ADVERTISEMENT

We should fire Pike after this year, however reality is he’ll get fired in March 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
But then we would be idiots, because we are clearly enumerating, here in 2021, the reasons why this doesn't make sense. Why would we look back and think "boy I wish we had acted stupidly back in 2022"?
Your post doesnt make sense. If the program flounders over the next few years and he gets canned in 2024 for that reason why would it have been stupid to just do it in 2022 instead? Again, im kind of just throwing this out there, we all know it aint gonna happen after this season
 
Your post doesnt make sense. If the program flounders over the next few years and he gets canned in 2024 for that reason why would it have been stupid to just do it in 2022 instead? Again, im kind of just throwing this out there, we all know it aint gonna happen after this season
Because time travel isn't a thing? Like, why would I look back from 2024 wishing I had made some irrational decision in 2022? That's called mental weakness kyk, I thought you were better than that. But then, you want to hire some mediocre Oklahoma State coach so I guess I underestimated you..
 
Because time travel isn't a thing? Like, why would I look back from 2024 wishing I had made some irrational decision in 2022? That's called mental weakness kyk, I thought you were better than that. But then, you want to hire some mediocre Oklahoma State coach so I guess I underestimated you..
Haha oh trust me, if the decision was mine pike is gone in march 2022. The decision isnt mine tho so therefore i just point out the reality. I also dont think when you lay out the facts that its be irrational to move on from pike on march 2022. But again, its not gonna happen because the bar is buried here. Were a fan base that thinks making the ncaa tournament is a huge accomplishment. We have such a low bar here
 
Haha oh trust me, if the decision was mine pike is gone in march 2022. The decision isnt mine tho so therefore i just point out the reality. I also dont think when you lay out the facts that its be irrational to move on from pike on march 2022. But again, its not gonna happen because the bar is buried here. Were a fan base that thinks making the ncaa tournament is a huge accomplishment. We have such a low bar here
If we should have a high bar why do you want to hire a guy who has never cracked the top 30 in kenpom????
 
The big picture lesson - Never, NEVER overhype if you can't back it up. That is how you lose trust and credibility with the fan base. This was Pikiell BIG mistake just prior to the season. He set expectations way beyond reality and now his credibility and trust is on shaky ground.
He had to do something to distract local press and the fanbase from having the worst offseason of any program in the country.
 
Thankful for what he's done here but I'm livid at these first 5 games. And already depressed about next season and beyond given his recruiting.

I think to his credit in building this program, this is a pretty attractive job right now too.
 
Thankful for what he's done here but I'm livid at these first 5 games. And already depressed about next season and beyond given his recruiting.

I think to his credit in building this program, this is a pretty attractive job right now too.
That is difference between Mens Basketball, and for that matter Women's Basketball, and Football. With Football, you can see a basis for hope in the future based on talent infusion that is coming in.
 
If we should have a high bar why do you want to hire a guy who has never cracked the top 30 in kenpom????
Local guy, good recruiter, has produced a top 5 pick, has beat a natty champ, has gone as far as pike already in the tourney in his first head coaching gig which he landed at age 34 at a p5, learned under brad underwood. He has a really high ceiling imo.

oh yeah and btw hes done all this while the program was under investigation stemming back to when underwood was there resulting in a 1 year postseason ban and 3 year probation period. All this loomed over the program
 
This thread is so disturbing in so many ways. First , you are such a ridiculous front runner that 5 games into this season , you start this shitty low life thread and try to temper it but I know Pike is here until 2024. You were never around after wins , some of the best wins in RAC history in 2019-2020 and never give one compliment to the coach for the blowout wins over Seton Hall, Illinois and Maryland , 3 of the best teams that year that didn’t get a chance to show it because of COVID. That team gets its heart ripped open by the stoppage of play when they are about to tip against Michigan. ( My humble opinion that team would have reached the Sweet 16)
Pike then has to navigate a difficult COVID year without fans and without the RAC as we know it , and takes the team to a win in the NCAA and is a blown last 4:21 to play starting from Myles missed dunk, from going to the Sweet 16 against a 2 seed.
No credit ever given just your whining about the total lack of offense , an offense that was really putting it to Houston , one of the best defensive teams in the country.
Now we are 5 games into the year , and you jump ship again. Pike loses Jacob, selfish delusion, Myles , going home and grad school with a chance to contribute to a Final Four team , and Montez , a guy that I thought was really valuable, but a player this board hated and wanted gone.

