ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Electric vehicles

The biggest misconception is that every EV needs to charge every night. Do you fill up everyday? I charge once a week and the battery is only at 40%. My charging time is about 4 to 5 hrs and the app tells me it stop charging.

How often/ far do you drive per week?
 
I had an older generation MR2 and loved it. Only had maybe 98 HP, so it wasn't exactly fast and at the top end, the wind stalled it out at about 120mph (actually got pulled over by the PA state police going 120, no ticket, but that's a story for another day). The fun part about MR2s is the nimble, neutral handling due to the mid-engine layout. The flip side being it was incredibly easy to spin it in wet weather (which was fun when intentional and scary when not).

As for the strong acceleration performance of many EVs, I think it's a potential problem giving ordinary drivers so much instant torque. It's not so much that the human body and mind can't handle it - we've been doing it for decades. It's that not all humans are equally capable of handling it and some clearly cannot.

There's a reason why so many new sports car owners wind up in YouTube videos wrapping their new cars around trees or crashing into a row of cars. People go from cars with normal acceleration capability to cars that can hit 60 mph around 3s and they aren't ready for it. And those are cars designed with a lot of mechanical and aerodynamic grip so as to make it safer to deal with the extreme forces involved in rapid acceleration or high-speeds.

Nowadays, ordinary EV sedans have all this torque and are not typically designed with a ton of mechanical grip or downforce. Nor are they equipped with tires designed to help with high-performance driving. We're sticking a bunch of ordinary and inexperienced (performance-driving-wise) drivers into a car capable of extreme straight-line performance. I think, as EV adoption continues to accelerate (no pun intended), that may become a more prevalent problem.

The good thing is that the cars are getting better at keeping us on the asphalt.

I once drove a 5th gen Mustang GT 350 that tried really, really hard to kill me. My BIL's new(ish) DB11 is remarkably well-composed by comparison - and the Aston isn't particularly well known for its handling.

I really want to get my hands on Cayman. Everything I know about it suggests that it's a desirable car to drive.

On a different note, I'm growing fonder of the Macan. I was chatting some woman in the ShopRite parking lot on Christmas Eve and she was raving about hers.
 
Don’t you use your primary car to bounce around town? Agree that it’s hard as the only car. I still need an ICE.
What I meant was I would always have a gas powered car also and not depend on an EV car
for serious driving
 
The extreme cold weather is exposing some downside of EVs. Overall, not a good look for EVs.


That first link is from the F150 Lightning foums. Unless I misread it, the problem is not with the EVs but with an equipment malfunction in EA s charging station. It's not a problem with the EV per se, but certainly impacts the driving experience. From what I have Seen EA is a pretty shoddy company.
 
That first link is from the F150 Lightning foums. Unless I misread it, the problem is not with the EVs but with an equipment malfunction in EA s charging station. It's not a problem with the EV per se, but certainly impacts the driving experience. From what I have Seen EA is a pretty shoddy company.
I have read bad things about EA but my personal experience has been good. Again, most of this doesn’t apply to majority of the EV owners. No one is really going out in the conditions they are testing in. But it’s good clickbait and not a good look for EV.
 
I have read bad things about EA but my personal experience has been good. Again, most of this doesn’t apply to majority of the EV owners. No one is really going out in the conditions they are testing in. But it’s good clickbait and not a good look for EV.
Not a good look for EV, or for the authors and publishers of these ridiculous articles? Dirty Harry's saying that "A man has to know his limitations" applies to EVs. Don't buy one if you live in an extremely cold climate or an apartment building or condo where at home charging is not possible. Also, if you need to tow heavy loads long distances, don't buy one. For every day truck guys like you and me who do homeowner truck things and use it to go back and forth to Home Depot and the recycling center, they are an attractive alternative to ICE vehicles.
 
The good thing is that the cars are getting better at keeping us on the asphalt.

I once drove a 5th gen Mustang GT 350 that tried really, really hard to kill me. My BIL's new(ish) DB11 is remarkably well-composed by comparison - and the Aston isn't particularly well known for its handling.

