Al, I actually think many of your takes are much more informed and realistic then you get credit for, I can tell you watch a ton of college football.
That said, I have to disagree with a few things here.
Former #1 QB Kyle McCord is nowhere near as good as folks on these boards think he is. He plays scared and gets happy feet. He is absolutely better than anyone we have, but is he special? Hard no from me. I realize that’s an unpopular opinion.
The rumors surrounding their #1 NJ WR are that he may be dropped by TAMU for better options ala Art Sitkowski at Miamiand their fans didn’t cry about him going. His Uncle is the new Cuse DC. I just don’t chalk this up to a genuine loss on our scorecard.
The #NJ RB was to me the biggest W for Brown. I don’t know if I 100% buy we didn’t offer. But with Monangai, SB III, Aaron Young still on the roster at that time and Benjamin logging considerable playing time I could see why a lot of solid Rb recruits would think twice before committing to us.
My opinion is Fran Brown has built a beauty pageant of hyped up leftovers and sloppy seconds. Like at a strip club, they look great in the dark but flip on the lights and those 10s turn into 4s and 5s real quick, belly scars, wrinkles and all.
My bigger concern is their schedule next year. A schedule that weak will make bad teams look decent and average teams look good. I don’t at all doubt Brown’s ability to recruit and with a decent year I think he may do some damage. That said Greg is a hell of a recruiter too, and no matter what their fans say they’ve been calling him Shady for 20 years because of his recruiting prowess.
If we can beat a UCLA, a Wisconsin or a very depleted Washington next year I think we can sell that we play a higher level of football, which is hard to argue when looking at their schedule. I have no problem letting their fans believe they ‘raided’ NJ this year and that college game day might show up to the Carrier dome next year, (yes, I did read that on their boards), but thus far I don’t feel Fran Brown is worth a fraction of the freak out that has happened on both Rutgers sites.