Major update. Still got more to add.
SG Ethan Wright, Princeton (6'4" 190) - Wright was one of the more efficient guys in the Ivy League this past season... he seems like a solid option but maybe not the best we could get. He's a good shooter but not a great one (39% on threes last season, 37% for his career) and doesn't bring a ton else to the table. He was a good rebounder in the Ivy League but I can't imagine that's going to transfer to the Big Ten at his size. He's not really a ballhandler or facilitator. And he had the luxury of playing with two of the best players in the Ivy League in Tosan Evuomwan and Jaelin Llewellyn (plus two other sharpshooters, both over 40% from 3, in Drew Friberg and Ryan Langborg). So I can't help but feel he's maybe not as well-positioned for success as it may seem.
PG Andre Curbelo, Illinois (6'1" 175) - In my opinion Curbelo is exactly the sort of guy Rutgers should be going after: a former highly-rated recruit who has already produced at a high level (Big Ten 6th man of the year as a freshman) but is a buy-low candidate coming off a season where injuries totally prevented him from building anything. To be clear, there are some major drawbacks to his game (outside shooting and turnovers) but is a potential gamechanger as a primary ballhandler. Like, he could be the best PG in the Big Ten. That's not a crazy take. My hunch is that the Rutgers staff would have very little interest in him given his bust potential, which is fine. Curbelo is a guy I'd love to take a chance on, but I'd also love if he went to SHU and then I could root for him to wreck that offense. Just a really fascinating edge case.
PG Joe Toussaint, Iowa (6'0" 190) - He's strong, he's stocky, he's fast, he's a good defender... but I'm not sure he's much of a helpful asset overall. He can't hit a jumpshot and, unlike Curbelo, doesn't really get to the rim. His athleticism and footspeed doesn't translate into layups the way it does for Curbelo. He's originally from the Bronx but for three years he's been an inefficient player in Iowa's offense and frankly if you can't be efficient when you're surrounded by Luka Garza, Jordan Bohannon, the Murray twins, Wieskamp then I have grave concerns about your ability to lead a Big Ten offense without any players of that caliber. He's a pass for me.
PG Rahsool Diggins, UConn (6'2" 175) - A Philadelphia guy who got an offer from Rutgers but doesn't seem to have seriously considered us. He did basically nothing at UConn, only playing in garbage time, but I'd absolutely take a chance on a former top-60 recruit.
G/F Shane Dezonie, Vanderbilt (6'5" 215) - Another former Rutgers offeree who played at Hudson Catholic before finishing his career at a New Hampshire prep school. Originally signed with Arizona, then switched to Vanderbilt with the Wildcats coaching change. He didn't play much for the 'Dores but he did make 14 of 25 three pointers attempted. Ranked #100 in his class at the time.
PG Jao Ituka, Marist (6'1" 196) - He was lightly recruited despite playing with Jordan Hawkins (UConn) in high school but he was incredible at Marist considering his insanely high usage. He was one of the best players in the country at getting to the free throw line, an efficient scorer on two pointers, and even hit 41% of his three pointers although he only attempted 39 of them. He's got a ways to go in terms of distributing but the prospect of playing him along with Paul Mulcahy is very, very enticing.
PG Camren Wynter, Drexel (6'2" 185) - A four year starter originally from New York, Wynter has been an iron man and among the nation's leaders in minutes played in his career. That's made it hard to him to truly maximize his efficiency but over his career he's shown off his skills as a distributor and a shooter, although the shot has come and gone -- only 28% from 3 as a senior. Still, I love that he's been a floor general for four seasons and he led the CAA in assist rate the past two years.
PG Dashawn Davis, Oregon State (6'2" 185) - Ordinarily I would not have much interest in the PG of a team that went 3-29, but the talent around Davis was just so terrible that his average numbers actually look decent with the context. He led the Pac-12 in assist rate and was a solid scorer inside (54%). The big drawback to his game was his three point shooting, where he went 9-48. But Davis, a New York native who originally committed to Seton Hall before going the JUCO route, was a decent shooter at that JUCO. If he can bump that number to 30% (still bad) while maintaining the rest of his game, he'd be a very solid option.
PG Isaiah Thompson, Purdue (6'1" 160) - He's probably not a good fit for Rutgers because I don't like his defense or his ability to lead a Big Ten offense -- his minutes got seriously cut down the stretch for Purdue. But if the staff is on the prowl for a shooter they could do a lot worse than Thompson who's at 39% for his career.
SG Tyreke Key, Indiana State (6'3" 205) - I'm putting pretty low odds that Rutgers would be able to get into the mix for the Tennessee native but he was a dynamic scorer at Indiana State before missing the 2021-22 season with shoulder surgery. He was teammates at ISU with Jake LaRavia who just had a fantastic season at Wake Forest.
G/F Cam Spencer, Loyola Maryland (6'4" 207) - Spencer was maybe the Patriot League's best player last season, filling the stat sheet as a great scorer but also throwing in some assists and some defense as well. He's a 39% career three point shooter and he's been good inside the arc, too. How that translates to major college basketball is a legit question but he'll have a long list of teams interested.
SG Michael Jones, Davidson (6'5" 210) - A shooter from Big Ten country (Minnesota), Jones is over 40% from three for his career. He's sort of limited in what he can do and the offensive system at Davidson is practically tailor-made to make guys like him look good, but he has enough game and is a good enough shooter to carve out a role on a high major.
C Wildens Leveque, South Carolina (6'10" 255) - The big man is a Massachussetts native so there's a good chance he follows former SCar coach Frank Martin to UMass. Probably doubtful that he's looking for a backup role, but for those looking for a Shaq Carter type, he's your man. He's a pretty good scorer, but not a go-to guy. He's only an okay rebounder, a bad foul shooter, but he'll block some shots. He'd be a very good option as a backup center but with Cliff and Reiber it doesn't feel like Rutgers would be very appealing to him.