I really want to get my hands on Cayman. Everything I know about it suggests that it's a desirable car to drive.

On a different note, I'm growing fonder of the Macan. I was chatting some woman in the ShopRite parking lot on Christmas Eve and she was raving about hers.
Is very true that all new cars, even minivans or trucks, handle way better and have way smarter ECU-based nannies than ever. And tire tech has improved a bunch too. So yeah, no argument about how cars are better than ever at keeping us on the pavement and upright.

But that’s part of the problem, IMO. Cars do a good job of getting drivers closer to the limit than ever today but there’s a point at which even the most sophisticated traction control systems are insufficient to the task and, unlike in the past with most ordinary cars, the breakaway point can occur with lots less warning.

Instead of communicating mild understeer or oversteer in cornering, or wheel slip in acceleration, to drivers that they feel and have time to respond to, the car manages the responses itself and the driver is unaware of the looming danger right up until physics asserts itself in a way that overwhelms the traction control system.

Combine all that with how quick cars and even some SUVs are these days, and with how drivers are coming from a Camry or Accord and don’t have the experience you got in the GT 350 (and elsewhere), and I‘m just saying bad things can happen.

I’m still high on the Macan, been doing builds of the Macan GTS in the configurator. But still not seeing any easing of pricing. Hoping that rising interest rates dent demand some. But one serious negative, for me, is that the back seat is really tight. Not great for road-trips for more than two adults, unless some of the adults are pretty small.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU4Real
Harsh but it needed saying…. Elon either needs to grow up or step aside. I think he ought to step aside and focus on philanthropy. It’d be good for his soul where being a billionaire CEO clearly isn’t.

 
If they were to cut the price of a 3 to something under 30k, I'd snap one up. That's about equilibrium, for me.
I was between a mx-5 or a ID4 for my daughter. At 40k with 7500 tax credit, it was “close enough” to go with the ID4. I think I’m ahead because of resale and gas savings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift
If they were to cut the price of a 3 to something under 30k, I'd snap one up. That's about equilibrium, for me.
I wouldn’t be surprised if it happens. I have no clue what’s gonna happen with the economy in 2023 and it seems like nobody else does either. So I keep waiting on the car buying. Impatiently.
 
I wouldn’t be surprised if it happens. I have no clue what’s gonna happen with the economy in 2023 and it seems like nobody else does either. So I keep waiting on the car buying. Impatiently.
Highly unlikely. What they should do is offer a shorter range model 3 at that pricing. VW is doing that with the ID4. It’s a 20% discount and 2/3 of the range of the standard model.
 
Highly unlikely. What they should do is offer a shorter range model 3 at that pricing. VW is doing that with the ID4. It’s a 20% discount and 2/3 of the range of the standard model.
We’ll see. If the economy really tanks, I think we’re gonna see a lot of price normalization, all the way up and down automotive supply chains. It’s totally nuts at the moment, even with interest rates being so high.

In mid-2020, I could’ve had a Macan GTS build allocation with 10% off MSRP. Today, I can’t find one at MSRP, dealers are marking them all up. Demand and supply.
 
We’ll see. If the economy really tanks, I think we’re gonna see a lot of price normalization, all the way up and down automotive supply chains. It’s totally nuts at the moment, even with interest rates being so high.

In mid-2020, I could’ve had a Macan GTS build allocation with 10% off MSRP. Today, I can’t find one at MSRP, dealers are marking them all up. Demand and supply.

We should both get a Macan GTS.

I will require a modest GoFundMe.
 
We should both get a Macan GTS.

I will require a modest GoFundMe.
Yeah, with even just a few of the more desirable options, the price climbs pretty quickly. MSRP of $115K for what I'd want. Here's a build close to what I'd probably get: http://www.porsche-code.com/PPKN3YN6.

The problem I have is that I could get a whole lot more SUV for that price (or less), with a lot more passenger and cargo space. And even more luxury. And it would be better in heavy snow.

