Paul was not going to play guard next year!
We brought in a guard (Fernandez) and also have Simpson.
Not sure why some people don’t understand that.
Mulcahy was 29th out of 30 B1G guards in PPG
- Thread starter NewJerseyHawk
- Start date
Paul was not going to play guard next year!
We brought in a guard (Fernandez) and also have Simpson.
Not sure why some people don’t understand that.
What is a guard ? How is a 2 different than a 3 ? Is there a clear distinction between a 3 and a 4 in today’s game ? Most teams don’t have 5s. What is Lebron ?
None of that matters. What matters
is ability to defend and score. He can’t consistently do either in high major competition.
None of that matters. What matters
is ability to defend and score. He can’t consistently do either in high major competition.
also pointless because PM was 4th in assists per game in the league.. on a defensive team... in steals we had 3 of the top 5. read that again... 3 of the top 5 in steals per game were Rutgers players.. McConnel, Spencer and Mulcahy. How many of those higher PPG guards lost to Rutgers? PM was 54th overall (all positions) in rebounds per game though Spencer and edged him out there and McConnell exceeded him. I think he should have done better there. (though thinking this trough.. Paul was often the outlet man.. looking to push ball up the court with a pass.. maybe he got fewer of those bounds because of that assignment.. and he often blocked out big guys.. as much as he could).
Tell you what.. looking at all these stats... we are really gonna miss McConnell and Spencer. UCONN is very lucky to get Cam. He was at or very near the top among guards in so many categories it is scary... and that includes his dreadful streak.
Last edited:
OP still hasn’t named a single available upgrade in the past month
Wait, does this mean Spencer IS going to be missed?
If Cam and Paul left right after the season, initial reaction would have been bad, but it would have given us a chance to get quicker and more athletic with tons of portal options
Now it's TBD. If we bring in an Agee level replacement for Paul it's obviously a net negative
Paul's leadership and experience will be missed. He was a much better spot up shooter than some give him credit for. If Hyatt ever shot the 3 like Paul Hawk would be on cloud 9.
Paul was injured. Mike said on the podcast that he actually came into the season injured so he basically wasn't healthy the entire season. There is at least a chance that he would be closer to the Paul who dominated for a stretch the previous year if healthy. We will never know
Being faster and more athletic on both ends might end up being a positive for us. I am looking forward to a more fast paced offense. Paul held the ball too long, wasn't aggressive enough shooting, slow footed one on one. There are holes in his game
Will we be better off without him? It's all TBD with 4 open scholarships. Anyone making definitive predictions at this point has an agenda. The prudent thing to do is wait until we see how the roster turns out first.
Now it's TBD. If we bring in an Agee level replacement for Paul it's obviously a net negative
Paul's leadership and experience will be missed. He was a much better spot up shooter than some give him credit for. If Hyatt ever shot the 3 like Paul Hawk would be on cloud 9.
Paul was injured. Mike said on the podcast that he actually came into the season injured so he basically wasn't healthy the entire season. There is at least a chance that he would be closer to the Paul who dominated for a stretch the previous year if healthy. We will never know
Being faster and more athletic on both ends might end up being a positive for us. I am looking forward to a more fast paced offense. Paul held the ball too long, wasn't aggressive enough shooting, slow footed one on one. There are holes in his game
Will we be better off without him? It's all TBD with 4 open scholarships. Anyone making definitive predictions at this point has an agenda. The prudent thing to do is wait until we see how the roster turns out first.
We are better off with him gone compared to him starting. Same as Myles Johnson.
Pike understands that, obviously. So he encouraged them to leave rather than lose major minutes.
Win win.
All would agree the team would be better with them as reserves, but Pike didn’t want to do that to them.
Pike understands that, obviously. So he encouraged them to leave rather than lose major minutes.
Win win.
All would agree the team would be better with them as reserves, but Pike didn’t want to do that to them.
Uconn had a guard who played 28 minutes a game and scored 10 points a game and they won the national championship.
Mulchay stinks. Cost us a tourney spot. He often looked horrible/confused late in close games. Good luck to him.
It's the same thing. Caleb wasn't a guard but he was. The ball wasn't going to go through him (which is what he needs).
Okay so Caleb was a guard.
And you just said guards who can’t score are useless. So that would have made Caleb useless by your logic….got it.
Mulcahy’s role next year would have been totally different and much more of what it should have been in prior years if we had the right personnel…anyone thinking we won’t miss his skillset at the 3/4 position is clueless. We currently have a very shallow team and any portal guy we go after will likely require NIL and we will be up against tons of other schools.
In the end it doesn’t matter bc Mulcahy probably wants to go somewhere where he can play PG because it wasn’t happening here next year.
Bad take. Mag getting hurt cost us a tourney spot, and while Paul might have had some short comings he never looked confused.
I’m not looking to dump on Paul but he wasn’t a perfect player. He made some boneheaded mistakes late in games that killed us. You take the bad with the good. I also thought looked disinterested and simply unhappy late in the year. He needed a fresh start, and in that sense I’m happy from him, but his timing stinks.
As Hawk said, Caleb was an elite defender. That can off-set someone who can't score. What was Paul? A guy who couldn't score who was an average defender. He's replaceable dude. He stunk most of the year outside of a few games here and there.
Your logic in this thread is saying that Caleb was “useless” because he couldn’t score….so almost stopped reading your posts.
But now I’m officially done reading your posts here after stating “As Hawk said……” lololol.
It's some dumb rationalize people are doing. It's a sign if how archaic our offensive philosophy has been.
Richie even did it the podcast recently saying "Gavin can't be the 2. He's 6'7" " as if that means something.