He retains Geo and Ron , who come back for a final ride and you expect they will lead and play up to their all conference ratings . Pike changes the offense with 4 guys on the baseline and Ron coming up on a horns set , and one and one and isolation ball for Ron . I have hated it since game one but Kentucky and Duke do it a ton and that is their offense , one you do not consider an offense . A team that has been at least a decent 2 point shooting team has shit the bed shooting in both Lehigh and Lafayette
and half of the Merrimack game not just from 3 but from 2. Caleb has gone into a collapse we have not seen out of a Pike player in 5 years . Things look bleak and I am officially worried as Piscataway Mike asked when do you start . This is as bad 4 out of 5 game stretch against lower level teams we have seen from a Pike team, even worse than the first 2 years because rebounding , defense and shooting is all abysmal. I am disgusted as anyone over the start but to absolutely abandon ship and give Pike no rope to try and turn this around is just pathetic and juvenile.

This is likely the worst the Big 10 has been in almost 5 years. Purdue is elite and then that is it. No other team is really good and most are mediocre . Illinois with Kofi back lost to Cincinnati by 20 tonight.

The season doesn’t end after 5 games , despite how bad it has looked thru 5 . Players we expected to give us something anything are not doing it. Are they going to continue to not do it all year, or will they break out of their collective slump ? I do not know but I do not trash a coach the way you do. Twitter is alive. Very easy for you , go root for another team , and go to their message boards and type away .
 
This thread is so disturbing in so many ways. First , you are such a ridiculous front runner that 5 games into this season , you start this shitty low life thread and try to temper it but I know Pike is here until 2024. You were never around after wins , some of the best wins in RAC history in 2019-2020 and never give one compliment to the coach for the blowout wins over Seton Hall, Illinois and Maryland , 3 of the best teams that year that didn’t get a chance to show it because of COVID. That team gets its heart ripped open by the stoppage of play when they are about to tip against Michigan. ( My humble opinion that team would have reached the Sweet 16)
Pike then has to navigate a difficult COVID year without fans and without the RAC as we know it , and takes the team to a win in the NCAA and is a blown last 4:21 to play starting from Myles missed dunk, from going to the Sweet 16 against a 2 seed.
No credit ever given just your whining about the total lack of offense , an offense that was really putting it to Houston , one of the best defensive teams in the country.
Now we are 5 games into the year , and you jump ship again. Pike loses Jacob, selfish delusion, Myles , going home and grad school with a chance to contribute to a Final Four team , and Montez , a guy that I thought was really valuable, but a player this board hated and wanted gone.

He retains Geo and Ron , who come back for a final ride and you expect they will lead and play up to their all conference ratings . Pike changes the offense with 4 guys on the baseline and Ron coming up on a horns set , and one and one and isolation ball for Ron . I have hated it since game one but Kentucky and Duke do it a ton and that is their offense , one you do not consider an offense . A team that has been at least a decent 2 point shooting team has shit the bed shooting in both Lehigh and Lafayette
and half of the Merrimack game not just from 3 but from 2. Caleb has gone into a collapse we have not seen out of a Pike player in 5 years . Things look bleak and I am officially worried as Piscataway Mike asked when do you start . This is as bad 4 out of 5 game stretch against lower level teams we have seen from a Pike team, even worse than the first 2 years because rebounding , defense and shooting is all abysmal. I am disgusted as anyone over the start but to absolutely abandon ship and give Pike no rope to try and turn this around is just pathetic and juvenile.

This is likely the worst the Big 10 has been in almost 5 years. Purdue is elite and then that is it. No other team is really good and most are mediocre . Illinois with Kofi back lost to Cincinnati by 20 tonight.

