This needs to be addressed: Gavin Wimsatt ≠ Art Sitkowski
- The Round Table
- 38 Replies
I’ve seen this comparison many times over the past 24 hrs. Let me be clear:
They are not even in the same stratosphere of each other. Art made legitimately 0 progress in his time here. He barely, very rarely ever showed flashes of being able to be good. He threw so many bad interceptions his freshman year - 18 to be exact. (Penn State comes to mind where he threw it up to their safety with no one from RU within 30 yards).
Gavin is making very clear progression. First half is a good example (Art never once had a half like that and certainly not against a top 3 defense PERIOD.) The progess he has made from Wagner until now is good. He commands the offense , can rattle off multiple good throws in a row and looks to be very comfortable. Last night showed more than just flashes. He is a legit QB that is young and needs to grow into the role AND THAT OKAY. We need to allow him to grow and evaluate his games with nuance.
There is nothing in his game that is unfixable. And no, he isnt this completely innacurate unfixable quarterback. Throwing high is fixable and you see it often in young qb’s. Of his 3 picks last night:
1) Freshman mistake. Got baited into thinking he was throwing into cover 2 when they were in a soft cover 4. Correctable and will come with maturity and seeing more defenses.
2) Threw a ripper to Cruickshank that shouldve been caught and he was unprepared to get the football. Teachable moment is to take some juice off the football on shorter throws.
3) This was an option route to the backside where Gavin makes the call to a speed out, hitch, fade or slant. He opted for the fade, probably shouldve thrown outside but at that point it made no difference.
Michigan pinned their ears back in the 3rd quarter and it impacted him because he has not seen that ONCE like that at this level of football.
Everyone relax and let the kid develop. Maybe he is or isnt the answer but the sky is falling crowd about GW need to take a breather, have a beer, smoke cig whatever you need to do to relax!
They are not even in the same stratosphere of each other. Art made legitimately 0 progress in his time here. He barely, very rarely ever showed flashes of being able to be good. He threw so many bad interceptions his freshman year - 18 to be exact. (Penn State comes to mind where he threw it up to their safety with no one from RU within 30 yards).
Gavin is making very clear progression. First half is a good example (Art never once had a half like that and certainly not against a top 3 defense PERIOD.) The progess he has made from Wagner until now is good. He commands the offense , can rattle off multiple good throws in a row and looks to be very comfortable. Last night showed more than just flashes. He is a legit QB that is young and needs to grow into the role AND THAT OKAY. We need to allow him to grow and evaluate his games with nuance.
There is nothing in his game that is unfixable. And no, he isnt this completely innacurate unfixable quarterback. Throwing high is fixable and you see it often in young qb’s. Of his 3 picks last night:
1) Freshman mistake. Got baited into thinking he was throwing into cover 2 when they were in a soft cover 4. Correctable and will come with maturity and seeing more defenses.
2) Threw a ripper to Cruickshank that shouldve been caught and he was unprepared to get the football. Teachable moment is to take some juice off the football on shorter throws.
3) This was an option route to the backside where Gavin makes the call to a speed out, hitch, fade or slant. He opted for the fade, probably shouldve thrown outside but at that point it made no difference.
Michigan pinned their ears back in the 3rd quarter and it impacted him because he has not seen that ONCE like that at this level of football.
Everyone relax and let the kid develop. Maybe he is or isnt the answer but the sky is falling crowd about GW need to take a breather, have a beer, smoke cig whatever you need to do to relax!