In the other thread we're talking about how Simpson's late-season surge last year was fool's gold. Beware.
GAME 26 PURDUE : Flush it
- Thread starter bac2therac
- Start date
You are not being realistic.....he is not the player you imagine him to be. He is injury prone OR someone who now has an ACL a year ago and now is not able to play, because of the other leg/knee.
It is about watching games across the conference and he is not a player that no one else has on their roster elsewhere. The item of his value was overblown last year and is being exaggerated yet again this year.
If we are being fair, when he returned, he had some effective games and games where his play or impact was very minor on both ends of the court. There wasn't any major change in how RU performed when he returned on offense, defense or rebounding.
The type of impact that fans are programmed to think of Mag, is what we got with Jeremiah Williams hitting the lineup. There is a clear and distinct impact that is very clear or easy to see. We didn't get that level of impact when Mag returned.
What is your plan, if Mag doesn't start games next year or starts asking out of workouts and training this spring and summer?? What contingency plan do you have??
My contingency plans involve Lathan Sommerville, Bryce Dortch, Dylan Grant and Ace Bailey all playing minutes at the forward positions or Lathan being the 5 as well. They all don't have to start, but I would imagine a scenario where Sommerville Dortch and Grant, battle in practice for minutes and playing time.
The other major item that we don't get from Mag IF he doesn't play lights out defense....he's not a 3 point threat. I have 12 for 46 from 3 this year....9 for 30 last year.....4 for 17 as a sophomore. And 1 of 3 as a frosh, which kinda was a redshirt season in theory.
26 for 96 career is not anything that helps the offense....if he's not as mobile or active defensively this year AND we get no consistent threat of offense from 3 or off the dribble, we can get a better player to play those minutes.
As much as you want to go against me and others on Hyatt and Simpson, they at least are threats to score.....and you harp on Simpson and his shooting.....if Simpson plays as good an amount of defense and pressure on the ball as Mag does as a sophomore, why don't we see the same praise for Simpson on his defense (which if you are watching the games, is miles better than Mag)???
Simpson is a better shooter than Mag from 3....what am I missing?? If you are in such a hurry to bury Simpson, at least explain why Mag gets a free pass??
What does Mag do better than Simpson does?? He's not a better defender in February 2024, Simpson is a better shooter and playmaker.....AND I am 100% advocating for Simpson to be the 3rd or 4th guard next year, yet, you and others blinded by the Mag narrative, want him to continue to start???
frontcourt players need the backcourt ball handlers to get them the ball in good position to score just like a WR needs a QB. Who is our basketball QB ? We don’t have one who elevates the others. The problem lies entirely in the backcourt. GG, Hyatt, Mag can’t ever get the ball with a good opportunity to score and are forced into late iso plays too. All three would be much better if we had a real PG and not Simpson or Williams dominating the ball and taking too many shots.
The roster doesn’t have complementary backcourt pieces, and what’s missing most is a serviceable PG. Noah could be that but his D limitations keep him a reserve.
JWill is an iso player, who does play within his skill set in the lane. Simpson is an iso mid range guy who just isn’t good at that. His offensive game is brutal. He’s a black hole, a high volume ‘misser’ as opposed to ‘shooter’ The Derek Selfish shitshow has to stop for the frontcourt players to be productive. I hope that’s the message Pike was delivering by benching him Wednesday. He’s the furthest thing from a team player and sucks the life out of the offense.
The roster doesn’t have complementary backcourt pieces, and what’s missing most is a serviceable PG. Noah could be that but his D limitations keep him a reserve.
JWill is an iso player, who does play within his skill set in the lane. Simpson is an iso mid range guy who just isn’t good at that. His offensive game is brutal. He’s a black hole, a high volume ‘misser’ as opposed to ‘shooter’ The Derek Selfish shitshow has to stop for the frontcourt players to be productive. I hope that’s the message Pike was delivering by benching him Wednesday. He’s the furthest thing from a team player and sucks the life out of the offense.
Last edited:
We bring our D game and they bring their A game. It happens. In fact, it's inevitable that a certain percent of games will be like this. That's why winning 5 of 7 in this league to finish the season was always a tall order. If we'd had this team from the start, we'd be comfortably on the right side of the bubble. This team is good enough to make the tournament over the course of the season, but not good enough to win 5-6 in a row, including those games where they don't play well.
Rutgers has a lot of talent coming next season. I think they'll all contribute.
Should be a season to remember.
Bryce Dortch is like the third guy on his high school team and Dylan Grant isn't even playing right now. Counting on them as positive Big Ten contributors as freshman is wild.
Grant is ranked among the Top 150 high school seniors in the country.
Dortch is ranked not too far below that level.
BTW, Terry Dehere was probably the third best player on what was Bob Hurley's best team at St. Anthony's back in the day. Of course that was behind Bobby Hurley and Jerry Walker.
Given what we've got returning next season I'm expecting both Dortch and Grant to make contributions as freshmen.
It was Gavin's ranking that caused me and other Rutgers fans to have such high expectations for what he would bring to the team this season. It's Dortch and Grant's ranking that has me and some other Rutgers fans to have expectations for those two to make contributions to next year's team....although not as high as our expectations were for Gavin.
In sports sometimes kids live up to expectations....sometimes they don't.
I mentioned it pregame: a scrambling, help-rotating defense isn't good against a very good 3pt shooting team.
You can't leave good shooters open.
Purdue reminded me of a NBA game.
People complain about the lack to NBA defense, but it's because their is little help defense.
Most every NBA team has 2-3 players on the floor every minute that can shoot better than the Purdue guys.
If you leave your man, the ballnis getting swung out and around for an open shot.
Small PGs aren't trying to dunk over taller guys and turning the ball over.
You can't help on drives and pray good shooters miss.
That works in college against most teams because they'll miss open shots.
You can't leave good shooters open.
Purdue reminded me of a NBA game.
People complain about the lack to NBA defense, but it's because their is little help defense.
Most every NBA team has 2-3 players on the floor every minute that can shoot better than the Purdue guys.
If you leave your man, the ballnis getting swung out and around for an open shot.
Small PGs aren't trying to dunk over taller guys and turning the ball over.
You can't help on drives and pray good shooters miss.
That works in college against most teams because they'll miss open shots.
Similar threads