The season doesn’t end after 5 games , despite how bad it has looked thru 5 . Players we expected to give us something anything are not doing it. Are they going to continue to not do it all year, or will they break out of their collective slump ? I do not know but I do not trash a coach the way you do. Twitter is alive. Very easy for you , go root for another team , and go to their message boards and type away .
I gave credit when due and i was around after big wins giving credit so youre completely wrong there. I also just call it like i see it and most dont like that. I said in 2017 @ nebraska that after i witnessed the team coming out of the locker room ash needed to go, to which people called me crazy. Im saying the same now, pike aint gonna cut it here and its gonna get worse before it gets better. And better wont occur until hes gone which imo doesnt happen til march 2024
 
So find one? It has to be a team that was good enough to get an at-large bid, not some conference tournament winner from a shit conference.

One recruiting class is 4 years. If you inherit the #275 team you get at least two years and probably three of a free pass. Anything else is ludicrous.

Yeah I’m not going to waste time to prove this specific theory about programs with incredibly low kenpom ratings getting at large bids quickly from such low kenpom ratings. That’s not going to be an easy task because those programs almost all play in one bid leagues. My point is that one recruiting class in basketball can turn around any program. Case in point Seton Hall with Isaiah Whitehead’s class. Alabama with their 2017 class. Illinois with the Ayo Dosunmu class.
 
Last year was last year. Pike had a good year last year. Bad losses happen. Two in a row raises red flags. Pike and his players have a lot of work to do. I don't follow basketball closely, and it was drill night for my fire department tonight. Was shocked RU lost. Hope they get it together, but they better do it soon. The Jersey Mikes jinx may have something to do with it. 🙄
Why do we need to know about your fire dept.?
 
I gave credit when due and i was around after big wins giving credit so youre completely wrong there. I also just call it like i see it and most dont like that. I said in 2017 @ nebraska that after i witnessed the team coming out of the locker room ash needed to go, to which people called me crazy. Im saying the same now, pike aint gonna cut it here and its gonna get worse before it gets better. And better wont occur until hes gone which imo doesnt happen til march 2024
So 5 games into this year , which has started about as bad as possible and 2-3 players playing as bad as possible and shooting even worse , has cemented it for you . As I said you give Pike no credit for the last 2 years. Not for the players he recruited , how he developed them , how he beat the top teams in the Big 10 in arguably the best 2 years in conference history , top to bottom , and having 2 NCAA worthy teams coming from being 275 in Kenpom when Eddie got canned. Like I said you are a pathetic front runner , scattering at the first sign of trouble.
 
The key to college sports success is to fire your coach at first signs the ceiling is capped and bring in a new coach with a newly undefined yet hopeful ceiling to keep the life blood of the program - recruiting and fan support and dollars - going in a positive direction.

I don’t see it happening though because Pike is Hobbs guy. I see him sticking around for many years. That would not be how I would handle it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_0k9zlfz6lz9oy
2019 was arguably our best team since the 70s and we were about a minute from the Sweet 16 last season. So no, he hasn’t been right.
Wow one tournament win let's crown him. Who has ever done that.
 
This thread is so disturbing in so many ways. First , you are such a ridiculous front runner that 5 games into this season , you start this shitty low life thread and try to temper it but I know Pike is here until 2024. You were never around after wins , some of the best wins in RAC history in 2019-2020 and never give one compliment to the coach for the blowout wins over Seton Hall, Illinois and Maryland , 3 of the best teams that year that didn’t get a chance to show it because of COVID. That team gets its heart ripped open by the stoppage of play when they are about to tip against Michigan. ( My humble opinion that team would have reached the Sweet 16)
Pike then has to navigate a difficult COVID year without fans and without the RAC as we know it , and takes the team to a win in the NCAA and is a blown last 4:21 to play starting from Myles missed dunk, from going to the Sweet 16 against a 2 seed.
No credit ever given just your whining about the total lack of offense , an offense that was really putting it to Houston , one of the best defensive teams in the country.
Now we are 5 games into the year , and you jump ship again. Pike loses Jacob, selfish delusion, Myles , going home and grad school with a chance to contribute to a Final Four team , and Montez , a guy that I thought was really valuable, but a player this board hated and wanted gone.

