about our sciences and all that.
And I am not saying anyone specifically, but in general I think some people are still basing their opinion on Rutgers on how things were there 20-30 years ago. A LOT has changed in the past 30 years at Rutgers.