Only thing I think I'd really miss was the great handling and handling isn't really why I'm in the market for an SUV in the first place. So... I dunno.

OTOH, if we both get one, we might be able to snag them at MSRP or, who knows, lower. I just checked online now some folks are reporting getting MSRP for stuff on lots on base Macans, so perhaps a small discount for GTS's isn't out of the realm of possibility already.

Actually, if we both get Macans and I plunk down a deposit on a GT3 build allocation, that might produce sub-MSRP on the Macans and some reasonable amount over for the GT3.

Anybody else interested? Group buy? Anyone? Bueller? Supposed to see an EV Macan sometime in 2023, I think if that helps with the decision.
 
Yeah, with even just a few of the more desirable options, the price climbs pretty quickly. MSRP of $115K for what I'd want. Here's a build close to what I'd probably get: http://www.porsche-code.com/PPKN3YN6.

The problem I have is that I could get a whole lot more SUV for that price (or less), with a lot more passenger and cargo space. And even more luxury. And it would be better in heavy snow.

Only thing I think I'd really miss was the great handling and handling isn't really why I'm in the market for an SUV in the first place. So... I dunno.

OTOH, if we both get one, we might be able to snag them at MSRP or, who knows, lower. I just checked online now some folks are reporting getting MSRP for stuff on lots on base Macans, so perhaps a small discount for GTS's isn't out of the realm of possibility already.

Actually, if we both get Macans and I plunk down a deposit on a GT3 build allocation, that might produce sub-MSRP on the Macans and some reasonable amount over for the GT3.

Anybody else interested? Group buy? Anyone? Bueller? Supposed to see an EV Macan sometime in 2023, I think if that helps with the decision.

They're insane with their options. I forced myself to be frugal and just configured a Macan S up to almost 85k.
 
Saw a suv drag race on YouTube and the Porsche Cayenne turbo GT did 0-60 in 2.8 secs. That’s just stupid fast for a suv.
I got to track several different Cayenne models up at Monticello Race Club in NYS a couple/few years back. The Cayenne Turbo GT wasn't out yet, but there was a Cayenne Turbo with all the performance/suspension options and it was pretty mind-blowing how something so big and heavy could lap so fast.

Was drizzling most of the day which made the cornering speeds even more mind-blowing - took me a while to work up the nerve to start really pushing and even then I probably only got to 5/10ths. In the dry, I figure I might've gotten to 7/10ths maybe. It just felt too physics defying, compared to low, light, sports cars.

I had one butt-puckering moment where I'd gone from lapping the loaded Cayenne Turbo to lapping a Cayenne S w/no upgraded suspension options. Big huge downgrade in handling capability.

But I wasn't paying enough attention and still had the Turbo's awesome handling on my brain and took it into the fastest corner, a high-speed sweeper, much too fast. Felt the weight shift and immediately realized my mistake in a big "oh shit" moment. I had maybe an inch or so of wheel hanging off the track on the grass on the exit of the turn, trying to use the whole track to bleed off speed while staying off the brake and on throttle to keep it from spinning off into the fencing.

It was a very, very close thing.
 
They're insane with their options. I forced myself to be frugal and just configured a Macan S up to almost 85k.
I'm pretty sure they keep psychologists on the payroll to assist in the design of the configurator and how they present all the options. Those f-ers.

For instance, If I do wind up getting a Macan, I'll want it to be color-matched w/my current car. And, of course, that color, available for under $1000 on my car, is only available in the Macan GTS as an $11,400 option. WTF?

Just thinking about this, about how mess with our heads this way, pisses me off. Makes me think of this scene:

NSFW

 
Positive Lightning towing reviews. Haters will hate, however. A man has to know his limitations and his EV's limitations too, just like Dirty Harry said:

 
My favorite quote from the article: "Talking about the 911, it will be the model which we will drive as long as we can with a combustion engine.’"

No idea how long that might be. But, as someone whose interest with 911s started at 10 years old, it warms my heart to hear. I can totally embrace a hybrid 911 and they are coming soon enough. But fully remove the combustion engine from a 911 and it's just not a 911 anymore - it'll become just another fast car, which is a little boring to me.