He retains Geo and Ron , who come back for a final ride and you expect they will lead and play up to their all conference ratings . Pike changes the offense with 4 guys on the baseline and Ron coming up on a horns set , and one and one and isolation ball for Ron . I have hated it since game one but Kentucky and Duke do it a ton and that is their offense , one you do not consider an offense . A team that has been at least a decent 2 point shooting team has shit the bed shooting in both Lehigh and Lafayette
and half of the Merrimack game not just from 3 but from 2. Caleb has gone into a collapse we have not seen out of a Pike player in 5 years . Things look bleak and I am officially worried as Piscataway Mike asked when do you start . This is as bad 4 out of 5 game stretch against lower level teams we have seen from a Pike team, even worse than the first 2 years because rebounding , defense and shooting is all abysmal. I am disgusted as anyone over the start but to absolutely abandon ship and give Pike no rope to try and turn this around is just pathetic and juvenile.

This is likely the worst the Big 10 has been in almost 5 years. Purdue is elite and then that is it. No other team is really good and most are mediocre . Illinois with Kofi back lost to Cincinnati by 20 tonight.

The season doesn’t end after 5 games , despite how bad it has looked thru 5 . Players we expected to give us something anything are not doing it. Are they going to continue to not do it all year, or will they break out of their collective slump ? I do not know but I do not trash a coach the way you do. Twitter is alive. Very easy for you , go root for another team , and go to their message boards and type away .
You go ru 7! Well said!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastMJ
The key to college sports success is to fire your coach at first signs the ceiling is capped and bring in a new coach with a newly undefined yet hopeful ceiling to keep the life blood of the program - recruiting and fan support and dollars - going in a positive direction.

I don’t see it happening though because Pike is Hobbs guy. I see him sticking around for many years. That would not be how I would handle it.
I agree that this is how many programs run things. Personally, I don’t believe that’s realistically how we should be running our program in 2021. We are simply not a perennial top 30 team.
It’s difficult to convey the Herculean job Pike has done with on the court results for the past 3-4 years and especially the last 2. I will gladly reward that employee (coach Pike) with some loyalty and support. I highly doubt I will ever think he should have been fired at end of 2022.
 
I agree that this is how many programs run things. Personally, I don’t believe that’s realistically how we should be running our program in 2021. We are simply not a perennial top 30 team.
It’s difficult to convey the Herculean job Pike has done with on the court results for the past 3-4 years and especially the last 2. I will gladly reward that employee (coach Pike) with some loyalty and support. I highly doubt I will ever think he should have been fired at end of 2022.
I don’t think he will wither and think there is quite a healthy debate that would support that. Just saying what separates the athletics departments that consistently win vs the others.

I doubt Rutgers admin would try to get a buy out through the Politics of NJ right now anyway because they walk on egg shells when it comes to playing the part.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rubigtimenow
I said it after the Lehigh game …this season is toast.
Losing to a winless Lafayette team at home ? WTF
Wait until we get into the B1G schedule. No Tournament this year boys. We will be lucky to get 10 wins this season.
 
Pike's made one tourney in five years. No coach would view a firing as poison. Was the Minnesota job viewed as poison after they fired a coach who made the tourney? No...
So the year when no team went to the tourney because it was cancelled, and we would have been in, counts? Jeez, it seems like you might have an agenda.
 
Some of the posters are acting like we've played 1 bad half in 5 games. We've basically laid 4.5 turds in 5 games. At this point, we are all just blindly hoping the team will turn it around. Based on what my eyes have seen, I don't objectively see anything to give us confidence in a turn around. There are just so many red flags.

When looking at the current roster, I'm not sure how anyone can be confident about next year. Missing speed (young) and a rim defender (Johnson) has impacted this team. If he can't go get transfers, there are lean times ahead.

I've really like some of the transfers, but there have definitely been a number of COMPLETE misses (like the coach didn't understand the talent needed for the B1G).
 