We had a 6'5" PF in RHJ.
PG (which isn't even real anymore),
Wing (pretty much everyone)
Post player (which is just a way of saying a tall guy who can't shoot in college).
Did Geo bring up the ball 100% of the time? No. Did Cam bringing up the ball make him a PG? Will Simpson never bring up the ball when Fernandes is in the game?
At this point, the ideal team had 4-5 guys who can hit from deep if given an open shot. It has 3-4 guys who can handle the ball and drive, and 2-3 guys who can distribute and run the offense.
Whatever you want to label them, we have two deep threats on the roster right now for next year, and one has not yet played college ball. We need more.
If Fernandes or Griffiths are out for foul trouble or injury, or just for rest, we're down to one. Whether you want to call them "shooting guards" or not, we need more "guards who can shoot". It's the skill set that's a gap, not the positional label.
No, not Cam.#4 and #15 before him so he wouldn’t demote them to being backups.
Last edited:
Assists Per Game LEADERS
RK | PLAYER | TEAM | GP | MPG | AST | APG | TO | TOPG | AP40M | AST/TO |
1 | Jalen Pickett, G | PSU | 35 | 36.4 | 234 | 6.7 | 77 | 2.2 | 7.3 | 3.04 |
2 | Ta'lon Cooper, G | MINN | 31 | 36.6 | 196 | 6.3 | 83 | 2.7 | 6.9 | 2.36 |
3 | A.J. Hoggard, G | MSU | 31 | 30.4 | 186 | 6.0 | 77 | 2.5 | 7.9 | 2.42 |
4 | Paul Mulcahy, G | RUTG | 29 | 32.1 | 142 | 4.9 | 58 | 2.0 | 6.1 | 2.45 |
5 | Boo Buie, G | NU | 32 | 34.8 | 145 | 4.5 | 79 | 2.5 | 5.2 | 1.84 |
6 | Braden Smith, G | PUR | 34 | 30.1 | 147 | 4.3 | 62 | 1.8 | 5.7 | 2.37 |
Blame ridiculous press attacks - looked like they were put in by a CYO eighth grade coach. Paul is a very good passer. Pike and staff have struggled getting the ball inbounds vs pressure since he got here.
Last edited:
Yup….looked like Mulcahy was hurt and was gutting it out….should have been commended for that and any fan would. Maybe docs/Pike told PM to shut it down and he didn’t? Maybe Pikes couldn’t publicly say “he’s hurt” otherwise bad look on RUs part?
Who knows….but the fact that Pike didn’t address this better and get out ahead of the criticism led to…..well…..we see what happened. Self inflicted wounds from Pike and Mulcahy.
Who’s you?
What are you talking about?
There’s not a high level player of a sport in the world who wouldn’t want the public to know they’re playing hurt if your performance is suffering….none.
Acknowledging injury is in no way disclosing what the injury is,
It’s why lower body, upper body or undisclosed is the norm.
They are the norm to protect and support your players, as well as lauding their courage for manning up.
Last edited:
Looks like Paul was playing hurt and not making excuses for it,just gutting it out
>Fighting through a shoulder injury most of the season, Mulcahy struggled the last month plus of the 2022-2023 campaign.<
https://thescarletfaithful.com/paul-mulcahy-has-never-been-more-important-rutgers-mens-basketball/
Last edited:
Everyone knows Paul was hurt. A few strangely fight the obvious. Mike even said on the podcast that Paul actually came into the season hurt as well
To me, you can’t use the ‘hurt’ excuse when he plays poorly bc he’s also had good games. Does it only hurt on Wednesdays ? Or when the guy he defends blows by him every time ?
Can’t be selective in asserting the excuse.
Can’t be selective in asserting the excuse.
Also the "playing hurt" isn't a benefit when it's negatively impacting the team.
If he was so hurt that he was playing so badly and costing the team games - then he needs to not play.
It's either on him or HC Pike in that case to be the adult in the room and sit out.
Is the answer "well there was nobody else to play" - I don't get that.
A diminished, severely hurt Mulcahy was better than every other lineup option?
If Clif was hurt then it could maybe make sense "A 65% Clif was a better option than anything else we had."
He has a specialty role and there were limited backups.
Paul must have been hurt his junior year too, cause he was pretty average outside of that 5 game stretch
Yep. Was he 100% ? Probably not. But if he’s out there playing and sometimes playing well you can’t make excuses for when he isn’t.
Who was replacing him? Early on Simpson wasn’t ready yet. Then when Mag got hurt they couldn’t afford to play Miller for significant minutes.
This is why Paul & Caleb both played hurt down the stretch even though it was hurting them on offense. Pike’s Achilles heel has always been bench depth and it bit RU hard last year.
Last edited:
The offense completely changed during that 5 game stretch. We put cliff in high ball screen action what felt like every possession for ten days.
Paul just backed down his defender until cliffs man committed to helping. When he did he threw a lob/dish. If he never came he put up a shot within 6ft of the basket.
You'll know in about five months how well we utilized both Cam and Paul, especially Cam.
Our offense was truly pitiful last year and changes obviously had to be made. Hobbs moving on heralds a new offense and Fernandes, a rising Simpson, and Griffiths likely push Mulcahy out of the starting lineup. However, I think he would've been a valuable 6th man that could play 1 through 4 depending on the situation. That plus inevitable injuries means there was still an important role and major minutes available to him if he stayed. Now our bench is seriously weakened and I think it'll be hard to find quality portal replacements that are looking to transfer into a backup role.
Paul was playing 27 to 30 minutes a game when he hurt his shoulder against UMass Lowell and missed a series of games.
You’re saying he was hurt while playing in those games?