Maybe the e-fuel will preserve it. Maybe not. But it's worth the try, IMO.
 
My favorite quote from the article: "Talking about the 911, it will be the model which we will drive as long as we can with a combustion engine.’"

No idea how long that might be. But, as someone whose interest with 911s started at 10 years old, it warms my heart to hear. I can totally embrace a hybrid 911 and they are coming soon enough. But fully remove the combustion engine from a 911 and it's just not a 911 anymore - it'll become just another fast car, which is a little boring to me.

Maybe the e-fuel will preserve it. Maybe not. But it's worth the try, IMO.
that's what everyone says about their favorite motors. water cooled vs air cooled 911, a supra without a toyota I-6, a 4 cylinder 328, a 6 cyl instead of a hemi in the dodge muscle cars. shouldn't you trust porsche to build a new-age 911 to drive as well as a traditional ICE one?
 
that's what everyone says about their favorite motors. water cooled vs air cooled 911, a supra without a toyota I-6, a 4 cylinder 328, a 6 cyl instead of a hemi in the dodge muscle cars. shouldn't you trust porsche to build a new-age 911 to drive as well as a traditional ICE one?

I don't know, people are still bitching about the 4 cylinder 718s (Boxter / Cayman). They're quicker, but don't sound like the flat 6. This offends some folks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mildone
that's what everyone says about their favorite motors. water cooled vs air cooled 911, a supra without a toyota I-6, a 4 cylinder 328, a 6 cyl instead of a hemi in the dodge muscle cars. shouldn't you trust porsche to build a new-age 911 to drive as well as a traditional ICE one?
I don’t trust anybody to build an EV sports car that will remain engaging to me. Is partly why I have zero interest in a Taycan. I know Porsche will weave its driver-centric magic on all these cars. They’ve got the formula down to a science.

But some critical elements of that, for me, are the sounds and lightness and gearboxes (even with PDK-equipped models).

Hell, in the 911, even driving with a passenger or full tank of gas cuts way down on the thrill due to the handling impact of the added weight. The most fun is found when the tank is near empty. Even all wheel drive interferes with my desired sense of engagement. If my front tire pressures aren’t perfect, it‘ll ruin the experience.

I’m not trying to make a general statement about this stuff for others. I’m sure a Rimac Nevera is wildly exciting to drive. Everybody is different. I’m just stating what I’ve found engages me, individually, over a sustained period of ownership.

I’m a little obsessive, a little nuts, about it, I realize.
 
I don’t trust anybody to build an EV sports car that will remain engaging to me. Is partly why I have zero interest in a Taycan. I know Porsche will weave its driver-centric magic on all these cars. They’ve got the formula down to a science.

But some critical elements of that, for me, are the sounds and lightness and gearboxes (even with PDK-equipped models).

Hell, in the 911, even driving with a passenger or full tank of gas cuts way down on the thrill due to the handling impact of the added weight. The most fun is found when the tank is near empty. Even all wheel drive interferes with my desired sense of engagement. If my front tire pressures aren’t perfect, it‘ll ruin the experience.

I’m not trying to make a general statement about this stuff for others. I’m sure a Rimac Nevera is wildly exciting to drive. Everybody is different. I’m just stating what I’ve found engages me, individually, over a sustained period of ownership.

I’m a little obsessive, a little nuts, about it, I realize.
only a little?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: mildone
I don't know, people are still bitching about the 4 cylinder 718s (Boxter / Cayman). They're quicker, but don't sound like the flat 6. This offends some folks.
Me being one of them. Not that they aren’t awesome, they are. But the latest GTS, GT4, and GT4RS‘s, with their 911-sourced flat 6 engines, are magical by all accounts, and the sounds and naturally aspirated torque curves are a big part of that.

Would an all electric Miata be as engaging and as loved as the current ones? Maybe, we’ll find out I guess.

But at the moment, that’s what’s so great about having options. And I hope we find a clean technological way to keep some of those choices alive.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT