ADVERTISEMENT

OT - Top Bars in NJ

Love the dive bars too +1 for Great Notch, Billy's Redroom, Hillbilly Hall, Crocodile Inn, Riggers!!! Need to add The Log Cabin - Columbia to your list
been there several times golfer! In fact that area used to have several great dives. Johnnys Island Park, Gunnars Landing, Red Wolf Inn and the Wedgewood come to mind.
 
The Shephard and the Knucklehead in North Haledon is a great bar. PS- IMO, if the joint has more bar stools than tables, then it's a bar, if it has more tables than barstools than it's a restaurant that happens to have a bar.

The Shepherd and the Knucklehead:

http://www.theshepnj.com/

celebrating the duality of man
 
  • Like
Reactions: ewc128
Off Broadway's - Camden, my boy Glenn-ski djs thur-sat and the cook is great. Drinks/food are cheap!
 
Unless I missed it, The Boathouse in Lambertsville is not on the list ??!!?? That should be in the top 5.
This x 100. The Boathouse made the top 5 in Pete Genovese's list. Not being in the top 87 here makes this list invalid. The dive bar Hudson House being top 5 is a joke
 
Bar A is #2. List invalid.

Also, whichever BENNY wrote the list shows Bar A's location as "Manasquan". It's in Lake Como.
Properly known as South Belmar and a reminder of when Bar A wasn't even the best bar in that town.

I remember still a friend calling in sick from the pay phone in the bathroom yelling "sick" as loud as he could because his boss at the New Brunswick sheriffs office couldn't hear him as the turtle races raged outside.
 
. . . Hillbilly Hall - Hopewell . . .
Not every year, but most, there's a midnight Christmas Eve ceremony/mass/reading/whatever -you-want-it-to-be here by a local reverend and awesome guy with regulars walking over from the bar, or just anyone who wants to, to read pre-selected Christmas stories or bible passages that is not to be missed. The best is the guy who curses whenever he screws up a word. Amen. It's pure entertainment and fun, even for this atheist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jreinsdorf
Yeah but Parker House is very much alive :sunglasses:
In the 80s-90s they required a collared shirt to get in, which did not come with the shorts and t-shirt my friend and I were wearing when we got there as our 4th bar that day/night. After being turned away, we got a newspaper, used it to make collars, returned, and walked straight in passed a laughing bouncer.
 
In the 80s-90s they required a collared shirt to get in, which did not come with the shorts and t-shirt my friend and I were wearing when we got there as our 4th bar that day/night. After being turned away, we got a newspaper, used it to make collars, returned, and walked straight in passed a laughing bouncer.
I know what SOMEONE's doing at 4:30AM Christmas morning (unless you have kids!). Merry Christmas!
 
Not every year, but most, there's a midnight Christmas Eve ceremony/mass/reading/whatever -you-want-it-to-be here by a local reverend and awesome guy with regulars walking over from the bar, or just anyone who wants to, to read pre-selected Christmas stories or bible passages that is not to be missed. The best is the guy who curses whenever he screws up a word. Amen. It's pure entertainment and fun, even for this atheist.

A little confusing wording but funny and a good story-bar, bible and beer. You may be onto something (PS arriving a church and being stick with once a years who don't want to be there I was almost driven to drink tonight!
 
Was not a big bar person at all and I know Bar A is probably cheesy to the bar enthusiast, but I will say that was my favorite growing up (haven't been in 10 years or so).

Not a drinker-may have been tipsy twice (once on campus on Cook on Ag Field Day night). However, despite missing a day on the beach I liked to go (no more Thank God)
Bar A on WFAN day with everyone in their (including RU) team's garb and hear Southside Johnny and the Jukes. On that note my other bar would be "The Stone Pony" due to the live music. In Chapel Hill (not so sure many were there when we played) I frequented Bubo Malley's ("BUBs") as it wasn't a wine and cheese crowd bar-just great 70s and 80s music from the juke box.
 
Back in the 90s if you left the Parker House having one to many and dared get into your car and drive...you could save a lot of time by driving directly to the police station and turning yourself in.
The odds of getting to wherever you were staying without being pulled over were low.
 
The Bluffs...Bayhead, The Pool Bar...Springlake
The greatest bars in history to pick up the preppy daughters of rich parents from Chatham, Summit and Montclair.

To bad they're both torn down

Loved the Bluffs! As for the Pool Bar, I got a job there bar tending back in my college days. Waitresses were hot! I lasted 2 weeks, got mono that summer. No luck, whatsoever.
Later bartender at the Royal Manor for a few years.
 
Loved the Bluffs! As for the Pool Bar, I got a job there bar tending back in my college days. Waitresses were hot! I lasted 2 weeks, got mono that summer. No luck, whatsoever.
Later bartender at the Royal Manor for a few years.
I know several married couple that met at the pool bar...lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: RURod
Back in the 90s if you left the Parker House having one to many and dared get into your car and drive...you could save a lot of time by driving directly to the police station and turning yourself in.
The odds of getting to wherever you were staying without being pulled over were low.

