ADVERTISEMENT

OT: 2024 NY Yankees Season Thread

That’s my point, you had to send him the way that game was going
I agree with the send there... team couldn't hit and it took a picture perfect throw directly up the line into the runner by Hernandez. So, I'm with you on sending him to try and get a shot of life... but holy geez is Stanton slow. I thought he was jogging intentionally like he thought it was a gapper or something, no way that's really his 100% max speed
 
That’s my point, you had to send him the way that game was going
100% had to send him. And even with how slow he is, not having a good read or even a good baseball IQ- it took a perfect play to get him at home. 3B coach made the right call.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zappaa
Wanna teach your son how to hit and play the game, watch Mookie Betts.
Not a hall of famer, not a lifetime 300 hitter… he knows how to play with a great hitting and fielding approach.

In my era, we had a lot more Mookie Betts type players on every team.
darn close to a HOF - 5 seasons in the top 5 MVP 3 seasons top 2...

have to say- for a smaller player- dude generates a lot of power.
 
Barring a historic comeback, this may be the worst WS in recent years, especially with the hype around it. I’m convinced if the Yanks closed out game one they would have won it all or at least this would have been a 7 game series. If there was ever a single moment in sports that changed the trajectory of a series it was the soul-crushing Boone/Nestor debacle. Who in their right mind brings in Nestor over Tim Hill if you are going with a lefty? Freeman was 9-14 against lefties with bases loaded with 4 GS. At least Tim Hill’s delivery makes him an unusual lefty for a guy like Freeman to face especially with 2 outs in the 9th. And Nestor had 37 days off. MAKES…NO…F’IN…SENSE!
 
100% had to send him. And even with how slow he is, not having a good read or even a good baseball IQ- it took a perfect play to get him at home. 3B coach made the right call.
Disagree…any player other than Stanton you send especially after Stanton’s piss poor read.
 
Disagree…any player other than Stanton you send especially after Stanton’s piss poor read.
I watched the replay this morning. Stanton was already running and about 30 feet off 2b when the ball flew over the SS's head. It surely wasn't a great jump, but he got a jump. And there was really no read to make, at least no complicated one. Ball in the air, run. Really almost, ball hit, run. He just runs in slow motion and got thrown out.
 
darn close to a HOF - 5 seasons in the top 5 MVP 3 seasons top 2...

have to say- for a smaller player- dude generates a lot of power.
Yes he does create power, he generates it with a great approach and sequence of his body and brain.
Watching Otahni and Judge hit is like watching Dave Kingman.
I’d much rather watch Carew, Brett, Boggs or Gwynn.

Soto has a Ted Williams swing and eye.
Tremendous player…..you can’t teach that swing
 
Barring a historic comeback, this may be the worst WS in recent years, especially with the hype around it. I’m convinced if the Yanks closed out game one they would have won it all or at least this would have been a 7 game series. If there was ever a single moment in sports that changed the trajectory of a series it was the soul-crushing Boone/Nestor debacle. Who in their right mind brings in Nestor over Tim Hill if you are going with a lefty? Freeman was 9-14 against lefties with bases loaded with 4 GS. At least Tim Hill’s delivery makes him an unusual lefty for a guy like Freeman to face especially with 2 outs in the 9th. And Nestor had 37 days off. MAKES…NO…F’IN…SENSE!
I don't think so. The Dodgers are so much better at basically everything.
 
Disagree…any player other than Stanton you send especially after Stanton’s piss poor read.
I’m more in agreement with the guy who spent a lifetime around MLB and playing the game at this level on this one.
I also tend to always think if it takes a perfect throw to make a bang bang play- then it was the right decision.
 
Yes he does create power, he generates it with a great approach and sequence of his body and brain.
Watching Otahni and Judge hit is like watching Dave Kingman.
I’d much rather watch Carew, Brett, Boggs or Gwynn.

Soto has a Ted Williams swing and eye.
Tremendous player…..you can’t teach that swing

Or Mattingly
 
I don't think so. The Dodgers are so much better at basically everything.
I hear you but at the same time Yanks had Game 1 locked down until Boone/Nestor gave it away. And in Game 2 the Yanks almost stole the game if not for Judge’s pathetic at bat, a terrible Volpe K swing, and an idiotic Trevino that swung first pitch on a reliever that prob just soiled himself as he entered the highest pressure situation of his life. The Dodgers are definitely more fundamentally sound but I’m not buying all the “AL sucks BS”. Terrible coaching as far as I’m concerned. Volpe and Trevino were mental mistakes given the counts/situations. And am I to believe that a few hours of film and a ton of batting practice can’t, if nothing else, help Judge lay off low outside or make contact? The guy is swinging like Kevin Maas.
 

Video: Fat Joe Accused Of 'Killing Yankee Stadium's Aura'



There is some truth to this…it would have been different if it was Jay-Z singing Empire State of Mind but a lot of people didn’t even know who Fat Joe is. The audio was terrible and the song clips seemed to have nothing to do with NY, baseball, Yankees, etc.
 
So of course the Twittersphere was filled with Stanton memes today, but for my money this one wins the day:

 
  • Haha
Reactions: charliem24
I know judge helped the team big time to get them to the playoffs but man he’s been a complete zero post season. Anybody have any reason why? Is he trying too hard, is it fatigue, too much pressure on himself?
 
When Mattingly was healthy he had Stan Musial’s swing.
There was nothing you could throw him

Funny you should say that. After my father's first stroke, and the short term memory problems it created (a few years older than your father), watching him bat I put Mattingly into context for him by making the comparison to Musial.
 
Not good. Seriously? They aren't equal to the Dodgers but they did make it to the World Series. You have to be good to be a League Champion!

They’ve had a few guys completely carry them. That’s not a great definition of a good time.
 
I know judge helped the team big time to get them to the playoffs but man he’s been a complete zero post season. Anybody have any reason why? Is he trying too hard, is it fatigue, too much pressure on himself?

Some people just wilt when the pressure is too tough. Some people just have “it”…

Judge doesn’t seem like he has “it”
 
They’ve had a few guys completely carry them. That’s not a great definition of a good time.
Stupid take. You're are not very knowledgeable about baseball. A guy or a few can carry you for awhile but it still takes a full team to get to the World Series. As I said before nobody in the playoffs didn't had holes. The difference is Freddie Freeman can actually play mostly pain free for this series and is making up for lost time for the previous playoffs rounds. Yankees and Dodgers has the best records on baseball. They both belong here. Dodgers are simply better in players and coaching.
 
Rizzo can’t move at first. Some of these balls hit down the line should be outs.
 
Yanks are desperately trying to blow this lead. It's like they are getting paid based on who can screw up the most.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT