Artur Had zero help that game from his supporting cast. Our ol was garbage and our WRs were garbage. I was there.
James Kratch says Art likely starts
- Thread starter rutgersal
- Start date
Artur Had zero help that game from his supporting cast. Our ol was garbage and our WRs were garbage. I was there.
Nova!!! If that's our gold standard we are in worse trouble than I thought.
Too bad that Bad Gary suppressed Good Gary quite a bit
Hey!
I thought we were getting along the last couple of years lol.:Heart
But yeah. That was my point.
Please don't call our student athletes "garbage," it is about as classless as you can get, just awful. These are young men who are putting their health on the line 12 Saturdays in the fall for your entertainment and you have the gall to call them "garbage." Who the hell are you to judge anyone? Grow up and get a life!!
He didn't play well at IMG. OMG, please make it stop. All these excuses for Sitkowski.
We get along fine :Heart no :BrokenHeart for us :WideSmile:
Glad to find I was right about what you said.:ThumbsUp
Our student athletes are not garbage but their performance was garbage. Hope that clears things up.
Maybe Art has a really bad ragweed allergy. Explains how he looks good early in camp but when it really kicks in around September maybe he's sneezing all the time and his eyes are watery and itchy and he can't see his targets as well. He got better last year later in the season when pollen counts came down.
Art is actually closer to Snyder than Carter. Unfortunately, McNulty is infatuated with his NFL arm.
If anyone had the 'pleasure' of witnessing that in person, let me just say it was akin to watching....well, hard to compare to most anything but a multi-car wreck on the highway. I'm hoping that was the bottom and he only goes up from there. We'll see.
Of course these kids are a hundred times better players then we fans are. But that is not the point.
Good Gary/Bad Gary was a real thing. Overall Gary? As a senior he was decent. 1,000,000 times a better football player then myself, but as a D-1 college QB? Decent.
Carter needs to play. They should be able to design rollouts and use some run-pass option stuff with him. If Art was on Ohio State right now he might put up decent numbers...being able to sit back there all day to throw to open 5 star receivers.
I root for Art but I can't figure out why the guy who threw bomb after bomb to Bo Melton that Spring Scrimmage not only can't complete long passes but seems almost afraid to let it fly. Based on game tape and the scrimmage Carter may not have Art's arm talent but he seems to have a good feel for the deep ball. Kind of reminds me of Chad Pennington. Didn't have a cannon but consistently was at or near the top of the NFL on long balls.
If McNulty's offense is run heavy and take deep shots, Carter may be the better fit.
I hope someone grabs the job and its not a case of one is less bad than the other.
If McNulty's offense is run heavy and take deep shots, Carter may be the better fit.
I hope someone grabs the job and its not a case of one is less bad than the other.
From one I’ve seen, it’s definitely going to be the case of one less bad than the other, but either should give us a punchers chance against non elite competition.
I think so, but admittedly cannot fully recall. Art showed talent, but also showed me he was pressing and overthinking matters. This is where I thought McNulty shouldered some blame as he needed to simplify more for Art. In addition, I keep harping on the receivers, who did not step up. I don't think we won any 50/50 balls all season.
There was a nice throw to Washington in the first game for a TD that was called back. After that I can’t think of any other impressive throw. Everything else was dink and dunk or interceptions.
I mean, he did take OB to a state championship as a sophomore while running an spread option.
I think everyone needs to spend time watching the WRs and O-line as well. This unit was awful as a whole. My friend and I spent the entire Northwestern game watching a WR on each side. We couldn't find one play where a non-slot WR had any separation.
If cratch is looking for rhymes I.E, Art and Start. He has to look no farther than Carter and Starter .
I dont care if this sound harsh. ART would not be a good D3 qb let alone D1. If you cant see the field arm strength, character, nice kid, hard worker etc is all irrelevant. I was at the open practice. He simply locks in on one reciever or one side of the field. It is impossible to succeed if you cant sit back in the pocket and see the whole field. It is why he constantly has to check down and cant make plays.
That was me rhymmin' not Kratch, lol. But he's welcome to borrow it, I'm not trademarking it like Ohio St is doing w the word 'The', lol.
Kratch is using false logic.
He thinks that Art must falter to allow someone else to take the starting role.
Problem is that Art never really solidified his position as starter.
Just the opposite, really.
He is currently the No. 1 QB out of courtesy, since he is the lone returning QB from last year.
Carter should start.
He thinks that Art must falter to allow someone else to take the starting role.
Problem is that Art never really solidified his position as starter.
Just the opposite, really.
He is currently the No. 1 QB out of courtesy, since he is the lone returning QB from last year.
Carter should start.