This is such a stupid thread because like 90% of all coaches get fired or mutually depart so there's an extremely high chance you're right and Rutgers will move on from Pikiell at some point and you'll want credit for saying see I told you back then!

Look at what happened to Indiana after they got rid of Tom Crean one year after a Sweet 16 run. The grass isn't always greener.

Kyk would've been trying to fire Fran McCaffrey after he missed the tournament two straight years, if he were an Iowa fan.
 
Last edited:
So the year when no team went to the tourney because it was cancelled, and we would have been in, counts? Jeez, it seems like you might have an agenda.
To be fair, we were 50/50 in 2020. There were guys who didnt have us in (jerry palm) and those who did had us as last 4 in
 
This is such a stupid thread because like 90% of all coaches get fired or mutually depart so there's an extremely high chance you're right and Rutgers will move on from Pikiell at some point and you'll want credit for saying see I told you back then!

Look at what happened to Indiana after they got rid of Tom Crean one year after a Sweet 16 run. The grass isn't always greener.

Kyk would've been trying to fire Fran McCaffrey after he missed the tournament two straight years, if he were an Iowa fan.
Nah youre wrong. Its simply about looking forward. What makes you optimistic moving forward? Anything? If pike had loaded recruiting classes lined up id simply be saying, “give it time, we knew this year would be a step back but reinforcements are on the way”. I mean this aint hard. Things are going to get worse
 
Thanks Kyk but I don't need therapy from a dude who sounds like he is suicidal after every rutgers loss. Pike has showed success in the past and deserves some deference to right the ship. He took a group of no names to march madness and the NCAA's. Maybe we do take a step back this season, who knows. Lets first see how the season develops.
I agree with your sentiment, but who has he recruited that gives you any hope of success moving forward? Geo and Ron, as frustrating as their play has been, at least they have somewhat of a track record of success. Jaden looks like a nice offensive player and Cliff is an athlete at center (though needs a ton of work at both ends of the court). Who else gives you hope?
 
Not sure what to say to the few people that don't see the cliff Rutgers just jumped off. Loading a Big Ten roster with players almost every other coach saw as not worthy of offering a scholarship had an inevitable end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_0k9zlfz6lz9oy
I agree with your sentiment, but who has he recruited that gives you any hope of success moving forward? Geo and Ron, as frustrating as their play has been, at least they have somewhat of a track record of success. Jaden looks like a nice offensive player and Cliff is an athlete at center (though needs a ton of work at both ends of the court). Who else gives you hope?
I don't know how many times this needs to be explained. Pikiell did it his way and it worked. That has earned him the chance to continue doing it his way.

Do I think it will work again? No. But that's not the point.
 
I agree with your sentiment, but who has he recruited that gives you any hope of success moving forward? Geo and Ron, as frustrating as their play has been, at least they have somewhat of a track record of success. Jaden looks like a nice offensive player and Cliff is an athlete at center (though needs a ton of work at both ends of the court). Who else gives you hope?
Pike gives me hope! Just saw his post game presser and it was as sober an assessment as I have seen any coach give of the performance of his team. Many of the gripes people have expressed on this board are areas that pike covered in his presser and it was not excuse making either.
I will leave it to pike and his assistants to make personnel assessments. Although I do understand when others complain about pikes recruiting. I am in agreement that pike should be recruiting a higher caliber of player but maybe there is method to his madness.
did you ever watch the movie Miracle about the 1980 U.S. hockey team? Herb Brooks had a vision and he did not pick the best players but the players he thought would give the team the best chance of success. We all know how that story ended. Maybe pike has a vision that we are not privy to. At the minimum he deserves the benefit of the doubt based upon where the team was immediately before he took over and last years results.
many of RU’s fans are crybabies who think Rutgers is literally going to go from the bottom of the barrel in college sports to being elite teams year in and year out. Well unfortunately life doesn’t work that way and my opinion is both Schiano and Pike deserve the benefit of a long leash to get these programs where they need to be.
 