We used to spend the night at the Osprey or Leggetts then around 1:30 pile in a car to drive to Jimmy Byrnes because it was open till 3:00. You'd never think about doing that now.

In the mid 70's I had a room upstairs at the Parker House and worked a few fill in shifts behind the bar downstairs. Fun times.
 
We used to spend the night at the Osprey or Leggetts then around 1:30 pile in a car to drive to Jimmy Byrnes because it was open till 3:00. You'd never think about doing that now.

In the mid 70's I had a room upstairs at the Parker House and worked a few fill in shifts behind the bar downstairs. Fun times.
We used to close the Torn Hat and go to Wallaces across from Star.
We knew the bartender, he'd lock the place up for us and we'd stay till daylight, no need to tell you what was going on there...
 
Loved the Bluffs! As for the Pool Bar, I got a job there bar tending back in my college days. Waitresses were hot! I lasted 2 weeks, got mono that summer. No luck, whatsoever.
Later bartender at the Royal Manor for a few years.
A caviat of The Bluffs were the epic after parties within walking distance.
 
We used to close the Torn Hat and go to Wallaces across from Star.
We knew the bartender, he'd lock the place up for us and we'd stay till daylight, no need to tell you what was going on there...

I wasn't living in the WO area back during the heyday of Wallaces. Even when I was I was a Dodds and Dodd's Crest guy as we've discussed before. My sister and friends used to go to Wallaces as they're close to your age. I'll have to ask her later today about the place if she'll admit to it lol.

A couple of guys from Montclair worked at Dodds and later owned the Parker House for many years which is how I ended up there.
 
We used to close the Torn Hat and go to Wallaces across from Star.
We knew the bartender, he'd lock the place up for us and we'd stay till daylight, no need to tell you what was going on there...

I asked my sister about Wallaces. She had a friend who played in a band who performed there so she and her other friends went often. Said it was a great hangout.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zappaa
We used to spend the night at the Osprey or Leggetts then around 1:30 pile in a car to drive to Jimmy Byrnes because it was open till 3:00. You'd never think about doing that now.

In the mid 70's I had a room upstairs at the Parker House and worked a few fill in shifts behind the bar downstairs. Fun times.

These days you could Uber to River Rock or Headliners. Outside Parker House at 11:45 it's Uber central with everyone going to Belmar and Squan.

The shore bar scene is variable. There are people who will literally ONLY go to Osprey, Legetts, or Djais. Many a shore house night I have had where the mere suggestion of going to Asbury or Bar A would get a look like I said to go to Mars.

I think Djais has begun to attract a less stereotypical crowd which has taken some from Bar A. I thought the crowd at Bar A had been dwindling until this past summer, when it was packed regularly...Jenks seemed to attract smaller crowds this past summer for whatever reason.
 
We used to spend the night at the Osprey or Leggetts then around 1:30 pile in a car to drive to Jimmy Byrnes because it was open till 3:00. You'd never think about doing that now.

In the mid 70's I had a room upstairs at the Parker House and worked a few fill in shifts behind the bar downstairs. Fun times.
Spent many a night at both the Osprey and Jimmy Byrnes. Sometimes it would feel like the floor was going to cave in at Byrnes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: knightfan7
That's a waste of a list. I've been to a few of them, and I don't think any that I've been to qualify as a "top bar". For example,they include the Stage House in Somerset; a place that doesn't know how to make a martini, has a limited whiskey selection, and a piss-poor beer selection. (I won't comment on wine selection, because this is a ranking of best bars, not restaurants with the best wine cellars.) Other than a nice patio, I can't think of anything that qualifies the Stage House to be on a list of best bars. Yet the list doesn't include Catherine Lombardi, which is one of the best cocktail bars in the area.
You my friend R so right.........I go there a lot in the summer time and they have like just one IPA on tap.....are you freaking kidding me !!
 
Under Flood if you wanted to see our football team all you had to do was go to osprey at night or djais for happy hour
 
I remember George. I think they still have a photo of him on the wall behind the bar.
Just know George was well known there. Apparently when he died, the owners of the place paid for a big 'party' in his honor. I've never been there, just know him & his family from summers down the shore. Not many people frequent a bar & have a big event thrown in honor of them by the owners.
 
Just know George was well known there. Apparently when he died, the owners of the place paid for a big 'party' in his honor. I've never been there, just know him & his family from summers down the shore. Not many people frequent a bar & have a big event thrown in honor of them by the owners.
Everyone knew him. In fact, you guys inspired me to have lunch there today. And his photos are still up behind the bar. RIP George.
 
Spent many a night at both the Osprey and Jimmy Byrnes. Sometimes it would feel like the floor was going to cave in at Byrnes.

A former Osprey bartender from the 70's stops in where I work once in a while. We were talking about Chuck Wepner, his white Panama hat, and that damn whistle he'd always be blowing.
 
Spent many a night at both the Osprey and Jimmy Byrnes. Sometimes it would feel like the floor was going to cave in at Byrnes.
The amount of people crammed into Jimmy Byrnes was just crazy. A fire in that place would have been catastrophic- not that it ever entered my mind when I used to go there.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT