This is where you are totally clueless! This was not two guys horsing around. This was an under the breath mean spirited comment about Kaminsky not to Kaminsky, that was caught on a mic. It is a story and one he had to apologize for.Originally posted by IL Lusciato:
Some of you guys seriously destroy your credibility when you try these arguments that are so devoid of context and reality that its pathetic.
A white player saying "f*ck that n*gger" is so so much different than a black player saying what he did. If you can't see that, you should straight up stop participating in civil society BC you need an education on sociology among other things.
This is a non-story.
If I talk to my Italian friend (I'm also half Italian) and I say "I figured you'd love this place ya guinea bastard haha, its got great sauce"
is that the same as if I walk passed a Mexican restaurant and remark "bunch of f'n sp*cs"?? NO.
Hell its even dumber than that. Its like me calling a black guy a " guinea" makes no sense.
I personally think all this race and "homophobic" "slur" crap is blown way out of proportion by the media, unless accompanied by an act of discrimination, or made by a person in the public trust, ts all nonsense. People can say what they want.
But to pretend as if "f that n" is not part of a normal lexicon, but was a "racial" slur is just dumb as hell.
For the record I feel the same about "fag". If some kids are on the ball court and a straight dude says to a straight dude " you suck fag" I don't care at all. I could not be less concerned. (Althogh this garbage media is)
BUT if a straight guy walks up to a gay coworker and says "stop talking that way you f'n f*ggot" that's a problem
This is basic common sense. Try and use it.
Not sure who this is directed to, but I never said they are the same, and I never said Harrison used it as "a racial slur."Originally posted by IL Lusciato:
Some of you guys seriously destroy your credibility when you try these arguments that are so devoid of context and reality that its pathetic.
A white player saying "f*ck that n*gger" is so so much different than a black player saying what he did. If you can't see that, you should straight up stop participating in civil society BC you need an education on sociology among other things.
This is a non-story.
If I talk to my Italian friend (I'm also half Italian) and I say "I figured you'd love this place ya guinea bastard haha, its got great sauce"
is that the same as if I walk passed a Mexican restaurant and remark "bunch of f'n sp*cs"?? NO.
Hell its even dumber than that. Its like me calling a black guy a " guinea" makes no sense.
I personally think all this race and "homophobic" "slur" crap is blown way out of proportion by the media, unless accompanied by an act of discrimination, or made by a person in the public trust, ts all nonsense. People can say what they want.
But to pretend as if "f that n" is not part of a normal lexicon, but was a "racial" slur is just dumb as hell.
For the record I feel the same about "fag". If some kids are on the ball court and a straight dude says to a straight dude " you suck fag" I don't care at all. I could not be less concerned. (Althogh this garbage media is)
BUT if a straight guy walks up to a gay coworker and says "stop talking that way you f'n f*ggot" that's a problem
This is basic common sense. Try and use it.
Well said. To not understand the historical context of the discussion is simply ignorant. Sure, he should not have said it - it was dumb and mean-spirited, but we're only 50 years removed from "separate but equal" and still have a long way to go before race doesn't matter any more (despite things being way better than 50 years ago - we're not there yet).Originally posted by IL Lusciato:
Some of you guys seriously destroy your credibility when you try these arguments that are so devoid of context and reality that its pathetic.
A white player saying "f*ck that n*gger" is so so much different than a black player saying what he did. If you can't see that, you should straight up stop participating in civil society BC you need an education on sociology among other things.
This is a non-story.
If I talk to my Italian friend (I'm also half Italian) and I say "I figured you'd love this place ya guinea bastard haha, its got great sauce"
is that the same as if I walk passed a Mexican restaurant and remark "bunch of f'n sp*cs"?? NO.
Hell its even dumber than that. Its like me calling a black guy a " guinea" makes no sense.
I personally think all this race and "homophobic" "slur" crap is blown way out of proportion by the media, unless accompanied by an act of discrimination, or made by a person in the public trust, ts all nonsense. People can say what they want.
But to pretend as if "f that n" is not part of a normal lexicon, but was a "racial" slur is just dumb as hell.
For the record I feel the same about "fag". If some kids are on the ball court and a straight dude says to a straight dude " you suck fag" I don't care at all. I could not be less concerned. (Althogh this garbage media is)
BUT if a straight guy walks up to a gay coworker and says "stop talking that way you f'n f*ggot" that's a problem
This is basic common sense. Try and use it.
Can you please explain the double standard.Originally posted by bac2therac:
Lots of excuse making for a double standard
Couldn't agree more. The fact people don't see this is crazy. HUGE story if white person uses it...ehh, not huge deal if black person uses the word...that is a double standard.Originally posted by bac2therac:
He was denigrating Kaminsky...if kaminsky chose to denigrate him by using that word the world would be up in arms.....you people are too caught up in the idea that its ok for blacks to use it...Harrison used the word with the intent to denigrate.. thats the key here
What do you want to happen to Harrison? I don't know anyone who thinks what Harrison did is ok. He apologized and Frank accepted? Remember when Riley Cooper got caught with the same word? Didn't he get to go back to work and not miss any playing time?Originally posted by bac2therac:
He was denigrating Kaminsky...if kaminsky chose to denigrate him by using that word the world would be up in arms.....you people are too caught up in the idea that its ok for blacks to use it...Harrison used the word with the intent to denigrate.. thats the key here
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
If a white person said it to a white person..would you say its racist? Can a white person use the word and not be "racist"?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
However, no one thinks he was trying to be racist when he said it, insulting, yes, but not racist.
Why is this so hard to understand for some folks here?
I am starting to sound like a broken record....
sure, if a white person called another white person the N word, it would not be considered racist. Stupid yes, racist, no.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
If a white person said it to a white person..would you say its racist? Can a white person use the word and not be "racist"?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
However, no one thinks he was trying to be racist when he said it, insulting, yes, but not racist.
Why is this so hard to understand for some folks here?
I am starting to sound like a broken record....
I'm pretty sure people would call him a racist. The comment itself wouldn't be racist..but a white guy using the word is racist to alot of people.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
sure, if a white person called another white person the N word, it would not be considered racist. Stupid yes, racist, no.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
If a white person said it to a white person..would you say its racist? Can a white person use the word and not be "racist"?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
However, no one thinks he was trying to be racist when he said it, insulting, yes, but not racist.
Why is this so hard to understand for some folks here?
I am starting to sound like a broken record....
Knee jerk reaction maybe, but once people realized it was two white people taking to each other about each other, it would just die down quickly. In hip hop culture, it happens all of the time and not considered a big deal. I have heard Asians, Latinos, and Indians use it to describe all kinds of people.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
I'm pretty sure people would call him a racist. The comment itself wouldn't be racist..but a white guy using the word is racist to alot of people.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
sure, if a white person called another white person the N word, it would not be considered racist. Stupid yes, racist, no.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
If a white person said it to a white person..would you say its racist? Can a white person use the word and not be "racist"?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
However, no one thinks he was trying to be racist when he said it, insulting, yes, but not racist.
Why is this so hard to understand for some folks here?
I am starting to sound like a broken record....
That we can agree on. Either no one should be allowed to use it, or we all should be allowed to use it without repercussions.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
Knee jerk reaction maybe, but once people realized it was two white people taking to each other about each other, it would just die down quickly. In hip hop culture, it happens all of the time and not considered a big deal. I have heard Asians, Latinos, and Indians use it to describe all kinds of people.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
I'm pretty sure people would call him a racist. The comment itself wouldn't be racist..but a white guy using the word is racist to alot of people.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
sure, if a white person called another white person the N word, it would not be considered racist. Stupid yes, racist, no.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
If a white person said it to a white person..would you say its racist? Can a white person use the word and not be "racist"?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is NOT ok, that is why he apologized.Originally posted by Spare130:
As others have already stated in the thread... Its ok coming from Harrison but not if Kaminksky said it about Harrison.
The biggest problem I have with this is the fact that a scrub like Stephen A Smith always plays the race card on every single topic, but quickly dismissed this as a non issue because Harrison apologized. If Kaminsky used that word and then apologized would it be ok?
However, no one thinks he was trying to be racist when he said it, insulting, yes, but not racist.
Why is this so hard to understand for some folks here?
I am starting to sound like a broken record....
I don't like the word, and I wish it was never used by anyone, but it is what it is. Just use common sense.
honkey is not very offensive, how about gringo or giajin? (try going to Japan if you don't know what "giajin" means :) )Originally posted by hinson32:
It was a black person calling a white person the N word.
For it to equal Kaminsky would have had to call Harrison a Honkey.
Exactly - it completely boggles my mind that people think the situations would be identical if Kaminsy said the same thing about Harrison, and that there is some "double standard" in place - as you said, the n-word is, by definition a word used by whites for centuries to denigrate and dehumanize blacks. Way too many people around here conflate dislike with racism. I'm sure there are plenty of black folks who dislike white folks for the role whites played over hundreds of years in slavery, then segregation and most recently in simply denying full rights and opportunities to blacks.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
Can you please explain the double standard.Originally posted by bac2therac:
Lots of excuse making for a double standard
It has been stated time and time again that is it an insult no matter who says it and no matter who it is being said to.
Also, it is common sense that it could only be taken as a racist if someone says it to or a referring to a black person since it is a racist slur towards black people.
So, once again, where is the double standard?
Totally agree. However there's a significant percentage of the population that thinks only White folks can be racist. That is the double standard to which I am referring.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
I understand there's some racist people..and I've been paying attention to what's going on. But when you allow one person to say F that N...and if another person says it and its not allowable..thats a double standard, no? I'm a white person, so I have no idea the impact of the word..But if it is so offensive, no one should be allowed to say it. That's all i'm arguing.Originally posted by RUScrew85:
Double standard? Maybe you haven't been paying attention to this Race Thing going on.Originally posted by mikemarc1:
Then your saying if Kaminsky said that about Harrison, you wouldn't have a problem? You'd attribute it to him giving Harrison a compliment?Originally posted by RUMountie:
Yes, now you've got it. Do you listen to much of the current music that kids listen to? Do you spend much time around kids?Originally posted by mikemarc1:
Wow. So now calling someone the n-word is a compliment?!?!?!?! Ridiculous.Originally posted by RUMountie:
This might be news to some of you but Harrison's comment might have been a compliment and there
are some white folks (especially high level basketball players who are white) who would take a comment like that as a compliment of the highest order. I didn't see Harrison say what he said and I don't know the nature of his relationship with Kaminsky so it is hard to know how it was meant (certainily could have been a straight out racist insult in a weird kinda way). It's not so simple to classify Harrison's comments as mean spirited and racist the way we would if the situation was reversed, epecially with this younger generation's experience of the N word as compared to us older folks (I am about 50).
If Kaminsky takes that as a compliment, and Harrison meant it as a compliment, then that words going to be used much, much more by white kids..
Children today generally have not seen or had the experiences with the N word that many older folks have had so they
don't attach the evil meanings to it. Many see it as a term of endearment.
Either way, there would be a HUGE uproar over it..and shouldn't be a double standard is all I'm saying.
That's some mighty fine hair splitting there, my ni$$a.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
Ok, so you still don't get it.Originally posted by WhiteBus:
A word that is ok to be used by only one race but is deemed derogatory by those same people who use it when it is used by everyone else is racist. I understand the culture today but not all people are comfortable with the word no matter who uses. The NAACP went out of their way to "bury" the term in 2007 but failed.Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
It is not a racial slur when used against non-blacks, but it is still an insult. That is why he apologize. It is NOT OK for him to say that, but it still doesn't make it racist.Originally posted by WhiteBus:
Huh what?? Difference. So it's ok to say "Fu#k that Ni$$a" ?? If your one color talking about another it's ok but not ok if the role was reversed?Originally posted by Scarlet_Scourge:
If someone can't tell the difference then they have some serious issues.
It shouldn't be that difficult.
If there is a difference than why did Harrison apologize? He knew it was a racial slur and he knew he was wrong.
I hope you understand what I meant now.
Let me try again..
It is an INSULT no matter who uses it when used in that matter against ANYONE.
However, it is only considered a racial slur when used against black people.
I hope that makes it clearer.
Reality isn't I L's strong suit.Originally posted by WhiteBus:
This is where you are totally clueless! This was not two guys horsing around. This was an under the breath mean spirited comment about Kaminsky not to Kaminsky, that was caught on a mic. It is a story and one he had to apologize for.Originally posted by IL Lusciato:
Some of you guys seriously destroy your credibility when you try these arguments that are so devoid of context and reality that its pathetic.
A white player saying "f*ck that n*gger" is so so much different than a black player saying what he did. If you can't see that, you should straight up stop participating in civil society BC you need an education on sociology among other things.
This is a non-story.
If I talk to my Italian friend (I'm also half Italian) and I say "I figured you'd love this place ya guinea bastard haha, its got great sauce"
is that the same as if I walk passed a Mexican restaurant and remark "bunch of f'n sp*cs"?? NO.
Hell its even dumber than that. Its like me calling a black guy a " guinea" makes no sense.
I personally think all this race and "homophobic" "slur" crap is blown way out of proportion by the media, unless accompanied by an act of discrimination, or made by a person in the public trust, ts all nonsense. People can say what they want.
But to pretend as if "f that n" is not part of a normal lexicon, but was a "racial" slur is just dumb as hell.
For the record I feel the same about "fag". If some kids are on the ball court and a straight dude says to a straight dude " you suck fag" I don't care at all. I could not be less concerned. (Althogh this garbage media is)
BUT if a straight guy walks up to a gay coworker and says "stop talking that way you f'n f*ggot" that's a problem
This is basic common sense. Try and use it.
Watch the video and you'll see that your analogy has zero common sense.
ATTENTION: *** racist alert *** racist alert **** racist alert ***Originally posted by RUnumber1:
Oh Good God!!! Blacks will always want to be victims What more do you want? You are all equal and in some case more than equal to whites. We even have a God Damn black president for Christ shake!!! What more do you want??!! My family was not here in America when slavery was here. My family had no part in slavery. Besides, black were not the only slaves in the world. There were many other races who were slaves at one time in history. The blacks are the only cry babies about what their ancient ancestries may have experienced. Not them personall. Blacks sold other blacks into slavery. This is really getting old. I am really getting sick and tired of every white person in America being blamed for slavery, real or imagined. Grow up!! Put on your big boy pants sand MOVE ON!!!!
Go up to a random black guy on the street and say "Hello my Nigga." and post what happens. Honestly.Originally posted by RutgersROB:
Riley Cooper did not use the same word !!!!! Clearly he said ER which is a racial slur....n*gga is not
Posted from Rivals Mobile
Well that is not true, anyone can be racist.Totally agree. However there's a significant percentage of the population that thinks only White folks can be racist. That is the double standard to which I am referring.