He gets two more years after this. If he hasn’t sniffed the tournament in three straight years it will be time to move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goru7
Pike gives me hope! Just saw his post game presser and it was as sober an assessment as I have seen any coach give of the performance of his team. Many of the gripes people have expressed on this board are areas that pike covered in his presser and it was not excuse making either.
I will leave it to pike and his assistants to make personnel assessments. Although I do understand when others complain about pikes recruiting. I am in agreement that pike should be recruiting a higher caliber of player but maybe there is method to his madness.
did you ever watch the movie Miracle about the 1980 U.S. hockey team? Herb Brooks had a vision and he did not pick the best players but the players he thought would give the team the best chance of success. We all know how that story ended. Maybe pike has a vision that we are not privy to. At the minimum he deserves the benefit of the doubt based upon where the team was immediately before he took over and last years results.
many of RU’s fans are crybabies who think Rutgers is literally going to go from the bottom of the barrel in college sports to being elite teams year in and year out. Well unfortunately life doesn’t work that way and my opinion is both Schiano and Pike deserve the benefit of a long leash to get these programs where they need to be.
His vision of what exactly? that his reality believes that guys who otherwise would go to cleveland state come to RU and thats the recipe to win? Lol
 
He gets two more years after this. If he hasn’t sniffed the tournament in three straight years it will be time to move on.
Sounds fair. All the more reason the OP starting this thread is a turd, a front runner , who should go root fir another team. Guaranteed he is rooting hard for Seton Hall this year.
 
Sounds fair. All the more reason the OP starting this thread is a turd, a front runner , who should go root fir another team. Guaranteed he is rooting hard for Seton Hall this year.
Lol, this is the same board that i got called basically hitler for because i audibly yelled “**** seton hall” during a break in the anthem in 2019. I did in fact grow up a SHU fan but once I went to RU I changed my loyalty. I do still watch hall but dont root for them. Objectively speaking theyre gonna beat the tar out of us tho. This is their best team since the final 4 squad imo
 
  • Like
Reactions: The RUT
Lol, this is the same board that i got called basically hitler for because i audibly yelled “**** seton hall” during a break in the anthem in 2019. I did in fact grow up a SHU fan but once I went to RU I changed my loyalty. I do still watch hall but dont root for them. Objectively speaking theyre gonna beat the tar out of us tho. This is their best team since the final 4 squad imo
You ain’t changing your stripes so quick when it comes to basketball. Football you have been all in on Schiano but hopefully you do realize the offense has not put the guys in the best position to succeed.
Are you really calling this year’s Seton Hall team the best one since their Final 4 team? That is laughable. I guess you thought that once they beat a shitty Michigan team that blew a 11 point lead but didn’t realize Michigan lost Sunday to Arizona by 20 and guess what Seton Hall lost to an average Ohio State team . Final 4 worthy. You are a joke of a Rutgers fan and remember to wear Seton Hall blue for our game with them. The way we are playing now it doesn’t appear Rutgers will win but after the next 4 games , I got a feeling it will be a great game
 
I'm not the biggest Pikiell fan either but your post is wrong. He should and will get a long leash because of the last two seasons. I hate the way he schedules, I don't like his roster construction, I don't think the things he emphasizes... that's all true but he got us to the tournament doing it his way. So he gets to keep doing it his way until it's proven not to work.
This is a very sensible and accurate post. No need for me to read the rest of this thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastMJ and kcg88
You ain’t changing your stripes so quick when it comes to basketball. Football you have been all in on Schiano but hopefully you do realize the offense has not put the guys in the best position to succeed.
Are you really calling this year’s Seton Hall team the best one since their Final 4 team? That is laughable. I guess you thought that once they beat a shitty Michigan team that blew a 11 point lead but didn’t realize Michigan lost Sunday to Arizona by 20 and guess what Seton Hall lost to an average Ohio State team . Final 4 worthy. You are a joke of a Rutgers fan and remember to wear Seton Hall blue for our game with them. The way we are playing now it doesn’t appear Rutgers will win but after the next 4 games , I got a feeling it will be a great game
In 2 years when Pike is still running an iso offense with no playmakers on the court, are you going to apologize to kyk and say he was right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT